![]() |
(Photo: David Lee/Courtesy of the Weinstein Company )
|
American Gangster
Strategy: Appeal to the masses. Of all the serious Oscar contenders, it’s the only one that’s made a box-office killing.Biggest Obstacle: Despite the knockout potential of its cast and director, critics didn’t like it nearly as much as Jay-Z did.
If We Were the Producers, We’d Push: Denzel Washington plays a flamboyant thug, and that’s netted him the Best Actor prize before.
Rash Predictions for Nominations:

Pic./Actor/Screenplay
…And Winners: None
Sweeney Todd
Strategy: Live up to the hype. It was touted, sight unseen, as one of the year’s best films. Reviews suggest that may actually be true.Biggest Obstacle: The movie’s copious bloodletting could turn off Academy voters, if not make them puke.
If We Were the Producers, We’d Push: Johnny Depp plays the film’s hero, villain, and victim—plus he can sing (sort of)! And he’s clearly due.
Rash Predictions for Nominations:
Actor/Supp. Actress
…And Winners: None
Charlie Wilson’s War
Strategy: Overcome the skeptics. Early word on this Tom Hanks–Julia Roberts comedy was lousy, but five Golden Globe noms can create buzz in a hurry.Biggest Obstacle: There’s still suspicion that despite its all-star cast, Charlie might be less than the sum of its parts.
If We Were the Producers, We’d Push: Philip Seymour Hoffman, whom even skeptical critics love in his supporting role as a zhlubby spook.
Rash Predictions for Nominations:
Supp. Actress/Supp. Actor/Screenplay
…And Winners: None
![]() |
(Photo: Courtesy of Warner Bros. Pictures)
|
Michael Clayton
Strategy: Brains over brawn. George Clooney’s legal thriller can make voters feel clever just for ticking it off on the ballot.Biggest Obstacle: Do you know anyone who loooooooves it? Neither do we.
If We Were the Producers, We’d Push: Tilda Swinton gives the performance of a lifetime; could a push get her past Supporting Actress favorite Amy Ryan (Gone Baby Gone)?
Rash Predictions for Nominations:
Pic./Dir./Supp. Actor/Supp. Actress/Screenplay
…And Winners: None
![]() |
(Photo: Courtesy of Twentieth Century Fox)
|
Juno
Strategy: Stress the positive. It’s the only major contender that doesn’t make you want to kill yourself.Biggest Obstacle: Will the Academy go for a teen comedy, no matter how artsy it is?
If We Were the Producers, We’d Push: Ellen Page is too young to beat Julie Christie (Away From Her) for Best Actress. Luckily, there’s stripper turned screenwriter Diablo Cody.
Rash Predictions for Nominations:

Pic./Actress/Screenplay
…And Winners:
Screenplay
![]() |
(Photo: Courtesy of Paramount Vantage)
|
There Will Be Blood
Strategy: Be relevant. It's about the intersection of single-minded capitalism and fundamentalism—sound familiar?Biggest Obstacle: Like Pedro Almodóvar and David Lynch before him, P.T. Anderson seems destined for a director nom—and a picture snub.
If We Were the Producers, We’d Push: Daniel Day-Lewis’s turn as the film’s misanthropic hero makes him the front-runner for Best Actor.
Rash Predictions for Nominations:
Dir./Actor/Supp. Actor/Screenplay
…And Winners:
Actor
No Country for Old Men
Strategy: Ride the wave. It’s the year’s most acclaimed film not made by Pixar.Biggest Obstacle: We’d say it’s too violent for an Oscar, but next to Sweeney Todd it looks pretty tame.
If We Were the Producers, We’d Push: This year’s movies are full of murderous sociopaths, but Javier Bardem’s understated Chigurh is the most memorable.
Rash Predictions for Nominations:
Pic./Dir./Supp. Actor/Screenplay
…And Winners:
Dir./Supp. Actor/Screenplay
![]() |
(Photo: Alex Bailey/Courtesy of Focus Features)
|
Atonement
Strategy: Maintain your lead. The front-runner since it was announced, this pedigreed adaptation is the horse to beat.Biggest Obstacle: Were we the only ones who thought that whole middle section was pretty saggy?
If We Were the Producers, We’d Push: It’s a classic Oscar-bait movie (with just enough critical approval), so go for broke: Push for Best Picture and see what else can follow in its wake.
Rash Predictions for Nominations:
Pic./Dir./Actor/Actress/Supp. Actress/Screenplay
…And Winners:
Pic.





Email
Print
Albert Camus and Literary Obsession 
True Blood's Guilty, Addictive Appeal
Brüno Takes Aim at Homophobia
Summer Food, Drinks, and Outdoor Events
Views, Biking, Art, and More at Governors Island
Marea's Lofty Ambitions and Luxurious Seafood
Three Make-Ahead Summer Party Menus
Why Does Ruth Madoff Inspire Such Hate?

Pedro Espada's Constituency of One
NYC Prep Turns New York Into a Joke
Our Annual Guide to Summer in the City
