Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Eat Cheap at Coney Island

Skip the tired funnel cake and save your money for the Wonder Wheel: Here are our five favorite bites on the boardwalk for under five bucks.


Hot dog, $3.99
Nathan's Famous

1310 Surf Ave., at Stillwell Ave.; 718-946-2202
There's a reason they've got "famous" in their name: The hot dog here (and here alone — skip it at any other location of the chain) is a classic. The sausage has a toothsome snap, sweet-smoky flavor, and a buttery, charred bun that renders toppings like sauerkraut or stewed onions entirely irrelevant.

Tacos, $3 each
Grill House

Boardwalk, nr. 15th St.; 718-265-0347
There are half a dozen counters affiliated with the hundred-yard-long Grill House, each selling its own specialty, from fresh-shucked clams to funnel cake. Head to the far western end of the booth for the Mexican offerings, where you can pick up a round of tacos that are easily as good as any in town. Your best bets: tangy chicken, charcoal-grilled after an all-day marinade in garlic and fresh herbs, or the meltingly tender shredded carnitas. Add some sliced avocado and cheese for $0.50 each, and be the envy of the boardwalk.

Quarter chicken, $5
Pio Pio Riko

1023 Boardwalk, nr. 12th St.; 718-266-4092
The ubiquitous Peruvian rotisserie chain might not seem like a natural fit for the beach, but its quarter chicken — dark-skinned, dark-fleshed, deeply flavorful — goes surprisingly well with the salt tang in the air. Sit down in the roped-in seating area for a little bit of peace and quiet among the otherwise madding crowd.

Soft-serve cone, $3
Denny's Delight

1212 Surf Ave., nr. Stillwell Ave.; 718-266-9371
Sure, there's fried dough and hot dogs to be had at this seriously old-school stand just off the boardwalk, but the real draw is the super-creamy, super-fresh soft-serve custard — once a Coney Island staple, now maddeningly hard to come by. Skip the chocolate or vanilla in favor of a cone of their justly famous pistachio. (Or if you're feeling particularly adventurous, a pistachio-banana swirl.)

Margherita pizza slice, $2.81
Totonno's Pizzeria Napoletano

1524 Neptune Ave., nr. 15th St.; 718-372-8606
Be warned: To get a single slice of Totonno's legendary Neapolitan pizza, you're going to have to order a whole pie, so it's smart to bring friends. The charred crust, bright-sweet tomato sauce, and super-fresh mozzarella elevate this significantly over most other pizzas in New York, let alone Coney Island.


Current Issue
Subscribe to New York

Give a Gift