Some mothers are a breeze to shop for (they just love candles and bath stuff!), others insist that they want nothing and remain impossible. Same goes for the mothers you’ve married into, but with an added twist: You still don’t know them as well, and you’ll probably never stop trying to make a good impression. Finding the right gift for your in-law, be it for Mother’s Day, a birthday, or as a thank-you, takes some strategy. To cut to the chase, we turned to ten real mothers-in-law to hear about the best gifts they received from the people their kids married, and then found some easy-to-buy online versions.
Fancy olive oil
“My daughter-in-law of nine months gave me the following gift as a thank-you for assistance in planning the wedding: a shipment of a gallon of olive oil and an earthen jug to pour it in to use. In addition, an olive-oil tree was planted in Italy in my name. I am Italian, I love to cook, and olive oil is a staple in Italian cooking. So this captured so many pieces of my life. The tree was ‘icing’: I am concerned about the environment and sustainability in general.” —Gay Hartigan, Park Ridge, New Jersey
It’s not a whole gallon, but this stuff is the best. Order several!
This cruet will look good in any style of kitchen.
Jewelry (from your favorite designer)
“As a mother-in-law, you suddenly find yourself feeling surprisingly older, less significant, irrelevant. My daughter-in-law gave me some very forward, trendy pieces of jewelry made by a New York designer, Lele Sadoughi. I love the two pieces she gave me because they were created by an artist she enjoys wearing. I live in a small midwestern town where fashion isn’t a priority. It’s surprising to me how slipping on these bracelets gives me a boost in confidence at a dinner or a meeting.” —Kris O’Neill, Cadillac, Michigan, mother-in-law for seven-and-a-half years
From the same designer: These acetate earrings have a “vacationing in Brazil” feel to them.
A fire pit
“The best gift my son-in-law (and daughter) have given me was a fire pit for Christmas. We have a house an hour outside of New York that we go to every weekend. Our favorite thing to do there is to gather around the outdoor fire pit and listen to music while catching up.” —Linda Ensko-Johnson, New York, mother-in-law for one month
A serving dish
“My son-in-law Steve gave me a serving dish the first time he visited our home and met the family. I frequently use that dish when our family shares meals and laughs together. And to me, time spent together is truly the gift.” —Joan Inwald, Franklin, Michigan, mother-in-law for five years
Some feel-good face oil
“My son and daughter-in-law have given me numerous gifts of jewelry and self-care products. I especially love the Peet Rivko Balancing Face Oil they got me. My skin drinks it in and gives my face a smooth sheen without feeling oily.” —Donna Ray, Encinitas, California, mother-in-law for six months
New as of last year, the Peet Rivko unisex line of skin care quickly became a favorite for its all-natural remedies for sensitive skin.
Cult favorite skin-care line Sunday Riley also makes one of the most beloved daily facial oils (the line also makes the very popular Good Genes lactic-acid treatment). Can’t go wrong with this one.
The best water bottle
“Although my daughter-in-law, Stephanie, regularly joins me for dinner or lunch — just the two of us— and that means a lot, she has also given me material gifts, such as the S’well water bottle, which sits on my desk at work. I had never noticed S’well bottles before, and now I feel like a rather cool middle-aged woman because I know what they are!” —Linda Kanefield, Chevy Chase, Maryland, mother-in-law for three-and-a-half years
This extra-tall S’well is a supreme version of the regular bottles — the kind of thing people normally wouldn’t buy for themselves.
“My son-in-law gives incredible gifts and puts so much thought into everything he does. One gift that I loved was my Loro Piana cashmere throw. I’m always cold — my family jokes that I even wear cashmere in August — and I wear the shawl year-round as a throw over a cocktail dress, or with my coat on cold winter nights.” —Rosa Capacchione, Manhasset, New York, mother-in-law for five years
“I’m also an avid golfer, and last year, my son-in-law got me a Garmin GPS golf watch, which is the perfect accessory on the golf course. The watch can do a lot more than what I use it for, so I’m sure other golfers would get more out of it, but for my purposes, it’s perfect.” —Capacchione
Golfers always need more balls. If they’re pink, you always know which one is yours.
A book of family photos
“For a recent birthday, my adult children (including my daughter-in-law and two sons-in-law) gave me a hardbound book with our family’s portrait on the front. The book includes beautiful pictures from a photo shoot arranged while we were together for one of our five annual family weekend holidays. Since my children and grandchildren live in different states, this book sits on top of the open kitchen bar top across from our front door, welcoming us.” —Robin Inwald, New York City, mother-in-law for five years
“My daughter-in-law is one of the kindest and most thoughtful individuals and puts her personal touch on each and every gift, from specific occasions to times when she knows I could use some encouragement. She’s given personalized blankets, with a matching pillow.” —Karla Ingle, Loudon, Tennessee, mother-in-law for one year
“Before my son and his now-wife were even engaged, she gave me a charm for the Pandora bracelet my sons gave me for Christmas. It was a giraffe. Valerie put an awful lot of thought into this gift. She found out I liked giraffes, and found this one, and it was the first charm I had for that bracelet — and it is still my favorite. She knows me well. She gets me.” —Jean Ericson, Beverly Hills, Michigan, mother-in-law for five years
The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best women’s jeans, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, ultra-flattering pants, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.
Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.