A Gift So Nice, We’re Posting It Twice, one of the many holiday-gifting series we’ll be running this month and next, is a look back at the gifts we wrote about last year that our readers actually bought. Here, Cut fashion director Rebecca Ramsey on the very flattering cashmere sweater she’s put on her holiday wish list for nearly a decade (we shouldn’t have been surprised that so many of you loved it last year).
We asked Rebecca to tell us if she planned to get another this year, but last year’s may have been the last. “I’m actually probably not asking for one this year (I know!) because I go to L.A. so much now and have little need for new sweaters. I do love it still, though. In fact, I wore another one on my red-eye last night as it’s perfect for travel layering.” A nice bonus for anyone who doesn’t already have seven of these: It’s on sale for half-off, in case you want to get some holiday shopping done early.
Each holiday season for the last seven years, I have asked my mother for the same gift: a private-label department-store cashmere sweater from Neiman Marcus. Yes, nondescript, quiet, quality two-ply cashmere. It’s not the sexiest or most thrilling gift by any means, but it’s my absolute favorite, and one less thing for her to stress over during the holidays. (It comes in plus sizes, too.)
The origins of the gift are not memorable really. In 2009, I simply asked my mother for a navy cashmere crewneck sweater, and let her run free into the malls of metro Detroit. She returned successfully from Neiman Marcus and that was it. The fact that she found something of her own choosing that I loved was the kicker.
It was such a successful gift that I ask for a new one each year. I like the way it fits me: It’s not too tight nor too big. There is nothing tricky in the stitching or trimming. It’s like wearing a favorite T-shirt — but one you have to dry-clean. And it pretty much works with any winter outfit of mine: a slimmer size layers nicely under a boxy blazer or complements a fancier skirt, while a larger size worn over a white tee is my exaggerated companion to jeans.
Timing is key, however. It’s nearly always on sale after Thanksgiving (in fact, 50 percent off right now), so my mom waits until December to start shopping. Two navy crewnecks later, along with a charcoal and a pale-gray V-neck (that I sadly left in Milan), a black version of each, and a surprising hunter-green sweater in 2013, I have amassed quite the collection and don’t see an end to it. This year, I went rogue and asked for ivory.
The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best women’s jeans, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, ultra-flattering pants, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.
Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.