Carnegie Hall celebrates Berlin’s two great eras—one of which is just getting started.

Gustavo Dudamel makes an enormously charismatic New York debut.

Barber’s Vanessa isn’t the forgotten marvel they say it is—but it’s a great vehicle for City Opera’s star soprano.

Verdi’s Macbeth returns to the Met, in awkward, stagy fashion.

Paul Jacobs can shake the rafters—and your soul.

The New York Philharmonic is as reliable and consistent as a metronome—and about as dull.

Natalie Dessay is a fabulous, if not exactly subtle, Lucia.

Margaret Garner, the opera by Richard Danielpour and Toni Morrison, fails its powerful material.

Bill Viola’s much-anticipated reinterpretation of Tristan und Isolde’s sexual angst is oddly neuter.

George Bernard Shaw thought little of Gilbert and Sullivan. Would an evening at Lincoln Center have changed his mind?