Gifts we’re interested in getting this holiday season: a Miu Miu Hobo bag; an hour of Tim Gunn’s time in which he complains to us (in iambic pentameter) about liars. What we’d rather not receive: paper slippers. For this week’s challenge — explained by L.A. Times fashion critic Booth Moore, looking disconcertingly like a soccer mom — the designers had to construct garments entirely out of newspaper. They were allowed to incorporate dye and muslin into their designs, and Tim even gave them a pep talk about the history of paperwear, dating back to 1968 (at which time it still didn’t look any comfier). Everyone is a bit confounded, yet most of the designers embrace the challenge, using pictures and patterns creatively. And then there’s Johnny. His first dress is scrapped after Tim calls it a “craft project gone awry.” Then, after a few hours doing a crossword puzzle, Johnny tells his model that the first dress was ruined by an overactive steamer. Nicolas calls bullshit on this fabrication (pun intended!), going so far as to confront Johnny on the runway when he repeats the bogus story. The most wonderful moment of the evening comes right after Johnny exits, with Tim's surprisingly harsh, yet beautifully poetic, judgment. “I’m incredulous of that utterly preposterous spewing of fiction that Johnny did on the runway. It’s ridiculous!” An amazing line from an amazing man. And now a look at the final designs, none of which are nearly as entertaining as hearing Tim talk shit behind Johnny’s back.
THE ARCHITECTURAL EMPIRE STATE DRESS
It’s pretty incredible that Althea managed to create this pattern out of newspaper. We love the sheen, and the shape flatters the model’s figure. Guest judge Eva Longoria points out that it “accentuates the bum,” which she views as her “asset.” Sadly, we don’t think she noticed her own semi-clever pun.
WONDER WOMAN ATE A HAIRBALL
Tommy Hilfiger, who’s guest-judging because he has a new Macy’s line, calls this dress “a wow.” And it’s not at all wearable, so of course Zoe Glassner loves it. We like the fitted gray bodice, but the skirt looks like homemade streamers to us.
ARIEL GETS HER LEGS
Taking a cue from her namesake, Daryl Hannah, CH creates a mermaid-inspired ballgown in a bright-orange hue. We had a Calypso skirt that looked just like this our freshman year of college (remember those skirts? They cinched at the waist with a tie, and could be worn different ways), so our nostalgia fills us with positive thoughts about this over-the-top design.
GEISHA WITH A YELLOW HANDBAG
We are confused.
THE POLITICALLY NEUTRAL MINI
Thank God Tim put the kibosh on Gordana’s embarrassing Time to Change statement dress. And yet this tiered mini-halter could have used some spicing up. She’s committed the mortal sin of making a dress “wearable,” and for that she is banished to the bottom three.
Irina — the Winner!
NEWSPAPER IS THE NEW FUR TRENCH Irina was smart to choose a design other than a dress, as her trench stood out among the sheaths. The coat “looks like Coco Chanel meets Laurent meets Givenchy in the sixties and seventies,” says Hilfiger, which doesn’t really make sense, but is a nice compliment. The scotch tape holding the back together is somewhat jarring, but the judges ignore the construction missteps and crown this the winner!
Johnny — the Loser!
THE RED MESS REDUX
In addition to being an egregious liar, Johnny is a horrible designer. Heidi calls this shapeless dress “a mess overall,” and we’re with Eva when she says she doesn’t like the pointy part at the bust line. Johnny says his first dress was “hard core” (it wasn’t), and that it was ruined by a steamer (it wasn’t), and that Nicolas is a jerk (he was).
THE SUSHI WAITRESS IN BLUE
The blue pattern is pretty and the shape of this dress is fine, if not a little boring. That said, we’d remove the half-fans near the bust and bottom, as they’re distracting.
THE HIGH-NECKED TUTU
What is it with Louise and high necklines? There must be some creepy psychological explanation for this obsession. Louise didn’t love this design, and neither do we. The hair rollers stuck to the neck area look mighty uncomfortable. And why is the model wearing pigtails? Cruel.
COCKROACH DOES PUNK
The picture of Nicolas in his “East Village punk” days made us laugh. How is this dress punky? The judges (and we) want to know. Zoe says it looks like an insect, which it does. Also, Nicolas, cool it with the shit-talking. You lost, buddy.
This is our favorite look of the night — the patterns Ra’mon created are very cool, and the fit of the top over the mini really works, proportion-wise. We’d actually wear that paper skirt, though paired with a black top.
THE SKIRT THAT ATE LOS ANGELES
We get what Shirin’s going for with this architectural, origami-like skirt, but it’s just too ginormous.
Most Viewed Stories
25 Famous Women on Childlessness
Blood Hounds: They’re Obsessed With Period Sex
What If You Just Don’t Know If You Want Kids?
What It Felt Like to Get an Epidural After 32 Hours of Labor
10 Men Explain Why They Became Gynecologists
The Most Feminist Moments in Sci-fi History
Tina Fey’s Foolproof Plan to Send Naked Photos That Stay Private
The 50 Most Memorable Eyebrows of All Time
Uniqlo Is Now Paying People’s Harvard Tuition
Gemma Ward Walked in the Prada Show Today
From Our Partners
the secret to mila kunis' eyeliner
3 Ways to Wear Leggings this Fall
Alexa Chung Has the Perfect Summer Hairstyle For Lobs
Latest News on The CutInside the Wedding Convention for Bikers
Scenes from the annual Sturgis bike rally.Look Book: The Dancer With a Cyndi Lauper Vibe
“I really want to meet her someday, so I can be like, 'Look, I look a lot like you, maybe we should hang out or do a photo shoot together or something.'”Meet the College Women Who Are Starting a Revolution Against Campus Sexual Assault
Emma Sulkowicz, who will not put her mattress down until her alleged rapist is expelled, is its new public face.Stranded in Milan: Air France Strike Throws a Wrench Into PFW
How the fashion set is coping.Watch the Emilio Pucci Show Live from Milan
Enjoy!13 More Glamorous Moments From Milan Fashion Week
Life-size Barbies, Amy Adams, Nietzsche, and lollipops.Meet Milan’s Most Successful Young Designer
Massimo Giorgetti's MSGM has skyrocketed since it launched in 2009.Watch the Roberto Cavalli Show Live From Milan
Enjoy!Watch the Salvatore Ferragamo Show Live From Milan
Enjoy!Watch the Marni Show Live From Milan
Jury's out.Why Is It So Hard to Find a Good Word for Your Vagina?
From vajayjay to lady-bits.Versace Piled On the Cutouts and Glitter
An unapologetically girly collection.Street-Style Awards: The 29 Best-Dressed People From MFW, Part 1
Someone has custom-made mink Birkenstocks.Seamless for Birth Control: Why the Heck Not?
Planned Parenthood is disrupting contraception.Kim Kardashian Wants a Role on Downton Abbey
"I love things like that."The Young Designer Shaking Up Italian Fashion
Arthur Arbesser has quickly made a name for himself in Milan.What the 17th Century Can Teach Us About Vaginas
An inside-out penis?Park Slope Moms’ Advice to Kate Middleton: Smoke a Little Pot
Tried-and-true secrets of child rearing.Doutzen Kroes on Fifty Shades of Grey and Working Out
"I was not wearing so many clothes [in the commercial], and he would be like, 'Here, here's a robe.'"
Along with quiet moments at Gucci and Prada.Watch the Versace Show Live From Milan
Enjoy!A Sexy Pencil Skirt for Date Night
Channel your inner Italian bombshell.Editor’s Picks: 5 Things I Liked on Thursday From Milan Fashion Week
Prints galore!Uniqlo Is Now Paying People’s Harvard Tuition
Will they throw in free leggings? Unclear.Going to the Chapel, Getting Married Naked
Be careful where you throw that rice!Kate Hudson Is Now a Self-Proclaimed Medium to the World of the Dead
The "fifth energy."Calvin Klein Was the Biggest NYFW Show on Social Media
Beating out fellow entrants Marc Jacobs and Michael Kors.An Eye Cream That Helps You Fake Drinking Water
And channel Cate Blanchett.Anna Dello Russo Wore Four Bags at Once
The more Moschino, the merrier.
Enjoy!What It Felt Like to Get an Epidural After 32 Hours of Labor
I thought I didn't want one, but I changed my mind.Stop Asking Laurie Penny to Write About Pubes
The U.K. feminist on her new book, Unpseakable Things.The Cool Italian Bag Designer You Should Know
Paula Cademartori on starting her brand, street style, and the challenges of launching a line in Italy.Prada Is Happy to Dress You for the Apocalypse
An Italian take on post-disaster DIY.Are You Even Cool Enough to Use a Flip Phone, Though?
It's not for everyone and it can't be for everyone.The Prada Show Took Place on a Giant Sand Dune
And some people damaged their lace espadrilles.Gemma Ward Walked in the Prada Show Today
Shall we call this a comeback?It Was a Barbie World at Moschino
"For ages 5 and up."Italian Food Critic Admits Brooklyn Has Better Restaurants — But Who Has Better Pizza?
Adam Platt's transatlantic chat with Italian critic Elisia Menduni.
Extreme ombré.See Giovanna Battaglia’s Masterful Italian Style
Dolce & Gabbana dresses, Keds sneakers, and everything in between.The 50 Most Memorable Eyebrows of All Time
Cara Delevingne is only the beginning.Watch the Moschino Show Live From Milan
Enjoy!An Unusual Stapler to Dress Up Your Desk
Way better than that red Swingline from Office Space.Editor’s Picks: 5 Things I Liked on Wednesday From Milan Fashion Week
Grunge and lots of denim.Companies Aren’t Being Such Dweebs About Employee Tattoos
Starbucks, Walmart, and PetSmart acknowledge the ink.15 Women on Their Miscarriages
Fifteen percent of pregnancies end in miscarriage. Why don't we talk more about it?See the Greenwich Hotel’s Sublime Penthouse Gardens
A 4,000-square-foot bilevel terrace that inspires major design lust.Watch the Prada Show Live From Milan