The Cheap Shave Butter That Makes Me Feel Like a Leg Model

By
Best Shaving Cream for Women
Gave me the closest shave I’ve ever experienced.

Shaving has never been easy for me. For years, I’d get crazy razor rash every time I shaved (thank you, thick Italian hair and sensitive skin), which would have to heal before I could attempt to shave again. Though there was a time I could let my hairy legs hibernate for winter, I recently moved to Los Angeles, land of sunshine and bare skin. I knew I’d found a solution when I discovered Dr. Carver’s Easy Shave Butter from Dollar Shave Club, the only shaving product that’s let me shave multiple times a week without turning my legs into a minefield of razor bumps.

The Shave Butter formula is indeed buttery — using the stuff feels almost like moisturizing. Compared to the drying, floral-scented shave-cream cans of my past, the experience is practically luxurious. The real difference is that the cream doesn’t lather, so it doesn’t feel like it’s ever stripping my legs of protective oils. I can even glide over the same spot a few times without repercussion.

Another thing: Shave Butter slathers on clear and thick, so I can actually see the hair I’m trying to vanquish, which is crucial for catching missed spots without having to go over my entire leg. Coupled with the 4X Dollar Shave Club Razor Blade, it’s the closest shave I’ve ever experienced. In fact, the first time I experienced the Shave Butter with the razor, I ran my own hands over my legs, marveling at their soft, shiny surface like I was auditioning for a Nair commercial.

My only regret is that I can’t buy this product in a giant tub. It only comes in six ounces and an even measlier travel size, but here’s a trick — buy an $11 bundle of the regular and travel size, and you get just a bit more bang for your buck.

More Strat-approved shaving tools

Writer Fiona Byrne swears by the hair-removing effects of the Braun epilator: “And the smoothness, you guys, the smoothness! It feels like your legs have never even grown hair! Are there red spots after like with waxing? Sure, but only for one night, and when you wake up in the morning, it’s just smooth, clear, Mr. Bigglesworth–bald legs.”

According to the Cut’s beauty editor, Kathleen Hou, these tiny Japanese facial razors are “small enough to fit under your chin, with enough of an edge to remove peach fuzz, yet not so sharp that they’ll nick you.”

Writer Allison Schmidt made a real discovery when she found the Weishi safety razor on Reddit: “You have no idea how life-changing it was using it for the first time. All the irritation that I got with other hair-removal systems was gone. I learned that because there is only one blade crossing your skin, it’s less irritating than five blades (one after the other after the other) going over the same spot.”

The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best women’s jeans, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, ultra-flattering pants, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.

The Cheap Shave Butter That Makes Me Feel Like a Leg Model