Here at the Strategist, we like to think of ourselves as crazy (in the good way) about the stuff we buy, but as much as we’d like to, we can’t try everything. Which is why we have People’s Choice, in which we find the best-reviewed products and single out the most convincing. While we’ve covered the best expensive-looking Thanksgiving décor, the best turkey-roasting tools, and the best last-minute Thanksgiving essentials, here we’re zeroing in on the best Thanksgiving decorations on Amazon. (Note that reviews have been edited for length and clarity).
The Best Nostalgic Thanksgiving Decoration
“I’m ‘old’ and I think I remember these when I was young—5o years or more ago. But they are still really neat, well made and well priced. I have given them as gifts to younger people and they too love them. They are an inexpensive way to create fun holiday decorations and they fold up so they don’t require the large storage space that a permanent, china for instance, decoration takes. They can be folded up and reused but I keep forgetting where i stored mine, so I just order new ones.”
The Best and Most Practical Thanksgiving Decoration
The Best Fall-Leaf Thanksgiving Decoration
“These add a great touch to my home Thanksgiving set up. Three different leaf colors (check out the pictures some have posted). Nice intense Autumn colors. A nice thickness; not cheaply made. Yes, you do have to separate them but it is not difficult to do. Arrived nicely sealed.”
The Best Twinkle-Light Thanksgiving Decoration
“I Couldn’t wait to put these out for our Fall decor. They are so simple and add a big punch - I really didn’t need much else to create a beautiful look in my home. I put the strands across the top of our piano and down the stair railing and it’s very pretty.”
The Best Long-lasting No-Drip Thanksgiving Decoration
“I bought these in orange tapers. I bought them during the Halloween season but didn’t get to use them until this past Thanksgiving feast. I was worried that they would drip all over my table. But low and behold they did not. I’m so used to low quality candles that I make sure I use vinyl table covers so I can easily clean up, but these didn’t disappoint. Not a drop dripped, and they were lit till about a quarter left on their length. Definitely will buy them again.”
The Best-Smelling Thanksgiving Decoration
The Best Thanksgiving Decoration That’ll Also Protect Your Table
“I just received this table cloth and was pleasantly surprised. The quality of the material is great and it looks expensive (like something you’d get at Saks or Bloomingdales). One reviewer said that it was orange, but it is not orange at all. It looks exactly as it does in the picture. You can use this for Thanksgiving, Christmas, or any celebration but its also suitable for a nice dinner with friends at home. I’m getting this as a gift for my mother (who is extremely picky). She would never guess that I payed so little for this. I almost forgot… It is also reversible which was a huge PLUS! On the reversible side it is a matte marigold color with a satin ivory colored embroidery. I wish I could give this 10 STARS. A+++”
The Best Thanksgiving Decoration for All Ages
“My 93 y/o mother-in-law resides in a nursing home. Each season and each holiday we look for something to hang on the door to her room. She gets many compliments on her ‘pretty’ door decorations. As a patient with dementia, she quickly recognizes ‘her door’ from the others even during her moments of worst confusion. The quality of this decoration means it can be used over and over. When not in use, we keep it stored under a plastic garment bag and it will last for years.”
The Best Thanksgiving Decoration You Can Use Year-round
“I have gotten so many compliments on this wreath. It is clearly artificial but does have a natural look to it. I love the shape of the leaves, the variation in their arrangement, and the olives. It has held up well for months, with opening and closing the door multiple times per day. It is the perfect size for a front door, and I love the symbolism of peace as you enter a home.”
The Best Thanksgiving Decoration for Kids
The Best Thanksgiving Decoration for Dogs
“Great quality collar! This particular one with the leaf is a darker pink looking color, but still good for boy or girl. The leaf is attached well and I have no worries of it falling off. I will definitely look into their other seasonal collars.”
The Best Thanksgiving Decoration for a “Turkey Trot” Race
“Absolutely perfect for a cold Turkey Trot race. We cut the lining so the hats would pull over our ears and I used a little elastic to help keep mine on. One runner had enough room to layer the hat over her skull cap too. Lots of laughs and compliments on the hats from other runners.”
The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.
Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.