people's choice

The Best Christmas Pajamas on Amazon, According to Hyperenthusiastic Reviewers

Photo: Courtesy of MGM

Here at the Strategist, we like to think of ourselves as crazy (in the good way) about the stuff we buy, but as much as we’d like to, we can’t try everything. Which is why we have People’s Choice, in which we find the best-reviewed products and single out the most convincing. We’ve covered the best artificial Christmas trees, Christmas tree toppers, Christmas lights, and wrapping paper, now we’re zeroing in on the best Christmas pajamas on Amazon. (Note that reviews have been edited for length and clarity.)

Best Christmas Pajamas for Women

#Followme Printed Microfleece Button Front PJ Set With Socks

“So nice and soft! I was expecting it to be of cheap quality because it was so inexpensive, but it’s actually really nicely made. I bought a XXL because I’m a size 16 to 18, and I felt it would run small, but it’s huge. I could have easily gotten an XL. I’m going to keep it though; it’ll just be super roomy. Cute pattern, too. Highly recommend these pajamas.”

Ekouaer Women’s Long Sleeve Sleepwear

“These pj’s are SO comfortable! They are smooth, light, and breathable. I absolutely love them. The sizing is perfect. I’m five-foot-five and about 165 pounds, and I bought a size medium. They fit perfectly with just the right amount of roominess, so buy your true size. These are the most comfortable pj’s I’ve owned, and they are nicely constructed and well-made, so they look nice, too. These are a must-buy!”

Alexander Del Rossa Womens Flannel Pajamas

“I am extremely happy with these pajamas, but unless you want them to shrink, wash them in cold water and dry on medium or low heat (or hang dry). I am only five-foot-two and intentionally dried the pajamas on ‘regular’ heat so they’d be a little shorter. When the sleeves and pant legs shrunk two inches (no kidding), I was delighted that I did not need to hem them! But if you are of average or tall height, take care in washing and drying. That being said, I am extremely happy with these cute and cozy pajamas and am thinking of buying a second pair!”

Best Christmas Pajamas for Men

CYZ Men’s 100% Cotton Super Soft Flannel Plaid Pajama Pants

“I’m six feet tall, 198 pounds. The large fit perfectly, about one inch over the top of my foot. It was snug but not too tight. Lightweight flannel, not heavy like one would get in sweat pants. This is good for cool weather.”

Forever Lazy Unisex Footed Adult Onesie

“Great size description from the company. My boyfriend is six-foot-five, 275 pounds, and the 2 XL fits great. They are roomy enough that he’s comfortable laying around. His feet are size 12, and these have a lot of room left in the feet. They have deep pockets, zip back flap, and are SUPER soft. SO cute, such a great gift to get him! And now I can keep the house as cold as I want and he can stay warm.”

Alexander Del Rossa Mens Plaid Flannel Pajamas

“Great product, very comfortable. Nice and warm, great price, substantial material. Very happy with these. Can’t say enough good things about them. I’m not a connoisseur of flannel pajamas, but I’ve owned five sets over the past several years. These ones are substantial, not thin. They have some nice weight to them, and are very comfortable to walk and sleep and sit in. These wear beautifully well, no problems at all, they just float, do not twist, don’t bunch up, don’t crawl up your legs in your sleep.”

Best Christmas Pajamas for Boys

Family Feeling Little Boys Pajamas Set

“They’re soft and stretchy; my son loved them! The material is nice and the design is super cute, better than I expected! He’s a size five, ordered a size five and thought they fit great.”

Boys Santa Claus Christmas Pajamas

“They are by far my absolute favorite pajamas I have gotten for my boys! They are true to size, the quality of the fabric is so soft, and all in all, ​these are so well-made!”

Boys Christmas Reindeer Pajamas

“Obsessed with these!!! They are so adorable and super soft! My kids love them!! I would say these fit as expected. My son wears a 5/5T, but I ordered him a 6. They are a little baggy in the pants, but I like pajamas to have a little extra room. He loves them and says they are very comfy. Pajamas should be comfy, and they have some room to grow over the winter. Love them!!”

Best Christmas Pajamas for Girls

Leveret Kids Christmas Pajamas

“My 5-year-old is tiny and wears them all day if we let her. Chickens, dogs, trampoline, and finally ready for bed in another pair of Leveret jams. They stay soft, and I have never had any shrink in the dryer.”

Carter’s Girls’ Fleece Gowns

“I am giving this nightgown to my granddaughter for Christmas, and it’s so darling that I don’t know if I’ll be able to wait! The micro-fleece material is really soft, and I can tell it’s going to be very warm. The colors are beautiful, and I can just tell from looking and feeling it that it’s very well made and will last a long time. Very pleased!!!”

Shelry Girls Christmas Pajamas

“My daughter received these as an Xmas gift and she loves them. They seemed a little stiff at first, but I washed them a couple times before she wore them, and she says they are really comfortable.”

Best Christmas Pajamas for Baby

Simple Joys by Carter’s Baby 2-Pack Holiday Fleece Footed Pajamas

“These are very warm and cozy. I took a star away because the red from the Santa sleeper rubbed off on the white sleeper in the packaging. It looks like it should wash out though. As of now, I have only washed the all-red one and it did not ruin any of my son’s others clothes. I’m still happy with my purchase.”

Leveret Striped Footed Pajamas Sleeper

“Three kids — I purchased matching pj’s for holiday photos. I was extremely pleased upon their arrival. The colors are vibrant, the fabric is soft and not scratchy, and they fit great. We have washed these a few times now, and have not experienced any issues with fading or shrinking — which is good, as we’re still passing these down through the kids. Also, I’ve even gone and purchased more for the infant, and am likely getting more for the other kids, too.”

Carter’s Baby Boys’ 1 Pc Fleece

“We live in Michigan and this was perfect throughout the coldest months. This is cute, of good quality, and very warm. Nice holiday outfit. My son was very comfortable in them. It fits a little bigger for him, he’s 20 pounds for 29 inches. I bought a size 18 M and it ran big.”

Best Family Christmas Pajamas

PajamaGram Family Christmas Pajamas Flannel Red/Green

“We love seeing our grandchildren’s faces when they open their PajamaGram pj’s on Christmas Eve each year. This has become our tradition. We get them for mom, dad, grandson, granddaughter, and even Lucy the dog. Always such good quality.”

PajamaGram Family Christmas Pajamas Soft, Green

“I bought them for my daughter, son-in-law, and their two kids. They are thick and very well made. They all fit perfectly and are so comfortable. It seems they can’t wait to change into them!”

Burt’s Bees Adult Holiday Pajama Sets

“Awesome. Soft. Comfortable. Warm.”

The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Christmas Pajamas on Amazon, According to Reviewers