New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Rum Punch

White rum is the ultimate summer mixer—and maybe, now that new premium brands are hitting the market, a sipping drink, too. Which bottle is best?


(Photo credit: Davies + Starr)

Bambu, $47.99
Rum for vodka drinkers. The bottle aims for premium-label chic, but the liquor is almost tasteless—the cotton-candy flavor dies instantly. At Astor Wines & Spirits (12 Astor Pl., at Lafayette St.; 212-674-7500).

10 Cane, $34.99
A sign that rum is the next premium liquor: LVMH’s new brand. Smoky, molasses-scented, and smooth enough to drink straight. At Union Square Wines & Spirits (33 Union Sq. W., nr. 16th St.; 212-675-8100).

Rogue, $29.95
A full-bodied rum with a bite to match, from Oregon, of all places. The clear scent belies a charcoal flavor and tingly aftertaste that serious drinkers will appreciate. At

Cane, $25
Top girly rum. Snobs might find it a little sweet, but ladies will love the sugary aroma and chocolaty finish. Mixes well with pineapple juice. At Crush Wine Co. (153 E. 57th St., nr. Lexington Ave.; 212-980-9463).

Wray & Nephew, $23.99
The strongest rum tastes sweet but packs a powerful punch—a subtle scent of sulfur is the main hint it’s overproof. At Waverly Liquor Store (135 Waverly Pl., nr. Sixth Ave.; 212-727-0483).

Appleton, $18.99
One of the strongest-smelling rums tested also has a tart grapefruit aftertaste that’s perfect for Jamaican rum punches. At Murray Hill Wines (516 Third Ave., nr. 34th St.; 212-532-2440).

Matusalem, $16.99
The slight taste of vanilla, gentle flavor, and slick texture make this rum easy to consume, if a little middle-of-the-road. At Beekman Liquors (500 Lexington Ave., nr. 47th St.; 212-759-5857).

Barbancourt, $14.99
Haitian import scores points for its cool, old-fashioned label, but smells slightly rubbery and has a thin consistency. At Kessler Liquors (23 E. 28th St., at Madison Ave.; 212-685-7651).

Bacardi Superior, $11.99
Firewater. Mixer rum for large parties, goes best with Coke. At Warehouse Wines & Spirits (735 Broadway, nr. Astor Pl.; 212-982-7770).


Current Issue
Subscribe to New York

Give a Gift