Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.


How often do the police get their man?


The recent stabbing death of Amy Watkins in Brooklyn was one of those high-profile murders (like Jonathan Levin's) that the tabloids swarm over, with coverage almost invariably tailored to inspire panic -- the suspect is still at large; you could be next. NYPD detectives, of course, also swarm all over such cases. But with what results? A decade's-end homicide historiography:

* The 1990 subway stabbing of Utah tourist Brian Watkins: Cops found four of eight suspects partying that night at the Roseland Ballroom. In the end, seven got 25 years to life.

* The 1992 murder of ex-El Diario editor Manuel de Dios Unanue: The Cali-cartel-funded hit man was sentenced to life in 1994.

* The 1995 murder of Maria Isabel Alves, a Madison Avenue shoe-store salesclerk whose body was found in Central Park: No arrests.

* The Zodiac killer: Found in 1996, six years after his first murder; that June, he shot his half-sister and engaged police in a three-hour shootout. A sergeant noticed the perp's mystic doodles and did a fingerprint match. Sentenced to life last year.

* The June 1996 murder of a Park Avenue dry cleaner known as the "Lollipop Lady," along with the brutal beating of a piano teacher in Central Park the same week: Police matched a fingerprint to John Royster, a turnstile-jumper booked three weeks earlier. Life without parole.

* The 1996 murder of 2nd Avenue Deli owner Abe Lebewohl: Investigation still open.


Current Issue
Subscribe to New York

Give a Gift