While it seems that the worst of the polar vortex is over, there’s still quite a bit of winter left, which means you’ll want to keep long underwear in your arsenal. These next couple of weeks aren’t going to get any warmer, so we got in touch with gear experts, undergarment designers, textile savants, and snowboarding stylists to come up with a list of some of the best long underwear and base layers out there. Below, the 24 best pairs that you can buy online.
According to Sarah Savala, gear expert at Park City-based outdoor store Backcountry, merino wool is always a reliable choice for frigid temperatures. “My number-one recommendation for long underwear is merino wool,” she says. “It wicks moisture away from your body, which makes it extremely breathable and odor-resistant. It’s an active fiber that reacts to your body temperature, which will keep you warm in cold weather and cool in warm weather, making it versatile to wear year-round. Unlike traditional wool, merino is very soft and feels very nice against your skin.” These leggings from Mons Royale are made from a 100 percent lightweight merino wool that’s ideal for layering.
Danuzia, a stylist and fitter at Paragon Sports, also recommends Icebreaker for its merino wool base layers and likes that they are anti-microbial, soft, non-itchy, great at regulating temperature, washable, and quick to dry. This long-sleeved crewneck top is great for layering. As Danuzia notes, “Layers should be form-fitting; not tight and not loose.”
According to REI’s category merchandising manager Shelly Wilkinson, the best long underwear for extreme weather is Smartwool’s Merino 250. “It’s a mid-weight merino wool base-layer option that helps maintain comfort whether the climate is warm, cold, or in-between,” she says. “Merino 250 is the warmest base-layer option that Smartwool offers. There are many silhouette options” in both tops and bottoms. These leggings are breathable and odor-resistant. Savala and Danuzia also love Smartwool’s merino long underwear.
A natural alternative to woolen long underwear is base layers made from thermasilk. Daniel at Panda Sport in Brooklyn recommends Terramar for its lightweight and stretchy clothing. These leggings are made from 100 percent filament silk and are machine-washable.
Panda Sport also recommends Hot Chillys’s long underwear for both outdoor activities and everyday winter dressing. These leggings are mid-weight and are made from the company’s “micro-elite chamois,” which offers a four-way stretch, odor control, and moisture-wicking technology.
Wilkinson’s pick for the best base layer for outdoor activities is Odlo, one of REI’s most technical brands. “Their new Performance Light collection wicks moisture and dries fast for comfort during high-intensity outings,” she says. “Seamless integrated ventilation zones offer added breathability, and the design provides freedom of movement for comfort during activity.” This crewneck T-shirt is slim-fitting for non-bulky layering.
Another base-layer brand that Wilkinson recommends is by Kari Traa, “a three-time Olympic freestyle skier who started the brand because she felt there was a lack of choices for women with style and function.” Launched in Norway in 2006, the brand is now available in the U.S. “It is a brand ‘for girls by girls,’ with a strong color palette, fun prints, and unmistakable design,” says Wilkinson. “Best known in the U.S. for its fun base-layer collection, which is mostly wool blends, the brand also offers a collection of outerwear and accessories.” These color-blocked leggings are made from a lightweight merino wool with four-way stretch.
For another ski slope-approved look, celebrity stylist Jasmine Caccamo recommends Sweaty Betty leggings. “My favorite base layers the last few seasons have been from Sweaty Betty,” she says. “As a snowboarder and obvious lover of fashion, [I] need long underwear that is both functional and fashionable. [The brand’s] heat-regulating base layers not only keep you warm under your snow gear or day-to-day looks, but also are super flattering and fashionable on their own.”
When Carolyn Yim isn’t wearing the merino knit leggings she designed for PLY–KNITS to stay warm, she swears by Patagonia’s Capilene thermals, which the brand calls its most versatile base-layer bottoms. “Their commitment to responsible sourcing is really neat,” she says. “For instance, these thermals are made from 92 percent recycled PET bottles. When you grow out of them, you donate them back to Patagonia’s Common Threads program, which will recycle them again into another new garment. Being able to recycle a garment twice or more is a big deal, because it is hard to keep the fibers stable enough after multiple recycling processes.” Primary Essentials owner Lauren Snyder agrees: “I like Patagonia [thermals] because they really do work and they last. I still have pairs that I’ve had for years.”
A pair of yoga leggings can do the trick, too. “I know many people swear by merino wool, but I am very sensitive to wool,” says Heather Wilson, director of marketing at the Comfort Sock. “I like Athleta because it’s made from polyester that feels like soft cotton, and includes a silver salt application that keeps it from getting smelly. Warm, soft, and odor-free — yes, please!”
For something more appropriate for everyday wear, Iva Pawling, co-founder and CEO of underwear brand Richer Poorer, recommends Uniqlo’s Heattech line of thermals. “The last time I bought long underwear was on a freezing-cold trip to NYC, so I got the extra-warm Heattech from Uniqlo,” she says. “These are super thin, so they were easy to wear under jeans and saved my built-for-70-degrees self!”
Celebrity stylist Krisana Sotelo also recommends Uniqlo’s Heattech leggings for layering: “I love the Uniqlo Heattech for layering because they have different warmth varieties, breathable and comfortable fabric. It’s perfect for those extremely cold winter days. It is also very easy on the wallet.”
Celebrity stylist Ashley Pruitt swears by Hanro’s leggings: “Hanro makes great products. I love these because they’re not bulky under pants, and when you’re inside they don’t overheat. Bottom line, when you need to be warm running around, they’re great without constraint.” Made of a blend of wool and silk, these thin but warm pants move with you.
“I’m pretty simple and unsexy when it comes to long underwear. I stick with men’s because I steal my husband’s,” says Garmentory founder Adele Tetangco, who loves men’s long underwear by Hemen. “These are perfect for the cold weather because it feels like you’re wearing two extra layers of skin. Makes all the difference. They say size down for women.”
The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best women’s jeans, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, ultra-flattering pants, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.
Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.