i'm not a professional. just crazy.

This Soft Brown Eye Definer Instantly Made Me an Eyeliner Person

Rio's eyes (and eyeliner) — the Strategist reviews Kevyn Aucoin's Precision Eye Definer.
A cat-eye in three minutes flat. Photo: Rio Viera-Newton

I’ve always been obsessed with eyeliner. Both a quick shading of your waterline or a full-on cat eye can drastically define your eyes, making them instantly appear bigger and brighter. The problem: I am very bad with eyeliner. My unsteady hands make a sleek line nearly impossible to achieve, and I rub my eyes so often that any product smears within minutes. As a result, I’ve long steered clear of eyeliners.

However, recently determined to integrate eyeliners into my routine, I decided to investigate brown eyeliners. Subbing out the jet-black eyeliners in my makeup bag for softer brown shades seemed like it would be more forgiving on my clumsy hands and itchy eyes. I went to a Space NK and was immediately attracted to the Precision Eye Pencil in the shade Kobicha from Kevyn Aucoin. The Kevyn Aucoin precision eyebrow pencil and eye gloss are among some of my Holy Grails, but it was the soft wax formula of this eyeliner — and the Space NK employee gushing about it — that had me sold in about ten seconds.

Kevyn Aucoin Precision Eye Definer
$32 at Sephora

This pencil is a dream. The soft formula that glides on with absolutely no tug, making quick lining very easy. The brown shade is dark enough to provide serious definition, but light enough that if it smudges or flakes a bit, it gives a soft, smoky effect rather than making you look like an emo kid. The first time I used this pencil, I was able to give both my eyes a cat-eye in about three minutes — something I have never ever been able to do in the past. This liner also doesn’t budge, even on the hottest and sweatiest August days. And now, I’ve quickly gone from avoiding eyeliners altogether to integrating them into my everyday routine. One thing I will mention: Read the instructions before stressing about how little product comes in the packaging. There’s an unusual mechanism for dispensing more product: Instead of twisting the bottom or simply sharpening it, you push down on the tip of the applicator and more pops out.

To complete the look

Glossier Lash Slick
$16 at Glossier

Another great product for people who tend to rub their eyes like crazy. This, in conjunction with the Kevyn Aucoin pencil, are now two of my go-to eye products for avoiding panda eyes.

Kevyn Aucoin Precision Brow Pencil
$26 at Sephora

This is an extremely thin, precise pencil from Kevyn Aucoin. Delicate and soft, you can give your brows a really natural fill, or a dramatic reshaping.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Eyeshadow in Caramel
$12 at Sephora

If you want to add some extra warmth to your eyes, tap on some of this brown eye shadow from Anastasia before you line your lashes. This will give your look a really pretty, smoky brown effect.

The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.

This Eye Definer Instantly Made Me an Eyeliner Person