The September issue of Essence marks the magazine's 40th anniversary — and the debut of Ellianna Placas as the new official fashion director. The appointment of Placas, who is white and has been freelancing for the magazine over the past six months, drew a lot of criticism, which Robin Givhan addresses in the Washington Post today. While Givhan feels none of the concerns regarding the hire should be discounted, she argues:
[Essence] treated a black woman's sense of style as though it was unique: the "special" beauty of black women.
That perspective is moving toward obsolescence. Models such as Liya Kebede and Queen Latifah have won lucrative cosmetics contracts from Est?e Lauder and Cover Girl, making black beauty more mass market than ever. Black models have starred as Victoria's Secret angels -- the contemporary version of a popular pin-up. Fashion designers vie to dress stars such as Beyonc?, Paula Patton and Viola Davis with the same ferocity as white ones. Black actresses regularly entrust their public image to white stylists. And designers of every race and ethnicity salivate at the prospect of dressing the first lady and a rainbow coalition of them have helped her look her best.
Givhan attempted to speak to Essence editor Angela Burt-Murray for her story, but she "declined to comment ... preferring to pass on a discussion of the magazine's anniversary if it included a conversation about Placas." Though Burt-Murray defended her decision in a piece she wrote for the Grio, Givhan wishes she'd take a more vocal approach:
Instead of wishing that the brouhaha over Placas would die down, Burt-Murray should take to the airwaves and hold up her decision as a sign that Essence isn't just about black women. Black women aren't "special." They are individuals and they are universal.
Just as surely as a black woman can develop the skills and sensitivity to someday hold sway over the entire fashion industry, a white woman can learn to seek out a diverse range of designers and a beautiful mix of models. And if the mainstream glossies keep to their mostly homogenous ways, so be it. That's another battle. Essence shouldn't aspire to be just like all the other magazines. It should aim to be better.
Most Viewed Stories
Why Did Everyone Act Like I Was Crazy When I Decided to Have a Baby in My 20s?
Rereading The Handmaid’s Tale, One Month Into the Trump Era
It Sure Looks Like Diane Kruger Is Dating Norman Reedus Now
People Everywhere Agree That Justin Trudeau Has a Good Butt
Woman Framed by Ex-Boyfriend’s Wife in Craigslist ‘Rape Fantasy’ Plot Speaks Out
Karl Lagerfeld Calls Out Meryl Streep for Canceling an Order for a Chanel Dress
Taylor Swift Is Not Going to Be Happy About This New Friendship
Someone Paid $2,000 to Provide Us With This Terrible Billboard
Sports Illustrated’s New Curvy Model on Fitness, Staying Healthy, and Embracing Her Body
Ask Polly: I Overshared My Way Out of a Boyfriend!
Latest News from The CutMissoni Grabs Back with Knitted Pink Pussy Hats at Milan Fashion Week
Audience members and models alike sported knitted pink pussy hats.Barbara Pierce Bush to Speak at Texas Planned Parenthood Fundraiser
Don’t mess with Texas women.Extremely Handsome Oscar Nominee Mahershala Ali Is Now a Hot Dad
Mahershala Ali and Amatus Sami-Karim’s baby was born earlier this week.Selena Gomez Is the Weeknd’s VIP at His Amsterdam Concert
Their globetrotting romance continues.Sergio Rossi Brought Sleek Heels and Smoky Mirrors to Milan
Sergio Rossi’s Winter 2017/18 line gets the high-tech treatment in this video.Danielle Brooks Talks Body Positivity and Lane Bryant
“Women are seeing themselves and are feeling beautiful about their bodies.”Laverne Cox: “Trans Rights Are Women’s Rights”
On bell hooks and more.Watch the Bottega Veneta Livestream
Enjoy!This Man Probably Knows More About Makeup Than You Do
A quick chat with Instagram’s favorite male makeup artist.See Marina Abramovic’s Greatest Moments in the Art World
Her first extensive monograph comes out next month.
Xanax in blog form.Designers Agree: Red Is the Color for Fall 2017
It’s more than just a trend, it’s a movement.People Everywhere Agree That Justin Trudeau Has a Good Butt
An image of the Canadian prime minister’s butt has gone viral.Leonardo DiCaprio Is Definitely Hiding His Oscar in This Fanny Pack
What else could be in there?When Dating Younger Men Becomes a Sexual Crusade
On this week’s podcast: Cindy Gallop reinvented her career so everyone could have better sex.A Rainbow Elephant Makes a Fun Purse
The chicest look from day two of Milan Fashion Week.Wear Paisley Like This for Spring
The Golden Peacock Award winner from day two of Milan Fashion Week.Gigi and Bella Hadid Get Rainbow Hair at Versace
A style that looks a little familiar to anyone who spent too much time listening to Avril Lavigne.Princess Diana Is Having a Resurgence As a Fashion Muse
She’s the subject of a new London exhibit, and her influence is all over the runways.It Sure Looks Like Diane Kruger Is Dating Norman Reedus Now
The pair was spotted returning from a “romantic road trip.”