strat investigates

What’s the Next Unicorn Toy Craze?

Photo: Courtesy of the retailers.

Somewhere around the summer of 2014, I noticed that my cousin’s 6-year-old daughter was in possession of a plastic bin shimmering with My Little Pony unicorns, not unlike the ones I hoarded in the 1980s and 1990s. At the time, this didn’t really surprise me: us nostalgic millennials have fueled the rebirths of all sorts of totems from our youth, particularly those that happen to be especially Instagrammable.

What did surprise me was what came next: all manner of unicorns started showing up wherever you might find a child: in the bathtub, at the breakfast table, on the underside of anything with a hood. We had reached peak unicorn mania when Fast Company published a piece that declared as much back in May 2017, a few weeks after my son was born. Well, he’s 18 months old now, and — peak, schmeak — I’m here to tell you about a 2-year-old’s unicorn-themed birthday we were invited to just last month (North West, incidentally, recently celebrated turning five in the same way). I also realized that going to the party would require zero advance planning: literally any kids’ store on the way there would inevitably carry something on-theme, be it a baseball cap or a sweatshirt or a face mask. Or I could have just brought along the brush-away sequin unicorn my son already owns — I took it from the free table at work, after it was left there, surely, by a fellow editor suffering from understandable unicorn fatigue.

Unicorns are simply not going away. “It’s been at least two years,” says kid stylist Michel Onofrio of this never-ending carousel ride. Not since the meme-driven cat craze of the early 2010s has Onofrio seen such demand for a particular genre of creature. According to Google Frightgeist data, unicorns were the third-most trending Halloween costume this year, up from number four last year. And none of the experts I spoke to seem to think the unicorn craze will dwindle anytime soon. But many of them can still point to a few creatures (and here we’re talking broad realms of animals, real and supernatural, rather than specific characters like Mickey and Harry Potter) that are gathering some fandom of their own. Even though they may well ultimately be left in the unicorn dust this season, at least these gifts have the added value of making you look slightly more original in the eyes of your youngster giftees. Here are the contenders.

Narwhals

“Quote me on this: 2019 will be the year of the narwhal,” said a shop clerk named Tess at the Balloon Saloon in New York, in disagreement with her colleague behind the register who was in the midst of telling me that nothing could be as popular as their unicorn balloons. Jenn Cattaui, owner of New York baby boutique Babesta, also mentioned the narwhal as an obvious successor to the unicorn. It doesn’t hurt that they’re known as the “unicorns of the sea.”

Douglas Rainbow Narwhal
$18 at Amazon

In the same way that unicorns and rainbows go together, so can narwhals and rainbows.

Cuddle Toys Narwhal Bubbles Toy
$15 at Amazon

An even fuzzier version.

Gund Narwhal Plush Toy
$15 at Saks

For the kid who’s more realistic.

Slumberkins Narwhal Snuggler Stuffed Animal
$36 at Nordstrom

And for naptime: a narwhal that’s practically a blanket.

Kololo Giant Narwhal Inflatable Pool Float
$35 at Amazon

The most ironclad evidence of the narwhal’s forthcoming dominance might be that for its latest pool float, the company that made the Instagram-ubiquitous inflatable unicorn decided to make a giant narwhal.

Llamas

At the boutique Ever After, which is like Intermix for the pint-sized (and is also teeming with unicorn stuff, like these Magi-Cool earbuds, this light-up glitter lamp, and this bath-burst set), I asked a saleswoman what other animals customers were interested in. Her one and only answer was llamas: llama sequin pillows, llama furry notebooks, llama eye masks.

Sandy Ruben, a sales rep and edPlay magazine trends columnist, confirmed this observation — which has been written about elsewhere, like in this article in The Guardian — saying that as part of his research, he conducts a bimonthly survey among kid retailers. As of a year ago, llamas weren’t even popular enough to be an option for a popular toy category on his survey, but since then have steadily climbed their way up to number four on the list. (Not surprisingly, Ruben also notes that unicorns are in no way slowing down as the far-and-away winner, every single time.) And, anecdotally, the bestselling Llama Llama book series is now an animated Netflix show, featuring the voice of Jennifer Garner.

Douglas Toys Lollipop Llamacorn Rainbow Stuffed Animal Toy
$30 at Amazon

Again, getting a rainbow version of the animal in question seems to be a perennial option.

Ann Williams Craft-tastic Yarn Llama Kit
$22 at The Paper Store

One of Ruben’s favorite holiday gifts is this llama craft kit.

Sock it to Me Toddler Knee Bundle
$20 at Maisonette

It’s also a good sign that they recently proved themselves worthy of a place alongside unicorns and rainbows in the latest sock set at Maisonette.

Furry Llama Pillow
$49 at Urban Outfitters

A pillow that’s basically a stuffed animal, but with an intricately beautiful blanket saddle.

Klutz Sew Your Own Furry Llama Pillow
$21 at Amazon

You can also sew your own llama pillow, if you wish.

Swans

This one is a very early call, Cattaui admits, but as she and her buyers look at what’s percolating among the more forward-thinking fashion brands, they’ve noticed something: the swan. The forthcoming interpretations of it remind Cattaui of the unicorn feel she had a few years ago. She pointed me to examples like this swan bomber jacket, a Dutch-made swan night-light, and this European Design Award–winning swan cushion. (And then once you start looking, you’ll also notice a little bit of swan all around: swan rockerswan dress, swan chain-mail purse, swan piggy bank, swan head wall decor …) To Cattaui, the swan also signals a similar potential for gender neutrality. (She found that mermaids never really hit in the way she thought they might, with the wave of fervor over the mermaid frapuccino and all, and suspects that’s because the aesthetic, even when you call it “merman,” simply doesn’t feel as inclusive as a unicorn or an animal.)

Jellycat Mad Pet Solange Swan
$40 at Amazon

The large-sized version of this swan is a full 27-inches tall.

Swan Lake Circus Dress
$60 at Nordstrom

For the budding ballerina.

Swan Bank
$20 at Nordstrom

For a mini savings account.

Swan Head Wall Décor
$17 at Target

And for hanging on the wall, trophy-style.

And if you just want more unicorn toys

My Little Pony The Movie Magic of Everypony Roundup
$18 at Target

The tiny ponies that reignited the craze in the first place.

SunnyLife Unicorn Neon Light
$33 at Shopbop

With no end in sight, even more unicorn paraphernalia is popping up — like this neon sign that’s suitable for adults as well as kids…

Unicorn Horns Sidewalk Chalk
$15 at Maisonette

… and this sidewalk chalk, which also works for unicorn fans of all ages.

Unstable Unicorns Base Game
$20 at Amazon

There’s even a unicorn board game that is one of the 50 most-backed Kickstarter projects of all time.

Poopsie Slime Surprise Unicorn-Rainbow Bright Star Oopsie Starlight
$50 at Amazon

Another recent trend within the trend is what Cattaui calls “unicorn plus gross”: Surely you’ve seen or heard of the Poopsie Surprise Unicorns that let you make toy unicorn poop. If that sounds both absurd and unappetizing, consider that the chief toy officer of the Toy Insider and The Toy Book told us that they’re selling out fast.

Hasbro Don’t Step In It Game Unicorn Edition
$80 at Walmart

Or, conversely, you can play a game of trying not to step in unicorn poop.

Unicorn Snot Glitter Sunscreen
$24 at Always Fits

You can even slather yourself in unicorn snot glitter sunscreen.

The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.

What’s the Next Unicorn Toy Craze?