New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Great Balls of Ice

Whether you’re into classic coconut or sake sorbet, we’ve got the scoop.


Bouley de Sorbet: Luciously thick, intensely-flavored sorbets from Bouley.  

120 W. Broadway (212-964-2525)
Pros: The Greek yogurt sorbet is as luscious as its thick, rich inspiration; a dark chocolate version has the dense intensity of a Swiss bar; huckleberry is just like the fruit—all creative and delicious. But that’s not the end: There’s sorbet for dinner, too (shrimp is served with carrot sorbet and oysters come with a celery version). $12 for five scoops.
Cons: Sorbets are made without stabilizers, so they melt fast.
Rating: Five stars

304 E. 48th St. (212-759-0590)
Pros: They don’t just go for the obvious at this nuevo Latino. Morir soñando, with rum, lime, orange, and a splash of milk, is a semi-solid cross between a dessert and a tropical cocktail; passionfruit and lime sorbets are properly tart, coconut is creamy and smooth. And you can just sit at the bar and order a few with coffee. $8 for three scoops.
Cons: Apart from the morir soñando, Ola’s creative efforts (like bitter, foamy beer sorbet) fall flat.
Rating: Three stars

24 E. 12th St. (212-924-4283)
Pros: We’ve sampled loads of imported sakes at this fun spot, with its gold-leafed wall and chopstick-decorated ceiling. Now, as a twist on dessert wines, Yujin offers sake sorbet. One is blended with white peaches, another with litchis; both can be ordered floating in a melon soup, a perfect naturally sweet conduit, or alone. $7 for three scoops.
Cons: The sorbets are a touch too sugary for our taste.
Rating: Three stars

208 W. 70th St. (212-875-8600)
Pros: The house specialty, “ten flavors sorbet,” is a blend of, yes, ten fruits and spices. It’s served with cool, tasty sides: a chocolate cone, tapioca pudding, and mango ravioli. The fromage blanc and lime-rosemary versions are far superior. $8 for three scoops.
Cons: Ten flavors are too many in one scoop—the result tastes somewhat bitter.
Rating: Three stars

Gotham Bar & Grill
12 E. 12th St. (212-620-4020)
Pros: The bar area and its tables are a great, romantic dessert spot with flattering lighting. Attractive, inventive flavor combinations include blueberry-and-lavender sorbet. $8.50 for three scoops.
Cons: The sorbets are over-aerated and candylike: You taste the sugar before you taste the fruit.
Rating: Two stars

2398 Broadway, at 88th St. (212-874-7400)
Pros: Pastry chef Jehangir Mehta is known for savory sorbets like passionfruit-marjoram, but he also has tasty dessert versions: coconut spiked with Malibu, and pineapple (the fruit is roasted for extra flavor). $7 for three scoops.
Cons: Mint sorbet is a good idea, but here it’s too sweet. More flavors would bring this up a star.
Rating: Three stars

480 Lexington Ave., at 46th St. (212-871-6600)
Pros: The sorbet pyramid is like a giant fruit sundae, with cantaloupe, honeydew, berry, piña colada, blueberry, lemon, litchi, cherry, passionfruit, mango, and plum, all served on a block of ice with peanut-butter cookies and homemade marshmallows. The sorbets have a nice balance of ice and smoothness. $12.
Cons: The pyramid cries out for one or two more exotic entries.
Rating: Four stars

Expert Advice
Inspired? Freeze your own sorbet with an ice-cream maker and a few tips from Ciao Bella president Charlie Apt.

1. Use slightly overripe fruit. It imparts more flavor.

2. If you are using a fresh herb like mint, soak the sorbet mixture for 24 hours so the flavor will be fully infused.

3. Use a pre-chilled glass so the sorbet doesn’t melt when it is scooped in.

4 . A touch of wine or vodka adds a little extra flavor and changes the texture by lowering the melting point.


Current Issue
Subscribe to New York

Give a Gift