Gumley Haft Kleier
2002 sales: More than $70 million.
Biggest deal: $12.5 million at 610 Park Avenue.
The details: Deals mostly with the big East Side prewars. Works with her husband, Ian, and cuts her kids in on commissions when they find potential buyers—which they began doing at Horace Mann, where they’d refer classmates’ parents. (Daughter Sabrina Kleier Morgenstern has since joined the firm.) Has sold to John Travolta, Billy Joel, and Neil Diamond, and—when they were a couple—to Diane Keaton and Warren Beatty. Spent four years dragging Al Pacino around, but he never bought. Still trying to move Richard Gere’s Fifth Avenue condo. Celebrates closings with clients at Le Cirque.
Stribling & Associates
2002 sales: “Around $50 million—to be honest, I haven’t calculated it.”
Biggest deal: A classic prewar Fifth Avenue co-op with terraces, for “in excess of $10 million.”
The details: Right-hand man to Elizabeth Stribling, Henckels was president of Edward Lee Cave’s firm before taking over Stribling’s private-brokerage division (dealing in sales of more than $4 million). Works primarily in the prewar co-ops on Park Avenue and Central Park West, plus the odd townhouse. He’s a Texan, but the Stanford–Harvard Business School–rides-English kind (he was the 1970 Texas riding champion). Runs an annual horsemanship competition in Dutchess County with his wife, Tiffany PR chief Fernanda Kellogg. Celebrity clients include Brooke Shields and Billie Jean King.
2002 sales: “In the first six months of this year, I totaled just under $30 million.”
Biggest deal: A 3,200-square-foot co-op at the El Dorado. How much? Like Bartleby, he prefers not to.
The details: His prime clientele circles around Central Park West and Park Avenue. Started as associate director at Albert B. Ashforth in 1986 and bought the company in 1991 (changing the name to Ashforth Warburg). On the board of the Glimmerglass Opera.
William B. May
2002 sales: More than $40 million.
Biggest deal: Sold the same apartment at 515 Park Avenue twice, first for $18.8 million (the seller was reportedly Jon Corzine) and a few months later for $18.25 million.
The details: Affable, friendly broker who’s been at William B. May for 21 years and tends to work with the same customers over and over: “I do a lot of follow-up, and I think that’s served me well.” Lives on Riverside Drive; sells all over town, specializing in big prewar apartments. “He’s extremely patient when you’re under the microscope,” says executive recruiter Joyce Hutton Roberts, who bought an apartment from him at 470 Park Avenue.
A. Laurance Kaiser IV
2002 sales: Won’t say.
Biggest deal: Sold the same apartment at 834 Fifth Avenue three times, most recently for $12.5 million.
The details: Go-to guy for swank East Side townhouses. Sold Maria Cuomo and Kenneth Cole their Fifth Avenue co-op and Neil Diamond his duplex penthouse in the limestone mansion at 17 East 63rd Street. Grew up on Fifth Avenue, attended Switzerland’s Le Rosey boarding school, and has the ascot to prove it. Inherited a formidable Rolodex from his mom, Evalyn Kaiser, who ran the firm before he did. Has encyclopedic knowledge of who lives where, from Palm Beach to Park Avenue. Often works with the European jet set.
2002 sales: An astonishing $287 million. “But remember, that’s unfair to other people—I sell in bulk, sometimes five apartments to one person.”
Biggest deal: Near closing on a $23 million apartment in AOL Time Warner Center, and on a similarly priced place in Trump World Tower.
The details: Brokers love to hate Lenz, mostly out of jealousy. She’s probably the city’s top broker, and in the country’s top five. Doesn’t have a geographical specialty: She follows the money. (Clients include Nathan Lane, Jay-Z, and Mariah Carey.) Speaks five languages; frequently flies to places like Hong Kong to secure clients. Sold the penthouse at the Ritz-Carlton for $17.7 million, and we hear she’s moving into the building herself. Never gets off the phone. Says she has a house in Southampton; also says she’s hardly there. But since Prudential bought Elliman, she’s been making big deals on the East End. Is known for celebrity sales—she found Tommy Mottola and Thalia their place at 30 East 85th Street, which they then flipped for $11.8 million—but says her clientele is “90 percent non-high-profile. It’s just that those people don’t get written about.”
2002 sales: “I don’t give it out.”
Biggest deal: A 4,500-square-foot loft in the New Museum building at 158 Mercer Street for $6.75 million (it had sold a month earlier for $5 million).
The details: She’s the downtown maven: Works mostly with loft conversions and new developments, especially in freshly gentrified neighborhoods, and actually moved to the Clock Tower in Dumbo. Pioneered Elliman’s Soho business in the mid-eighties and was among the first in Tribeca and Chelsea a decade later. Lately, does more business in Williamsburg than in Manhattan.
Alice F. Mason Ltd.
2002 sales: $30 million.
Biggest deal: A pair of deals, really: Jean-Paul Messier bought a place at 515 Park for $17.5 million, after the seller paid $15 million (also through Mason) and never moved in. (What is with these people?)
The details: A legend among old-money types for her discretion, meaning that celebrities, socialites, and elite executives feel safe with her (she has the exclusive to sell former EMI Music chief’s Jim Fifield’s penthouse triplex at 27 North Moore Street). Her firm just sold Maria Cuomo and Kenneth Cole’s Fifth Avenue apartment for about $14 million—though the broker who did the deal, Claire Kaufman, has since jumped to Corcoran. Known for her dinner parties and Democratic fund-raising (she’s had Carter, Clinton, and Gore as guests) and obsessively maintained Maltese, Fluffy.
MacRae Parker Jr.
Brown Harris Stevens
2002 sales: “I don’t talk about these things. I think it’s wrong.”
The details: Now 80, he was operating when everyone else on this list was in short pants. Is among the most tight-lipped in the business, never discussing his clients. A Dakota specialist—he got Judith Stern Peck, ex-wife of former Hartz CEO Leonard Stern, through the impossible co-op board and into a $5 million–plus fixer-upper there in 2000.
Brown Harris Stevens
2002 sales: Will say only that she consistently does deals in the $15 million range; you do the math.
Biggest deal: “Just under $20 million for an East Side co-op.”
The details: The top producer in the luxury category at Brown Harris Stevens, Sloane is still egalitarian: “I think my smallest sale last year was $349,000 for a studio, and I’m always getting calls to help friends’ kids.” On the other end of the scale, last year she sold Robert Redford’s penthouse at 1030 Fifth Avenue to Mike Nichols and Diane Sawyer for $11 million. Does quite a bit downtown, too. Showed the Clintons a few Manhattan apartments before they bought (through her) in Westchester and remains a Democratic Party operator.
2002 sales: “What do I want, the IRS?”
Biggest deal: “All the large deals come with confidentiality agreements.”
The details: Has worked with a lot of music-business people (Billy Joel, Sting). Sold ex-husband Seymour “I Discovered Madonna” Stein’s apartment at 55 Central Park West to Donna Karan for a reported $11 million. Was the basis for Sylvia Miles’s character in Wall Street, and has been profiled in Vanity Fair. Has the exclusive for the old “Warhol compound” in Montauk, owned by friend Paul Morrissey. Used to manage the Ramones.