Lately, I’ve been getting the same question over and over, from friends and strangers on the internet alike: “Do you have a recommendation for a good lipstick that creates a blotted look?” I understand the appeal: sheer lipsticks let your natural lip color peek through while elevating your everyday makeup, allowing you to feel just a tad more put together without having to commit to a full-on lipstick look (plus, they’re much easier to eat with).
The brands, it seems, are listening to the people — I’ve noticed a surge of sheer lipstick tints hitting the market in the last couple of months. I decided to put three of the most popular options from three cult-favorite beauty brands — Milk Makeup, Ohii, and Glossier — to the test (which are, by the way, all vegan). That way, you can decide which is right for you. Or, if you’re a nut like me, you can decide you need them all.
Glossier’s Gen G, the OG of trendy sheer lipsticks, is a super-matte formula that gives your lips a hint of powdery, soft color. Or in other words: This product makes it look like you applied a full coat of lipstick, and blotted most of the pigment away on a napkin. I’ve long loved these lipsticks — the berry-colored Jam, and the light, cool pink shade Like are some of my everyday staples. But I’ve found that the formula is a tad drying, so I always moisturize my lips before applying Gen G with my Bite Beauty Agave Lip Balm.
I am so obsessed with the formula of these new Ohii lip tints. Unlike Gen G, which is super-matte and powdery, these lip smudges are waxy and smooth. And if Glossier is a lipstick look blotted down, these lip smudges are your natural lips but better. As my friend Joelle put it, “These lipsticks make your lips look like you’ve eaten a popsicle that happens to be the perfect color for your mouth.” This is perhaps the most flattering lip tint I’ve ever tried in my life — they’re matte but not too drying and give your lips that effortless tint of color that I’m constantly striving for. I also happen to be in love with every one of the colors of Ohii’s Lip Smudge and have been wearing them all daily — I’m currently wearing Punch, which is a gorgeous bubble-gum-pink shade.
These Kush balms from Milk Makeup are awesome twofers — they give your lips a smudgy, soft tint, and have mango butter, cocoa, and shea butter in the formula, which means these are easily the most smoothing and hydrating of the bunch. The balms aren’t matte — they make lips look a little shiny and glisten-y — but they’re just as low-maintenance and flattering as the two listed above. Generally, I put on Gen G or Lip Smudge when I leave the house, then touch my lips up throughout the day with my Milk Makeup Kush Lip Tint, so that my lips stay soft and hydrated with a pretty pop of color all day long. I personally love the berry shade Plushberry and the pinky-rose shade Bubble. If you wear Glossier’s Jam, Kush Lips Plushberry is a similar color for touch-ups throughout the day. If you wear Ohii’s Scorpio, Nug is your best bet.
The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.