testing testing

I Tried the Button-down Shirt That Promises to End ‘Boob Gap’

Photo: Courtesy of Tradlands

I’m not a huge fan of those lists of “must-have” pieces that no wardrobe is complete without. Not everyone’s personal style calls for a tailored blazer or little black dress. I do think, however, that a button down white shirt belongs in most closets. Problem is, if you have any semblance of breasts, chances are you’re probably familiar with the “boob gap,” when a button-down that fits perfectly otherwise stretches out across the chest and gapes open between the buttons (yes, this has a name). Even I, someone without very much boob to begin with, find it to be one of my main complaints about button-downs.

So you can imagine my enthusiasm when I learned that the menswear-inspired women’s brand Tradlands created a shirt that claimed to eliminate boob gap with two design modifications. First, an extra button — eight instead of the traditional seven — leaves less room in between buttonholes for gaping. Then, they add a bit more fabric across the chest to accommodate a bustline.

I’ve always sized up in button-down shirts to avoid boob gap, but I ordered my normal size in Tradlands’s short-sleeve Lily top to really test it out. It felt snugger than I’m used to, but to my pleasant surprise, it looked fitted without straining. The extra button not only eliminated boob gap (it truly does what it says) but it also gave me flexibility with the neckline. I’ve owned shirts that had zero safe midpoint between totally buttoned-up and way too revealing. But with the Lily, I’m able to undo just the right amount of buttons to show off a necklace but nothing else.

Even aside from its gap-closing power, the Lily is just a great shirt. The material (a 100 percent mid-weight cotton) has a linenlike texture that makes it so much more interesting than your standard white shirt. I’m incorporating it into all sorts of outfits this fall — with a tied hem and skinny jeans for a Marilyn vibe, or tucked into a midi skirt, or layered under a drapey cardigan. I’m now eyeing Tradlands’s denim and gingham shirts. Stay tuned.

Tradlands The Lily
$99 at Tradlands

More Strat-approved button-downs

Equipment Slim Signature Silk Shirt
Photo: Courtesy of the vendor
Equipment Slim Signature Silk Shirt
$230 at Nordstrom

Writer Jen Doll told us she owns this silk button-down, which she says “slims while enhancing” in four colors.

Everlane Silk Short-Sleeve Square Shirt
$98 at Everlane

Another short-sleeve option, this one is a favorite of writer and Who? Weekly podcast host Lindsay Weber. She calls it “the Perfect Shirt” that always earns her compliments.

Milano Technical Dress Shirt
$48 at MPG

For under $50, you can pick up this shirt that Caitlin Shockley, founder of the Creative, told us “completely blurs the line between ready-to-wear and athleisure.”

The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.

I Tried the Button-down That Promises to End ‘Boob Gap’