Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Summer of Sandwiches

Ice cream hasn't been left out of the sandwich trend, and you don't have to fiddle with molecules to be innovative. Here are seven nouveau ice-cream sandwiches to try now.


Ice-cream sandwich with Nutella from the Big Gay Ice Cream Truck.   

Big Gay Ice Cream Truck
Multiple locations: Find him on Twitter
Trailblazing founder Doug Quint turns the Mister Softee model on its head, pairing soft-serve with toppings like cayenne pepper and Trix cereal. His chocolate-cookie sandwiches might combine chocolate or vanilla with anything from Nutella to candied bacon, $4.

Insomnia Cookies
50 W. 8th St., nr. MacDougal St.; 212-228-2373
NYU kids' late-night fix bookends vanilla-fudge ice cream with a pair of warm cookies baked in-house including chocolate chunk, M&M, peanut-butter chip, and s’mores, $3.

Three Tarts
164 Ninth Ave., nr. 20th St.; 212-462-4392
A better description for these patties might be portable ice-cream cakes: lemon cake layering lavender-lemon ice cream and honeycomb crunch gets cut into handheld squares and the same process goes for triple-chocolate ice cream and cake, $4.25.

159 Second Ave., at 10th St.; 212-677-2301
Dairy- and gluten-averse can have a happy ending at this dairy-free ice-cream shop, where they combine Babycakes chocolate chip or oatmeal raisin cookies with any specially made flavor, including vanilla-coconut and bananas foster, $5.35.

Peter Pan Donut and Pastry Shop
727 Manhattan Ave., nr. Norman Ave., Greenpoint, Brooklyn; 718-389-3676
Four words we can't believe didn't get put together sooner: Doughnut. Ice Cream. Sandwich. Choose old-fashioned or red-velvet-cake doughnut plus pistachio, vanilla, chocolate, cookies and cream, or strawberry ice cream, $3.50.

Sweet Revenge
62 Carmine St., nr. Bedford St.; 212-242-2240
Ciao Bella turned up in our favorite ice-cream sandwiches from 2006, and here their chocolate, vanilla, or mango gelati (and sorbetti) get swiped into housemade peanut butter, English ginger, cranberry pecan, and, of course, chocolate chip cookies, $7.

Xie Xie
645 Ninth Ave., nr. 45th St.; 212-265-2975
This newcomer to the Asian-sandwich trend also advances the frozen-dessert category by smearing their own cocoa tuille cookie with caramel-infused ice cream, $4.


Current Issue
Subscribe to New York

Give a Gift