Pencil skirts can be tricky to style. Add a blazer or cardigan, and you run the risk of looking like a corporate drone. Pair it with a feminine top or kitten heels and you could look over-the-top retro. Still, the curve-friendly style looks amazing when worn right, which is why we picked out a $108 black paneled number from BCBG, gave it to up-and-coming model and art-world star Coco Young, and handed over styling duties to the staff members of five of our favorite local boutiques: Pixie Market, Alter, Seven, Edith Machinist, and Patricia Field, who paired the staple item with everything from floaty blouses to Gaga-worthy bustiers (one guess which store was behind that decision). Click through the slideshow to see what each of our impromptu stylists came up with.
Sales associate Meghan Lavery paired the body-con BCBG skirt with a sheer, floaty Shape Shiftr blouse ($187 online). She also dressed Coco Young in a Daydream Nation leather and fur cuff ($99 online) and peep-toe, leopard-print wedges from Shakuhachi ($440 online).
Co-owner Roy Caires wanted to give pencil-skirted model Coco a casual, everyday look, so he dressed her down with OTBT Hutchinson buckled boots ($160), a Cheap Monday tee ($24), and Alter's signature chained scarf ($35) and chain/PVC necklace ($45).
We knew we could count on Seven to make our basic a bit more avant-garde. Sales associate Julian Garcia loaded Coco up with industrial jewelry (including a Gareth Pugh leather and metal hook ring for $135, a FAUX/real black rubber and metal bracelet for $225, and a FAUX/real gold necklace for $235), Raphael Young Eagle One platform booties ($995), and a Mark Fashion bra top ($227.50) that looks as if it were custom-made for this skirt.
Sales associates Moto and Reiko styled Coco in an outfit of Lady Gaga proportions. Our pencil skirt is barely recognizable under all those glittery layers, including an ostrich-feather boa ($85), Bordello Gold Fairy Dust platforms ($88), a Timmy Woods Adam and Eve purse ($260), vinyl top fishnet thigh highs ($14), MiniMini fingerless black leather gloves ($34), a Gasoline Glamour spike ring ($72), an Ophelie sequin UFO hat ($100), a Noir Keith Haring cuff ($168), Bernhard Willhelm ski glasses ($525), a V Moda hourglass corset ($770), and — lastly — a Natasha Midnight Raven bodysuit ($136).
Owner Edith Machinist and sales associate Kim Lease descended upon Coco with armloads of vintage shoes and bags. Eventually, they settled on a sweet floral eighties clutch from Laura Biagiotti ($180) and vintage Ferragamo heels ($235), paired with a forties cotton top ($145), vintage belt ($75), sixties sterling-silver cuff ($305), and sixties sterling-silver ring ($255).
Most Viewed Stories
Everything You Need to Know About Ghost Sex
Dating Naked: The Magic of Meg’s Giant Boobs
Ask Polly: How Am I Supposed to Make Friends in My Late 20s?
How I Turned My Sex Life Into an Exercise Routine
Men, You Can Stop Lying About Your Height
By Choice or Necessity, the Future of Abortions May Be at Home
Kendall Jenner Drops the ‘Jenner’
College Men Finding Not Raping Really Quite Burdensome
7 Men Who Will Renew Your Faith in Tan Suits
This Is the Greatest Invite in Fashion Week History
From Our Partners
10 Wedding Trends That Need To Be Retired (And What To Do Instead)
11 Zara Pieces Just Too Good to Pass Up
4 Sonia Kashuk Cheapies You Should Definitely Buy
Rag & Bone’s Sweatpant Jeans–A Lazy Girl’s Dream Come True
Latest News on The CutEverything You Need to Know About Ghost Sex
We know you've been wondering.Kendall Jenner Drops the ‘Jenner’
She's pulling a Cher.Dating Naked: The Magic of Meg’s Giant Boobs
She put a spell on you.A Perfume That Smells Like a Fleeting Dream
A dream directed by Sofia Coppola.Marines Have Their Own Rape-y ‘Hot or Not’
The Marine Corps. thinks flip-flops are more offensive than rape jokes.By Choice or Necessity, the Future of Abortions May Be at Home
In countries where abortion is illegal, women are safely self-inducing. Maybe we should, too.25 Chic Fall Pieces on Sale Right Now
Finally, cold-weather clothes to get excited about.Beyoncé Wrote, for Us, a Poem
"Words by Beyoncé, remixed by Forrest Gander."14 Ways to Wear Your Ripped Jeans Through Fall
You don't have to retire them just yet.A Matte Lipstick Marker You Only Have to Apply Once
And then forget about it.
To debut at her New York show.Now You Can Skateboart Like Beyoncé
Grinding on that wood.Kendall Jenner Went for a Walk in a Lab Coat
Physician chic.Here’s a Tennis Star Worthy of Your U.S. Open Lust
Ernests Gulbis is so foxy his name is a plural.7 Men Who Will Renew Your Faith in Tan Suits
For all the haters.The Complete Spring 2015 New York Fashion Week Calendar
Your guide to navigating the zoo.Rag & Bone Took Winona Ryder to Coney Island
Where she played the claw game.Graffiti Artists Are Taking Roberto Cavalli to Court [Updated]
Redefining "style wars."This Is the Most Fashionable Thing de Blasio’s Ever Done
He's teaming up with the CFDA for a Fashion Week kickoff.Blake Lively Survives Vicious Bee Assault
Pricked but not vanquished.
Pizza. The kind you eat.Andre Agassi on Fake Hair, True Love, and Being an Accidental Fashion Icon
"I wouldn’t take hair right now, if you gave it to me."V Has Coined a Term to Describe Kylie Jenner: ‘Calabasian’
Adj.: Of or hailing from Calabasas, California.Inner Beauty: A Tour Through Caudalie’s New Offices
A tour through French skin-care line Caudalie’s new, winery-inspired offices.Men, You Can Stop Lying About Your Height
A new study says short dudes make for better long-term partners.How Can You Make Stand-up Comedy Out of Sexism?
By dressing up as a dude.Beyoncé Found the Chicest Surfbort Ever
She graces the cover of CR Fashion Book.Zoe Saldana Wore a Nice Little Rorschach Test
One giant inkblot.No One Back-to-School Shops Anymore, Nerd
Ugh, do I have to explain everything to you?Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie Got Married
The long engagement ends.
Senior Beauty Editor Kathleen Hou talks to our new team member.Courtney Love Has Been Discussing Cheese for 25 Years
Dairy-themed chats since 1989.A Ladylike Pastel Tote Will Ease You Into Fall
Unusual.Vogue Italia Cover Is Chock-full of Supermodels
Now, this is a model cover!IMF Chief Christine Lagarde Demoted to IMF Vixen
By the Drudge Report.How to Make Your Foundation Last Forever
A little really does go a long way.Game of Thrones Meets Normcore in New Video
Grimes wears Adidas pool slides in her video for "Go."There’s a Severe Rosé Shortage in the Hamptons
Chic, pink, and hard to come by.Prince Harry Narrowly Avoids Lifetime of Loneliness
He has a new girlfriend. Her name is Camilla Thurlow.5 Cool Ways to Upgrade Your Look This Fall
It's now or never.
The two sat together to watch mutual buddy Roger Federer play.Breezy Linens and Tevas at MoMA PS1’s Warm Up
Street-style highlights from the annual outdoor summer dance series.Ask Polly: How Am I Supposed to Make Friends in My Late 20s?
Aim low and open your heart.Band of Outsiders Canceled Its NYFW Presentation
It's decided to focus on its store opening.Playboy Figured Out How to Appeal to Women
Answer: Make fun of men.Meet the Teenage Sisters With an App to Prevent Police Brutality
Ima and Asha Christensen made really good use of their summer vacation.Get Ouuuut: Donatella Versace Accepted the Ice Bucket Challenge
With shirtless male models and Versace buckets.ABC Announced Next Season’s Bachelor
Curveball: He's white, wholesome, and a fan of hair gel.Jennifer Aniston Hates Your Line of Inquiry
Citing Steinem influence.A Summer Sandal That Will Be a Hit Next Year Too
A jeweled slide that'll last.