New York Magazine

The Best New Cheap Eats
 
  American
  Asian
  Burgers
  Falafel
  French
  Hot Dogs
  Italian
  Mexican
  Pizza
  Wine Bars
  Eclectic Mix of Cuisines
   
  Sullivan Street Food Crawl
  Manhattan
  Brooklyn
  Queens
   
  2002 Picks
  2001 Picks
 

 

New Mexican Restaurant Picks

 
Seeing Double:Creative quesadillas at Mexican Sandwich Company. (Photo by Kenneth Chen)

Café Mexicano
671 Union Street, Park Slope, Brooklyn
718-623-6754

Two-dollar tamales and superior café con leche are reason enough to patronize this seven-seat sliver of a Park Slope café, but happily for local fans of the cheap, delicious Mexican snacks called antojitos, the dexterous kitchen doesn’t stop there. Zesty avocado salad ($4.25) is enlivened with lime juice and cilantro. Pressed sandwiches ($5.75 to $6.50) are stuffed with savory fillings like chicken mole and roast-pork guajillo. Corn masa is put to every conceivable use—most of them involving sour cream, Oaxacan cheese, black beans, and tangy tomatillo salsa. Thirst-quenchers like lime lemonade and tamarind water are made in-house, as is cinnamon-spiced Mexican hot chocolate, served in rough earthenware mugs.

Itzocan Café
438 East 9th Street
212-677-5856

Tex-Mex you’ve heard of, but French-Mex? That’s the best way to describe the offbeat fusion perpetrated at this unexpectedly gourmet hole-in-the wall. The Puebla-born chefs (who happen to be brothers) picked up a few tricks working at French bistros around town, which accounts for the asparagus “a la plancha” with mango and Oaxaca cheese in passion-fruit vinaigrette ($6), the inspired combination of huitlacoche and truffle oil in the signature soufflé cakes ($6), and specials like roast leg of lamb stuffed with feta and spinach in merlot-pasilla jus ($14.50). For dessert? Blue-corn crêpes, of course.

Mexican Sandwich Company
322 Fifth Avenue, Park Slope, Brooklyn
718-369-2058

Technically a misnomer, the name of this high-concept cantina refers not to the traditional Mexican torta but rather to creative, multicultural takes on double-decker quesadillas. We’re partial to wild plum and brie with double-smoked bacon, caramelized red onion, and lavender-chili honey ($8), and barbecued duck confit with Cheddar, spicy mango salsa, and blood-orange-chili purée ($9). But that’s just us. If you prefer, you can keep it simple by customizing your own with add-on delicacies like pickled jalapeños, chorizo, and chipotle shrimp.