Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

The Phantom Menace


Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber recently previewed Love Never Dies, the sequel to the 21-years-and-counting musical Phantom of the Opera, for press in London. Assuming that, like its predecessor, Love Never Dies never dies, New York is preparing for what could be a decades-long double residency on Broadway. It’s been a while in the making.

January 1988
• After a blockbuster 1986 opening in London, Phantom previews at the Majestic Theatre. Written by Lloyd Webber with lyrics by Charles Hart and book by Richard Stilgoe, the Paris-set story of a love triangle between chorus girl Christine, nobleman Raoul, and the disfigured Phantom is a hit, winning seven Tonys.

• Original Phantom Michael Crawford leaves Broadway to star in Phantom’s L.A. production. (Sarah Brightman, Lloyd Webber’s then-wife, had already left the role of Christine in the summer of ’88 after a dispute with American Actors’ Equity.) Audiences keep coming, drawn by the production’s signature crashing-chandelier scene and an original-cast album that will spend almost five years on the Billboard 200 with hit songs like “Think of Me” and “The Music of the Night.” Phantom joins Les Misérables, A Chorus Line, and Cats as Broadway musicals that seem as though they might never close.

• The megamusical era reaches its apogee with Miss Saigon, which begins a ten-year run on the strength of an onstage helicopter liftoff.

• Lloyd Webber is knighted the next year.

• Sir Andrew begins planning a sequel set in turn-of-the-century New York. With the novelist Frederick Forsyth (The Day of the Jackal), he creates new characters and a plot that has the now-successful Phantom building an opera house on Coney Island.

• Sir Andrew abandons the project. Forsyth publishes their story as a novel, The Phantom of Manhattan.

• Across the street from the Majestic, The Producers becomes the tenth show to open at the St. James during Phantom’s run.

• A movie version of Phantom is released starring Emmy Rossum and Gerard Butler, directed by Joel Schumacher (Batman & Robin, Phone Booth). Nevertheless, the musical remains popular.

Phantom’s 7,486th Broadway performance breaks the record held by Sir Andrew’s own Cats.

The Producers closes after a measly 2,502 performances.

• Novelist (and former collaborator) Ben Elton suggests to Sir Andrew that he jettison the sequel’s new characters, refocusing the story on the iconic trio: Christine, Raoul, and the beautiful creature of darkness himself, plus Raoul and Christine’s 10-year-old son. An inspired Sir Andrew sets to work with lyricist Glenn Slater (The Little Mermaid).

• The sequel reportedly suffers a setback when Sir Andrew’s kitten, Otto, leaps onto the composer’s computerized piano and erases the entire score from its memory.

• Before rehearsals for Love Never Dies have even begun, Sir Andrew records a complete cast album. The New York Post’s Michael Riedel reports that the London budget could go as high as $20 million, raising the question of what even-more-enormous thing could possibly collapse on the stage this time.

• Sir Andrew presents the show and his lead actors at a press conference in London. Canadian Ramin Karimloo, the current West End Phantom, will create the role for the sequel; Sierra Boggess (The Little Mermaid) will play Christine. Love Never Dies will open in London in March, with a Broadway run planned for November (the original Phantom has made $744 million here so far). Sir Andrew is tight-lipped about plot details but does not explicitly rule out the possibility that Raoul and the Phantom will settle their rivalry with a hot-dog-eating contest.

Have good intel? Send tips to


Current Issue
Subscribe to New York

Give a Gift