By Amy Larocca

  Are these New Yorkers radiating hot — or not? Our expert judges say the things their best friends wouldn't. The verdict on 15 typical New Yorkers...  

The Panelists
  Micky Boardman: Deputy editorial director, Paper magazine.

Robin Givhan: Fashion editor, Washington Post

David Kirsh: Owner, Madison Square Club
  André Leon Talley: Editor at large, Vogue

Amy Sohn: New York's "Naked City" columnist

1 of 16