New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > The Water Club

The Water Club Menu

lunch

appetizer
All American Cheeseburger Slider       ea 5
Classic Lobster Bisque       11
Yellowfin Tuna Tartare pickled mango, whipped avocado, barbecue potato chips       18
Maryland Lump & Peekytoe Crab Cake celery root coleslaw       17
Broiled Littleneck Clams white wine, fava beans, toasted bread crumbs       14
Montauk Calamari Grilled or Fried horseradish cocktail sauce       15
House Smoked Salmon brioche toast, crème fraiche, capers, egg, red onion, chives       13
chilled shellfish
All Served With Lemon & Cocktail Sauce
East & West Coast Oysters market selection, on the half shell. available by the 1/2 dozen or dozen       ea 2.50
North Fork Littleneck Clams       ea 2
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail       17
Grand Plateau 6 east & 6 west coast oysters, 4 shrimp, 4 littlenecks, mussels & chilled lobster salad       70
the lobster lunch $40
Classic Lobster Bisque      
1.25Lb Whole Lobster mashed potatoes o’keeffe      
Key Lime pie, sorbet, or Ice Cream brooklyn ice cream factory      
shuckers lunch $20
Six Assorted Oysters      
Cup of Soup or Lobster Bisque      
Six Leaf Salad      
salad
Vine Ripe Tomatoes buffalo mozzarella, pesto flatbread       15
Six Leaf & Shaved Vegetable Salad red wine & shallot vinaigrette       9
Boston Wedge pancetta, creamy buttermilk dressing       11
Tuna Niçoise chopped greens with blackened tuna, cherry tomatoes, balsamic vinaigrette       17
Crab Cake Salad mixed greens, balsamic vinaigrette       18
new england style rolls
Served With French fries, Coleslaw & House Made Pickles
Lobster Salad       26
Crispy Oysters       23
Golden Ipswich Clam Bellies       20
entree
Maine Lobster steamed or broiled, deshelled tableside      
Olive Oil Poached Salmon tricolor lentils, sel de mer       31
Soft Wild Mushroom Omelette gruyere cheese, roasted fingerlings & baby spinach salad       16
Chicken Milanese lightly dressed arugula, grilled lemon       19
Vegetable Gateau zucchini, summer squash, roasted peppers, eggplant & mozzarella beignets       18
Sirloin Steak Frites choice of bernaise or bordelaise sauce       27
The Water Club Burger choice of cheese, served with salad or french fries       15
Seared Tuna Burger diced tuna, sesame seeds, ginger, wasabi, whipped avocado aioli       19
sides $7
Broiled Cauliflower sharp cheddar cheese      
Lightly Toasted Mushrooms      
Glazed Carrots      
Creamed Spinach      
Sautéed Baby Spinach      
Mashed Potatoes O’keeffe      
French Fries      
Baked Idaho Potato or Sweet Potato      
Lentils & Quinoa Crushed Almonds      
Pommes Lyonnaise      

dinner

appetizer
All American Cheeseburger Slider       ea 5
Yellowfin Tuna Tartare pickled mango, whipped avocado, barbecue potato chips       18
Maryland Lump & Peekytoe Crab Cake celery root coleslaw       17
House Smoked Salmon brioche toast, crème fraiche, capers, egg, red onion, chives       13
Broiled Littleneck Clams white wine, fava beans, toasted bread crumbs       14
Montauk Calamari Grilled or Fried horseradish cocktail sauce       15
Oysters Rockefeller pernod, chopped spinach, bacon       17
Golden Ipswich Clam Bellies traditional cocktail sauce       17
American Sturgeon Caviar crème fraiche, potato skins       15
Classic Lobster Bisque       11
chilled shellfish
All Served With Lemon & Cocktail Sauce
East & West Coast Oysters market selection, on the half shell. available by the 1/2 dozen or dozen       ea 2.50
North Fork Littleneck Clams       ea 2
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail       17
Grand Plateau 6 east & 6 west coast oysters, 4 shrimp, 4 littlenecks, mussels & chilled lobster salad       70
salad
Vine Ripe Tomatoes buffalo mozzarella, pesto flatbread       15
Grilled Green Bean Salad sliced tangelo, farmer’s cheese, toasted pine nuts       11
Six Leaf & Shaved Vegetable Salad red wine & shallot vinaigrette       9
Boston Wedge pancetta, creamy buttermilk dressing       11
Chilled Beach Salad octopus, calamari, shrimp & lump crab, avocado, cracked olive vinaigrette       16
entrée
Maine Lobster steamed or broiled, deshelled tableside, stuffed with lump crab       10
Whole Roasted Rainbow Trout served head-on, roasted yukon potatoes, toasted almonds       28
Olive Oil Poached Salmon tricolor lentils, sel de mer       31
Porcini Crusted Tuna chive orecchiette, creamy morels       32
Old School Lobster Thermidor tender lobster, braised leeks & mushrooms, dry sherry sabayon       38
Whole Dover Sole meuniere sauce       65
Vegetable Gateau (v) zucchini, summer squash, roasted peppers, eggplant & mozzarella beignets       18
Double Cut Stuffed Pork Chop sopressata, almonds & dates       27
Crisp Skin Free Range Chicken wild summer fried rice, grilled onion rings, light bourbon gravy       29
Beef Wellington sweet baby carrots & onions       34
Colorado Lamb Chops cabernet lamb jus       47
charcoal grilled steaks
Choice of: Au jus, Béarnaise or Peppercorn With Brandy & Cream
New York Sirloin u.s.d.a. Prime       38
Filet Mignon       41
Petite Ladies Cut Filet       28
sides $7
Broiled Cauliflower sharp cheddar cheese      
Lightly Toasted Mushrooms      
Glazed Carrots      
Creamed Spinach      
Sautéed Baby Spinach      
Mashed Potatoes O’keeffe      
French Fries      
Baked Idaho Potato or Sweet Potato      
Lentils & Quinoa crushed almonds      
Pommes Lyonnaise      

brunch

You May Serve Yourself or Your Server Will Be Happy to Serve You

Adults       42
Children       37
Parties 8 and Over adults       47
Children       39
brunch selections
Assorted Seasonal Fruits      
Domestic & Imported Cheese      
Croissants      
Pain Au Chocolate      
Orange Cranberry Scones & Bagels      
Traditional Irish Soda Bread      
from our smokehouse
Applewood Smoked Norwegian Salmon      
Smoked Whitefish Salad      
Smoked trout, Vegetable Slaw & Horseradish Sauce      
Smoked pastrami, Marble Rye      
omelette
Prepared With Your Choice of
Country Ham      
Vermont Cheddar      
Sautéed Peppers      
Sautéed Mushrooms      
Tomatoes      
Caramelized Onions      
eggs benedict
Pecan Waffles fresh berries & whipped cream      
Griddle Pancakes buttermilk, blueberry or chocolate chip warm vermont maple syrup      
breakfast sides
Breakfast Sausage      
Applewood Smoked Bacon      
Home Fries      
Onion Hash Brown Potatoes      
chilled shellfish
Littleneck Clams on the Half Shell      
Fresh Shucked Oysters on the Half Shell shallot mignonette      
Lemon Poached Shrimp Cocktail      
salads
Six Leaf Salad lemon shallot vinaigrette      
Poached Chicken Salad apples, walnuts, honey, dill      
Orecchiette Pasta broccoli florets, fresh peas, ricotta salata      
Roasted Meats carved to order roasted sirloin with horseradish cream stuffed leg of lamb      
Seasonal Antipasto fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil marinated feta, olives grilled vegetables      
dessert
Crème Brûlée      
Carrot Cake      
The Water Club Cheesecake      
Key Lime Pie      
Chocolate Selections chocolate mousse, chocolate pot de crème, chocolate truffle cake, coconut devil’s food cake      
Fruit Selections port poached pear tart, lemon meringue tart, golden delicious apple pie, peach blueberry cobbler, passion fruit white chocolate mousse tart, chocolate dipped strawberries, raspberry mousse, mixed berry pudding with grand marnier berry compote,      
the water club’s signature bloody marys $12
Served At Brunch
Classic tomato, tabasco, horseradish      
Bloody Mariner clam juice      
Bloody Bull beef consommé      
Bloody Maru sake, lime juice      
dessert
Tuscan Toffee Parfait coffee & butter pecan ice cream, hot espresso syrup, peanut & macadamia brittle       11
The Water Club Cheesecake apricot sauce, pistachio gelato       11
Salted Caramel Chocolate Ganache Tart caramel hazelnuts & cashews, hazelnut gelato       11
Profiteroles vanilla ice cream, special hot fudge sauce       11
Molten Chocolate Cake coffee ice cream, hazelnut chocolate nib tuile       11
Classic Crème Brûlée classic crème brûlée       11
Our Strawberry Shortcake fresh baked biscuits       11
Rustic Apple Tart vanilla ice cream, vanilla bean caramel sauce       11
Chocolate Layer Cake fresh whipped cream, candied orange peel       11
Lemon Mousse Cake blueberry & candied lemon peel sorbet       11
Ice Cream or Sorbet a selection of ice cream from the brooklyn ice cream factory america’s finest ice cream       10
Graham’s 30 Years Old Tawny Port & Cheese Pairing in celebration of the water club’s 30th anniversary! paired with brebis d’ossau, a semi-firm and mildly sweet sheep’s milk cheese from the french pyrenées mountains       30
Tableside Preparation Bananas Foster bananas caramelized with rum and banana liqueur, served over vanilla ice cream       16

bar

pub menu
Maryland Crab Bites tartar sauce       13
Water Club Sashimi Roll tuna and salmon tartare, wasabi ponzu       15
Montauk Calamari Grilled or Fried old bay remoulade       12
Pizza Margherita pomodoro, fresh mozzarella, basil       10
Chips & Dips vegetable crudités, sour cream & chive       12
Classic Lobster Bisque       11
The Water Club Burger choice of cheese and salad or french fries       15
Cauliflower & Cheddar Skewers       7
Golden Clam Strips Basket       15
Hand Cut French Fries or Buttermilk Onion Rings       7
sliders $15
Choice of
Tuna & Avocado on Brioche      
Classic Cheeseburger      
chilled shellfish
Served With Lemon & Cocktail Sauce
East & West Coast Oysters market selection, on the half shell       ea 2.50
North Fork Littleneck Clams       ea 2
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail       17
Grand Plateau 6 east & 6 west coast oysters, 4 shrimp,4 littlenecks, chilled lobster salad & mussels       70
beer
Anchor Steam (u.s.) (draft)     half 5   full 7
Guinness Stout (ireland) (draft)     half 5.50   full 7.50
Blue Point Toasted Lager (u.s.)       6.50
Brooklyn Lager (u.s.)       6.50
Samuel Adams (u.s.)       6.50
Bass Ale (england)       6.50
Sierra Nevada Pale Ale (u.s.)       6.50
Chimay Cinq Cents (belgium)       9.50
Pilsner Urquell (czech republic)       6.50
Paulaner Hefe Weizen (germany)       (half lt) 9.50
Hoegaarden (belgium)       8
Beck’s Dark (germany)       6.50
Beck’s (germany)       6.50
Budweiser (u.s.)       6.50
Corona Extra (mexico)       6.50
Heineken (holland)       6.50
Stella Artois (belgium)       6.50
Spaten (germany)       6.50
Amstel Light (holland)       6.50
Heineken Light (holland)       6.50
Michelob Ultra (u.s.)       6.50
Coors Light (u.s.)       6.50
Miller Light (u.s.)       6.50
Kaliber (ireland) (non-alcoholic)       6.50

wines by the glass

champagne & sparkling
Domaine Saint-vincent Brut       9
Prosecco "rustico," Nino Franco       12
Heidsieck monopole, Brut N.v       16.50
white
Chardonnay, angeline, Santa Barbara/sonoma 2010       9
Sauvignon blanc, morgan, Monterey 2010       10
Sancerre, Domaine Pastou 2010       11
Pinot grigio, Maso poli, Trentino 2010       12
Riesling, Erdener Treppchen kabinett, meulenhof, Mosel 2011       12
Albariño, "mar de viñas," Adegas Gran vinum, Rías Baixas 2010       12
Chardonnay, neyers, Napa Valley 2010       15
rosé
Grenache rosé, Beckmen vineyards, Santa Ynez Valley 2010       10
red
Merlot, kenwood, California 2009       9
Cabernet sauvignon, L de lyeth, Sonoma County 2010       9
Pinot noir, ramsay, North Coast 2009       10
Malbec, zuccardi, "q," mendoza, Argentina 2010       12
Cabernet sauvignon, Heitz cellar, Napa Valley 2006       20
Advertising