To be a Strategist editor is to live with the constant burden of always having the perfect gift ideas. But for you, our dear readers, it’s a burden we’re happy to carry. Presented as part of our Mother’s Day extravaganza, here’s what we’ll be gifting our moms this year. (You might want to check out what we gifted last year, too.)
Alexis Swerdloff, Strategist editor
In addition to giving her a selection of novels set during World War II that I’ve collected from the office giveaway table (it’s a Mother’s Day tradition!), I’ll be giving her a new watch. She’s been wearing the same cheapo Quartz-brand watch for the last … 15 years or so, and the band just broke, which means that I think it’s time for an upgrade. I love this super-simple and elegant watch from Swiss brand Mondaine. It’s not over-the-top at all, and just my mom’s style I think.
Jason Chen, deputy editor
Last year, my mom read Kathleen Hou’s post about the Buly 1803 scented rock and asked me to get it for her. I laughed because I thought she was kidding. Then she asked me again, “but only if you can get it for free.” (She doesn’t quite understand how my job works.) So this year, I will be getting her the fragrant porous rock, and if she asks, I got it for free.
From time to time, my mom will get fixated on something and become unable to talk about anything else. We’ve survived a Jell-O-salad phase, and a potpourri-sachet phase, and now we’re all about the FitFlop loafer. I didn’t know FitFlops made anything other than butt-firming flip flops, but according to my mom, their loafers have the world’s most comfortable soles. Last year, while visiting girlfriends in Taipei, her travel shoes became so painful that she popped into a store. The salesperson suggested these, and she liked them so much she went back days later and bought two more pairs. Well, now she’ll have four.
Margaret Rhodes, senior editor
My mother is an inveterate bath-taker. And luckily for my sister and me, who sometimes never know what to get her, she’s always receptive to new bath products. These salts hit a sweet spot: My mom loves the brand Naturopathica, and turned me on to its very refreshing Oat Cleansing Facial Polish, and because she’s also very active, she swears by magnesium to help soothe tired and overworked muscles.
Is there a phrase for when someone gifts you something, and then you buy them the same gift later? My mother bought me and my boyfriend a Le Creuset French press over the holidays, and has since been asking me if the ceramic keeps the coffee hotter than an ordinary glass pot does. I think it does? And even if that’s a placebo effect, it feels and looks good. Yield Design is a small husband-and-wife product studio based out of St. Augustine, Florida, and they make beautiful, modern stuff — like this ceramic French press, that I think will look very hip in my mother’s kitchen.
More ceramic coffeeware: I was recently introduced to this company from Asheville, North Carolina, that’s reinvigorating the old ceramics industry there, and making hefty, beautiful pieces like plates and bowls. Their coffee mug is kind of extraordinary. It feels really smooth and sturdy in your hand, and I swear makes coffee taste better. My mom can pair this with her cool new French press.
Simone Kitchens, senior editor
Plants love my mom. Indoor, outdoor, on the brink — all varieties. She is a master home gardener; whenever she doesn’t pick up her phone, it usually means she’s out back working in the yard, which is often. When she is on her phone, she’s usually texting me progress-report-style photos of whatever’s blooming: From the lime tree to the sweet-potato vines and so on. So while it’s an obvious one, I like to give her plant stuff. She’s definitely happy to receive a well-established, already-on-its-way plant, but what she really loves are just straight-up bulbs. If I’m back home, I’ll grab her a few from the garden store, but this service easily arranges direct-to-mom delivery.
And what goes better with a bulb than a nice giant planter? I’m thinking this exposed-clay one from Helen Levi.
Lauren Levy, senior writer
You’re going to call me repetitive and uncreative (see Mother’s Day gifts from last year), but if I really want to gift something my mom will actually use — and I always do — it’s gotta be something for the bath and made by Jo Malone. She actually just told me last week that she’s been using the rose bath oil I got her for her birthday, so I might go for the Nectarine Blossom and Honey scent this time around.
Like most moms, mine loves a good robe. So much so that she often sleeps in or next to hers. I saw this one go up in a post yesterday, and it looks like the definition of soft and cozy. If I get all of my siblings to chip in, we can probably make it happen, and mom would never get over it.
Katy Schneider, associate editor
At the risk of sounding incredibly twee, I like to bake for my mother on Mother’s Day. She has fed me through every mild to moderate to severe trauma of my life, so cooking for her feels like an appropriate way to say, you know, Love you lots. My plan this year is to make her a giant batch of granola that she can sprinkle on her yogurt for a couple of weeks, which I’ll give to her in one of these cute little glass jars from Amazon.
I also plan to get her a robe because she doesn’t have one! She does not like overly fluffy, chintzy-looking things, so I’m going to get her this sleek waffle version from Parachute. And because, let’s face it, I am twee as hell, I will probably embroider her initials somewhere on the front.
Maxine Builder, writer
My mom is charmingly sentimental and takes photos of any and every family gathering with her Samsung Note. So I’ve been thinking about getting her an easy-to-use external hard drive, especially after she complained about running out of storage space on her phone, and panicked when she thought she had accidentally deleted all of her memories earlier this year. I like this LaCie hard drive because it can withstand casual drops yet is pretty straightforward to use. I’m also planning on spending time with her to set it up, and I know that kind of face time is what she really wants for Mother’s Day anyway.
Speaking of accidents — earlier this year, my mom dropped her beloved Samsung Note 5 on the ground. The phone’s fine, but the case shattered, which devastated her because she really loved it. So I’d like to get her a phone case that’s nicer (and more durable) than what she’d probably buy for herself, like this one from Speck.
If your mom has a newer Samsung, like the Galaxy S9, then you have many more options. This leather case, also from Speck, is the one I’d get my mom if she upgraded her phone, in part because it’s been tested to protect your phone for drops up to ten feet.
Lori Keong, writer
I always abide by the philosophy “Give gifts that you would want yourself,” so my mom will be getting some Natura Brasil bath products that I love and know she’ll actually use. It’s the most delightful-smelling stuff for gifts (and they’re very affordable, too). This shower gel is something I hoard at home, which is like a scrub because of the maracuja beads in it, but smells fresh and tropical — like you’re sipping fruit juice on a sunny beach in Brazil. Hopefully, it’ll make her bath time more of an experience.
I’ve been dropping hints on my mom to get a mattress topper for one of the guest rooms because the bed there is rock-solid. And since I know it would be a nice upgrade that she’d appreciate, I’ll just buy one for her. I sleep there when I visit, and she does too when my dad’s snoring is off the charts, so really it’s a gift for both of us. I’m getting her one of these egg-crate mattress toppers, which I had when I moved to New York and was subletting on a cheapo Ikea mattress, so I know they’re a dream to sleep on.
My sister dropped me some intel on the phone that our oldest sister — who just delivered her baby last week — has a standard backpack, but not a dedicated diaper bag with slots for formula bottles and baby gear yet. So since this is her first Mother’s Day, I’m going to take the opportunity to give her this understated Land bag, which, word has it, all the chic moms in D.C. own, too.
Karen Iorio Adelson, writer
As a Long Island–native and card-carrying AARP member, my mom surprised no one last year when she moved to Florida. She doesn’t miss the Northeast winters, but I know there are some things that just aren’t the same outside of New York — like bagels and lox — so I’ll be sending her this kit for a taste of home. I actually sent my grandma a similar basket a few years back, and although I was skeptical about shipping cream cheese and smoked fish long distance, everything arrived surprisingly fresh in an insulated tote.
My mom binged The Assassination of Gianni Versace on FX, so I think she’ll enjoy the book the series was based on, which delves deeper into the story. The Versace family slammed the book for being “full of gossip and speculation” and for its author’s “lurid claims,” which I’m sure means it will make for an enticing beach read.
The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best women’s jeans, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, ultra-flattering pants, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.
Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.