We Tested Six Sofas-in-a-Box

By
Sofa-in-a-box.

First came prescription glasses. Then mattresses, then leather jackets. Nothing, it seemed, was too important or cumbersome to ship straight to a shopper’s doorstep, bought sight unseen. Now start-ups — Article (launched in 2013 under the name Bryght), Hem (2014), and, as of last year, Campaign and Burrow — are taking on the couch, a big-ticket item that, like mattresses, people once wanted to see and sit on before they spent a sizable amount of money. These new couches arrive at your door in cardboard boxes and can be assembled with minimal know-how, catering to city-dwellers with discerning taste, moderate budgets, and a desire to graduate from the Ikea Ektorp. UPS shipping constraints mean these sofas look comically similar (mid-century-modern angles fit better in boxes, after all), but each couch still varies in design pedigree and comfiness — so we sat on six of them and ranked them based on product, price, assembly, fine print, and comfort.

1. Burrow

Burrow Sofa
$1,095, Burrow

The product: One style that resembles the Florence Knoll sofa, in five colors and with high or low armrests (from $1,095; burrow.com). Reversible seat cushions are tufted and smooth. Bonus: USB outlets are underneath.

The assembly: Incredibly easy. Free shipping via UPS (a three-seater comes in four 50-pound boxes), then pieces attach via snapping hinges. We saw Burrow’s co-founder assemble and disassemble a two-seater in five minutes.

The fine print: Free returns within 30 days as long as it’s in the original packaging.

What happened when we sat on it: Springy, comfortable, and supportive, but not deep — good for sitting upright, but less suited to sprawling out for a Netflix marathon.

The verdict: Our favorite for smart (if a bit pedestrian) design, incredible ease of assembly, and a nice return policy.

2. Article

Article Timber Sofa
$1,199, Article

The product: A range of styles — from mid-century to minimal to tufted and formal — across 30 available sofas (from $699; article.com).

The assembly: Sofas arrive via three tiers of delivery: $49 to the building, $99 to get upstairs to a specific room, and $169 for movers to assemble the couch, although that just requires screwing on legs.

The fine print: A 30-day, no-questions-asked return policy, but Article will charge you a pickup fee equal to the delivery fee.

What happened when we sat on it: A recent plop-down at a pop-up (now closed) revealed the angular Sven in leather to be a little tough, like it needs to be broken in. The linen-upholstered Timber, however, has some give to make the sitter feel embraced.

The verdict: A good starter sofa for someone who’s moved into their first apartment out of college. Aesthetes might find the selection lacking, but it’s a broader range than most. —Max Berlinger

3. Campaign

Campaign Sofa
$1,195, Campaign

The product: Founded by an ex–Apple engineer, Campaign offers love seats ($895; campaignliving.com, or 21 Prince St.) and couches ($1,195) in one Herman Miller–like silhouette and seven different colors, such as “Mojave orange” and “sprouted green.”

The assembly: Designed according to UPS shipping dimensions, sofas arrive (for free) in two boxes — compressed cushions fit inside the steel frame — and take 15 minutes to set up.

The fine print: Return the frame for free within 14 days with the original packaging. Campaign doesn’t ask for cushions back — once they expand, they won’t fit back in the box.

What happened when we sat on it: Very comfortable, thanks to a soft, downlike polyester fill in the back cushions, but the armrests are bony.

The verdict: The flat-pack ingenuity of the sofa is a well-deserved selling point, and it’s a cinch to put together, but it’s more expensive than you would think, and we wish it had a more expansive selection of styles.

4. Hem

Hem Palo 2-Seater Sofa
$1,999, Hem

The product: The Swedish company makes the Palo (from $1,699; hem.com), which has one clean slab of a seat, low backrests, and exposed hardware (pictured here), and the more traditional Koti (from $1,679) in a mix of configurations and neutral colors.

The assembly: Sofas ship free in the U.S. and arrive almost fully assembled. Fit in the legs, slot in the struts (the metal backrest frame), and tuck cushions into place.

The fine print: Returns accepted within 14 days, but shoppers cover a $400 return-shipping cost.

What happened when we sat on it: Neither sofa has much give.
Cushions are stuffed with an extra-firm polyurethane foam — not ideal for committed couch potatoes.

Verdict: Beautifully designed and easy to assemble at a fairish price, but returns are pricey and the policy itself is not the most forgiving.

5. Interior Define

Interior Define Toby Sofa
$2,000, Interior Define

The product: Interior Define is among the more design-y of the options available in online sofas — the brand collaborates with designers including Alison Victoria and Apartment Therapy’s Maxwell Ryan on capsule collections but also has clean-lined sofas like the Toby ($2,000; interiordefine.com).

The assembly: Models arrive in either one piece or two pieces, and Interior Define delivers with free white glove service, so someone will assemble it upon delivery.

The fine print: You’re able to return a product for up to 365 days after you receive the sofa, but within 14 days you get a full refund. After that, you’ll be charged a 10% restocking fee. Deliveries typically take eight to 12 weeks.

What happened when we sat on it: The Toby (deep cushions, short back, and slightly firm — good for sitters prone to slouching) was comfortable if slightly formal.

The verdict: If you’re looking for more interesting silhouettes, don’t care to assemble it yourself, and have commitment issues, look no further. —Max Berlinger

6. Can Sofa by Hay Design

Can Sofa by Hay Design
$2,695, MoMA

The product: A special project from French designers Ronan and Erwan Bouroullec, the Can ($2,695; store.moma.org) takes cues from camping furniture, right down to the Coleman-esque canvas upholstery and steel frame.

The assembly: Very intuitive, and possible in 30 seconds. The sofa arrives in four boxes. Curved rods attach to longer ones for the frame and then slip into a canvas backrest.

The fine print: Depends on the stockist, but MoMA Design Store charges a $250 delivery fee and accepts returns within 90 days.

What happened when we sat on it: Feels sturdy. The Can is daybed-size, with firm cushions filled with foam and feathers — it feels like stretching out on a Japanese floor futon.

The verdict: You’re paying for the Hay name here, which is fine, though there are bigger names and glitzier options out there for a sofa from a marquee designer.

Other sofas in a box

Joybird

Joybird Calhoun Sofa
$1,199, Joybird

The product: Joybird has perhaps the most styles of any of the new breed of sofa companies. Mid-century shapes, tufted sofas, leather low-seaters, millennial-pink numbers, etc. That’s because Joybird “custom-makes” each sofa according to your specifications after you decide what you want.

The assembly: Like Interior Define, Joybird offers white glove service, in which deliverers will come with your fully assembled furniture, place it where you’d like, and remove all packaging.

The fine print: Joybird also allows a generous 365 days with your sofa. Within the first 14 days of returns, shipping is on them, too.

Bench Made Modern

Bench Made Modern Crowd-Pleaser Sofa
$2,295, Bench Made Modern

The product: Bench Made Modern — the direct-to-consumer sister brand of founder Edgar Blazona’s wholesale business True Modern — offers a close-to-custom experience made in Los Angeles. The 54 mid-century modern sofa styles (deep-set, almost daybed-like) lean more toward Nancy Meyers than off-campus housing.

The assembly: Sofas arrive fully assembled, and with $200 white glove service, Bench Made drivers will deliver the sofa to the room of your choice, unwrap the piece, and carry off the packaging.

The fine print: Returns are accepted within 100 days of purchase, minus the 10 percent shipping return fee, but within the first 14 days, you can get a full refund, including shipping.

Rove Concepts

Rove Concepts Luca
$2,590, Rove Concepts

The product: Rove began in 2011 by working with artisans and sofa manufacturers around the world to create couches they’ve organized into three distinct vibes: Classics (similar to CB2), Sandro (slightly more whimsical and vaguely Italian-looking), and Kure (Scandinavian-lite).

The assembly: Sofas are largely assembled besides the unpacking of pillows, cushions, and screwing of legs. White glove service (whose cost depends on your location) is available, but opting for it extends wait time from 14 to 16 business days. Note the service can only travel up a single flight of stairs, too.

The fine print: You can live with the sofa for 30 days before deciding whether to return it, though you will be responsible for the return shipping costs in the original packaging. (The cost again depends on where you live.)

So why pay double the price of Ikea?

First, for solid wood and steel, which cost more than particleboard. Second, for design. Ikea pieces aren’t made to withstand a move — the brackets and screws used to hold them taut and level don’t come out and go back in without wear and tear. “Ikea comes with bags of hardware, and it’s actually complicated,” says Lothar Windels, a furniture-design professor at Rhode Island School of Design. “Stuff that’s smartly engineered has six pieces instead of 50.” New flat-pack sofas rely on just a few precision-cut-steel parts and locking mechanisms to fit together. And last, for Amazon-like delivery. Ikea offers many things, but easy shipping’s not one of them. —Margaret Rhodes

*A version of this article appears in the February 5, 2018, issue of New York Magazine. 

The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best women’s jeansrolling luggagepillows for side sleepersultra-flattering pants, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.

We Tested Six Sofas-in-a-Box