• Critics’ Pick
  • Primeburger

  • Hamburgers American Traditional Diner $4.25-$12
  • 5 E. 51st St.
    New York, NY 10022
  • Neighborhood: Midtown East
  • Phone: 212-759-4729
Primeburger Photo
6
This venue is closed. Until time travel becomes feasible, there’s always the Primeburger, an authentic diner that’s frozen in 1965. Everything is unchanged, from the faux-dark-wood paneling to the terrazzo floors and once-futuristic conical lighting fixtures. There are 24 individual box seats with swing-out trays that look like they came from an ancient amusement-park ride. Even the menu is old and predictably dependable: It’s all burgers, classic sandwiches, and a few fried dishes, like chicken-in-a-basket. Most of the fare is ordinary, but the honest, handcrafted burgers have been keeping people coming back, literally, for generations. The modestly sized quarter-pounders are made from freshly ground lean chuck; they’re moist and tasty but do not require a three-napkin cleanup job. The fries are hot and crisp, but the French-fried onions (not rings) are superior. It’s the cracker-meal dusting prior to frying that makes them unusually crunchy. For desserts you can choose among exceptionally flaky pies made daily in house by Ed Adams, a 60-year baking veteran. The apple and cherry versions are expertly balanced between sweet and sour; they’re best à la mode. Situated across the street from St. Patrick’s Cathedral, the Primeburger gets especially crowded during the holidays. After all, it’s a pilgrimage site.
http://primeburger.com
  • Hours

    Mon-Fri, 7am-7pm Sat, 7am-5pm Sun, closed

  • Prices

    $4.25-$12

  • Payment

    Discover MasterCard Visa

  • Special Features

    Delivery Lunch Breakfast Take-Out Online Ordering Good for Groups Great Desserts Kid-Friendly Private Dining/Party Space Classic NY

  • Alcohol

    No Alcohol

  • Reservations

    Not Accepted

  • Delivery Area

    44th St. to 54th St., Third Ave. to Broadway

Avg. Rating 0

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • E-mail
  • Save to foursquare
See the Full NYMag Site »