painless shopping

The Expensive Sandals You Want, Versus the Cheap Sandals You Should Get

Two velvety green mules
A spendy shoe and its cheaper counterpart.

I had the sandals in the shopping basket and my credit card in my hand when I came to and realized, You nut, you can’t afford $397 (plus tax and shipping) sandals! They were beautiful sandals, to be sure: black suede slingback mules with a simple metal strap, made by an Australian company called By Far. I desired them greatly.

But we mourn; we move on. We look for sandals that capture some of the original sandals’ understated elegance. We fail. We buy a pair of cherry-red Urban Outfitters sandals that we like fine, but don’t fall head over heels for. They look good with our cropped jeans, and we’re doing okay! Less happy than we might be had we purchased the Perfect Sandals. But less anxious, too, as we narrowly dodged spending several hundreds of dollars on shoes we’ll wear for two months.

Below, please find ten too expensive summer sandals that will break your heart, along with their closest cheaper counterparts, to help you try to move on. Let’s not think of it as settling. Let’s think of it as financial self-care.

Black strappy sandals

By Far Scandi Strap Sandal
$397 at Garmentory

Let’s get this the hell out of the way: These are the sandals I wanted.

The Noelle Slingback Sandal in Suede
$98 at Madewell

And a much-cheaper — and really, quite similar — alternative.

Steve Madden Cactus Sandal
$80 at Nordstrom

And another.

Bright-blue mules

Maryam Nassir Zadeh Sophie Leather Slides
$360 at Moda Operandi

Vibrant, life-changing Maryam Nassir Zadeh mules.

Patti Suede Mule Heel
$39 at Urban Outfitters

And perfectly nice Urban Outfitter copycats.

Earthy-green slingbacks

By Far Scandi Strap Sandals in Green
$397 at Garmentory

The prettiest green suede sandals that I lusted over for all of summer 2017, and frankly have yet to get over.

The Noelle Slingback Sandal in Velvet
$98 at Madewell

And these are, y’know, nice and green, too.

Sunny mid-heel mules

Mansur Gavriel 40MM Heeled Mule in Sun
$475 at Need Supply Co.

Beautiful, elegant Mansur Gavriel mules.

The Day Heel Mule
$155 at Everlane

But really, don’t be ridiculous: Buy this Everlane pair instead.

Marta Mule Heel
$59 at Urban Outfitters

Or these, they’re even cheaper!

Neutral-colored glove shoes

Martiniano Glove Shoe in Tostado
$437 at Need Supply Co.

Did you say you wanted the Martiniano glove slipper?

The Day Glove
$110 at Everlane

These almost-flats will do.

Fancy mary janes

Rachel Comey Bali Closed Toe Mary Jane in Fuschia Velvet
$395 at Need Supply Co.

You want these Rachel Comey high-heeled mary janes for your summer weddings, don’t you?

The Claudia Sandal in Velvet
$96 at Madewell

Don’t do it, my friend! Go for these.

Walking sandals

James Rowland Shop Dual Strapped Sandals
$130 at Garmentory

The comfiest stylish shoe you’ll ever wear. I own them in this natural color and in black.

$100 at Charleston Shoe Co.

And their practically identical, Strat-favorite counterparts for $30 less.

The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best women’s jeans, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, ultra-flattering pants, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.

Expensive Sandals and Their Cheap Counterparts