In our advice column, Ask the Strategist, we take your most burning shopping questions and scour friends, call up experts, and draw from personal experience to answer them. As always, please comment with one of your own — we’re here to help.
Question: I’m looking for a cashmere zip hoodie that is not too long and will work for a shorter woman (I’m five-foot-one).
There are few phrases that evoke cozy luxury quite like “cashmere hoodie.” An upgrade on your basic zip-up, it’s perfect for long flights, lounging around at home, or even battling ice-cold office air-conditioning. But for petite women out there, like you and me (I’m even shorter than you!), this sleek staple can look schlumpy if it’s too long or oversize. Your question inspired me to hit the streets and try on a bunch of cashmere hoodies in search of the most petite-friendly.
Ending right at the waistband of my jeans and not a centimeter lower, this feels like the just-right hoodie of petite dreams. The cashmere is soft and warm and has enough thickness to be your only outer layer on a brisk fall day. It’s formfitting with a minimal, polished look. Aritzia caters to petites with sizes going down to XXS, and they actually offer a “long” cashmere hoodie that’s more in line with other brands’ regular lengths. The only downside? No pockets for keeping your hands warm.
If your hoodie doesn’t have to be 100 percent cashmere, and you really like the idea of having pockets, I’d probably go with the Splendid option. It’s only 5 percent cashmere (the rest of the blend is made up of rayon, nylon, and polyester), but it’s as soft to the touch as the purer options, and it’s just the right length. It’s a little thinner than the Aritzia hoodie, so not quite as warm, but it’ll be fine for wearing indoors or on mild days.
This one narrowly inches into the runners-up category despite two notable flaws. (1) The sleeves are baggy, which could overwhelm a smaller frame, and (2) the thick drawstring of the hood give it a decidedly more casual look than some of the other hoodies (especially in contrasting white), which could be a deal-breaker if you want something you can dress up. However, the extra warm, hefty cashmere makes this one of the comfier options, and it is definitely short — in the same range as the two listed above. If you’re looking for a boxy, lounge-centric hoodie, I’d recommend this one.
With a hint of wool (it’s 95 percent cashmere and 5 percent wool) this is a solidly warm and thick hoodie. The rib-knit details on the hem and sleeves give it a more athletic vibe. Unfortunately, falling at around the midpoint of my back jeans pockets, it’s not going to give you that hip-skimming look.
I own and really like last year’s version of this hoodie and would have immediately recommended it if I didn’t get a chance to try out some more hoodies and learn that there are much shorter options out there. It hits about midway down my butt, so it isn’t among the shortest, but it’s incredibly cozy. One caveat, though, is that the one I have was made from a thicker cashmere, and now it’s only available in the thinner — but more affordable — “everyday” cashmere. Not shabby by any means, but not one of the warmest choices. And it is a 100 percent cashmere hoodie under $200, which is nothing to sneer at.
I’d say this hoodie is very similar to the J.Crew version in terms of length, thickness, and even price (although it’s currently 30 percent off, which makes it the cheapest option if you act fast). It’s also one of a few hoodies available in colors besides black and gray. Granted there are only two other options (a heathered ivory called “ash” and a soft lavender), but if you do want to break out of the dark winter hues, these are refreshing alternatives.
And a wild card
Depending on what you’re looking for in a cashmere hoodie, this could either be the overall winner or not even on the list. If you’re going for shortness above all else, ignore everything you’ve already read and just buy this hoodie. It’s cropped, which puts it in its own category. It’s easily shorter than anything else in this post, not even reaching the hip and with side slits that, as you can see on the model on the site, reveal a little midriff.
But for me, personally, it just doesn’t feel in the spirit of a classic cashmere hoodie designed for ultimate comfort. I feel the same way about this hoodie as I do these calf-hair Rick Owens x Birkenstock sandals: Objectively, they’re very cool, but do you wear them when it’s warm enough for sandals or cold enough for fur? If you don’t share my hang-ups, though, by all means go for this one. Longer in the back, it’s a very now cropped style, not at all like the midriff-baring velour Juicy jackets of the early aughts.
The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.
Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.