Few things relax me more than thoroughly cleansing my face after a long, tough day — there’s a certain satisfaction in splashing cold water on my face and watching the makeup and dirt melt off. But, for New Yorkers at least, cleansing isn’t done solely for meditative purposes. Between the muggy weather, ghastly subway rides, and constant human contact, my skin is exposed on the daily to an unthinkable amount of dirt and germs, making my daily scrub-down extremely necessary. And I have evidence to back this up: When I slip up and sleep in my makeup (this does not happen often, I can assure you) I will, without fail, wake up with a major breakout.
Recently, people are voicing some skepticism over cleansing, and whether it will strip away natural skin oils. Is it even really necessary? these people ask. My answer: Umm, yeah! You must wash your face, especially if you live in the city, and double especially if you are acne-prone or have oily skin.
I tend to overheat and sweat in my sleep, so I wash my face twice daily. If you have very dry skin, just skip out on the morning wash — when you wake up you have not yet been exposed to the outside world and all its grime.
There is no universally “perfect cleanser,” because different skin types require different formulas. I have dry, acne-prone, sensitive skin, so I can only represent that skin type. However, after doing diligent research on Reddit and YouTube, and quizzing a few of my trusted peers (with various skin types), I’ve put together a comprehensive list of some of the most beloved and effective cleansers on the market.
Dry or sensitive skin
Since my skin is both dry and sensitive, and since I find that the two often go hand in hand, I’ve grouped them together for simplicity’s sake. I’ve searched high and low for a cleansing milk that is as spectacular as Biologique’s, and even though I’ve found some pretty convincing dupes, this has, and probably will always, hold the No. 1 spot when it comes to cleansing my dry-ass, sensitive, blemish-prone skin. This cleanser hydrates and soothes intensely, and while it doesn’t actively fight against rashes or blemishes, it preps skin perfectly for serums. I’ve heard some complaints that this cleanser doesn’t do an incredible job of removing makeup. This is true: When I come home with a full face of makeup after a night out, I go in with micellar water first.
When I’m in need of a slightly less expensive substitute for the Biologique, I sub in this cleansing milk from Nuxe. Similarly gentle, this cleanser delicately washes away any dirt and grime without breaking you out or stripping your skin of its natural oils. This is the perfect I’m-scared-of-cleansers cleanser to start on if you have dry skin. Biologique can be kind of a pain to find, both in person and online, so I order this on Jet when I just don’t feel like going through the hoopla.
Though I don’t have oily skin, even I can appreciate the wonders of this pH-balanced gel cleanser from the beloved brand Cosrx. If your skin is oily, this cleanser will prep your skin for the day by providing you with the perfect amount of pH, meaning it ensures nice, soft skin but also preps for whatever toner or essence you’re putting on next.
I read about how good this cleanser is for oily skin on Reddit’s r/AsianBeauty. There were hundreds (seriously) of testimonials about how wonderfully purifying this cleanser is for those with acne and excess oil.
This gold-star favorite can be found in virtually every Japanese drugstore, and people rave about it in my skin-care group chat (yes, my friends and I have a group chat about skin care). Not only does this oil do a great job of removing makeup, it also happens to be one of the best products for getting rid of stubborn blackheads. Why? I’m not so sure — its Dermstore description claims that its “water-soluble formula removes pore-clogging impurities.” But if you don’t trust the marketing lingo, trust the group chat: My friends have assured me that this stuff is a must-have if blackheads are an issue for you.
Combination skin — where some areas of your skin are dry and others oily — can make picking a cleanser a pain. My recommendation: Instead of using two different kinds of cleansers on two different parts of your face (because really, who has time for that?) buy something that gently tackles both issues. This hypoallergenic balm won’t dry you out, but it won’t make you oily, and it also happens to do a seriously good job at removing makeup. I’ve used it and can swear that I’ve never broken out from it.
I’ve used the cream version of this and fell in love: It really brightened, plumped, and hydrated my skin. This oil version is better for combination skin, because it does all that good work without supplying the extreme hydration an oily-skinned person needs to avoid. And though it’s not the most conditioning, I can personally attest that it’s not drying.
When I say “normal” skin, I’m talking about those who are blessed with the kind of skin that produces an average amount of sebum. That’s what we’re all trying to attain with our cleansers, so since you already have that, you should be looking for a cleanser that’s very gentle, and not hydrating or exfoliating. This Neogen foam cleanser has green tea properties that brighten skin and it effectively washes away impurities like sweat and dirt, without drying you out.
This very gentle, very neutral face cleanser from Fresh is a Sephora fan favorite. It’s light, calming, and refreshing, and does a good job of cleansing without stripping oils or giving your skin a weird, overly conditioned feel. Cleansing and nourishing but not overbearing, this is the perfect middle ground for an (extremely lucky) normal-skinned person.
The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best women’s jeans, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, ultra-flattering pants, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.
Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.