Self editor Lucy Danziger admitted last week that Kelly Clarkson's September cover was retouched. Apparently this became a big deal on the Internet, which is curious because magazines digitally altering photos, especially cover photos, is hardly news. But Danziger seized the opportunity to defend her magazine's use of retouching with a thorough blog post on the subject. She argues retouching is not unlike editing vacation photos: "I keep the pix that show us all happy and glowing and laughing and playing, not the ones where we are scowling or hungry or tired." Except the difference with those vacation photos is that's where the editing stops — they won't then be digitally slenderized. Nor will millions of people see them.
When Danziger decided to run a photo of herself after she completed a marathon five years ago, she had her hips slimmed. "I am confident in my body, proud of what it can accomplish, but it just didn't look the way I wanted in every picture," she writes. Well, does anyone ever?
Danziger explains what typically goes into digital retouching:
[W]e mark up the photograph to correct any awkward wrinkles in the blouse, flyaway hair and other things that might detract from the beauty of the shot. This is art, creativity and collaboration. It's not, as in a news photograph, journalism. It is, however, meant to inspire women to want to be their best. That is the point.
Except at our "best" we can never ensure we don't have awkward flyaways or bulging hips or other things that detract from our beauty. It's called being human, and it's something that, thanks to the culture of Photoshop, many women must work to accept rather than choosing to aspire to impossible ideals. Danziger writes of the Clarkson cover:
Did we alter her appearance? Only to make her look her personal best. Did we publish an act of fiction? No. Not unless you think all photos are that. But in the sense that Kelly is the picture of confidence, and she truly is, then I think this photo is the truest we have ever put out there on the newsstand.
We could go on for hours enumerating the flaws in this reasoning. But why couldn't Danziger just come out and say: "You know what? My goal is to sell magazines. We Photoshopped her because in this day and age it feels impossible to do that without retouching. Readers have grown accustomed to looking at inhuman ideals of beauty, and looking at someone in a magazine who hasn't been digitally improved has become more abnormal than looking at a normal person."
Pictures that please us [Lucy's Blog/Self]
Most Viewed Stories
Meryl Streep Issues Scathing Response to Karl Lagerfeld’s Oscar Dress Comments (UPDATED)
Rereading The Handmaid’s Tale, One Month Into the Trump Era
Why Did Everyone Act Like I Was Crazy When I Decided to Have a Baby in My 20s?
Woman Framed by Ex-Boyfriend’s Wife in Craigslist ‘Rape Fantasy’ Plot Speaks Out
Why Red-Carpet Makeup Looks Bad in Real Life
Missoni Grabs Back with Knitted Pink Pussy Hats at Milan Fashion Week
Barbara Pierce Bush to Speak at Texas Planned Parenthood Fundraiser
Taylor Swift Is Not Going to Be Happy About This New Friendship
How Celebrities Dressed Before ‘the Red Carpet’ Became a Juggernaut
Why the Casey Affleck Sexual-Harassment Allegations Just Won’t Stick
Latest News from The CutBehold, Amy Schumer’s Fabulous Alexander McQueen Duvet Coat
The comedian wore a marabou-trimmed duvet coat on her morning coffee run, because why not?Dolce and Gabbana Put On One of the Most Epic Shows Of All Time
People were cheering as Austin Mahone performed.Watch the Salvatore Ferragamo Livestream
Enjoy!Watch a Definitive Snapshot of the Past 20 Years of Costume Design Winners
All in one place.Meryl Streep Issues Scathing Response to Karl Lagerfeld’s Oscar Dress Comments (UPDATED)
Do not come for Meryl.Missoni Grabs Back with Knitted Pink Pussy Hats at Milan Fashion Week
Audience members and models alike sported knitted pink pussy hats.Barbara Pierce Bush to Speak at Texas Planned Parenthood Fundraiser
Don’t mess with Texas women.Extremely Handsome Oscar Nominee Mahershala Ali Is Now a Hot Dad
Mahershala Ali and Amatus Sami-Karim’s baby was born earlier this week.Selena Gomez Is the Weeknd’s VIP at His Amsterdam Concert
Their globetrotting romance continues.Sergio Rossi Brought Sleek Heels and Smoky Mirrors to Milan
Sergio Rossi’s Winter 2017/18 line gets the high-tech treatment in this video.
“Women are seeing themselves and are feeling beautiful about their bodies.”Laverne Cox: “Trans Rights Are Women’s Rights”
On bell hooks and more.Watch the Bottega Veneta Livestream
Enjoy!This Man Probably Knows More About Makeup Than You Do
A quick chat with Instagram’s favorite male makeup artist.See Marina Abramovic’s Greatest Moments in the Art World
Her first extensive monograph comes out next month.Let Martha Stewart’s Story About Her New Peacock Soothe You
Xanax in blog form.Designers Agree: Red Is the Color for Fall 2017
It’s more than just a trend, it’s a movement.People Everywhere Agree That Justin Trudeau Has a Good Butt
An image of the Canadian prime minister’s butt has gone viral.Leonardo DiCaprio Is Definitely Hiding His Oscar in This Fanny Pack
What else could be in there?When Dating Younger Men Becomes a Sexual Crusade
On this week’s podcast: Cindy Gallop reinvented her career so everyone could have better sex.