Best Bet: Clark’s Botanicals Lip Tint

Lighter than a lipstick, less shiny than a gloss, Clark’s Botanicals’ lip tints strike a balance between the two. Packed with shea butter, aloe-leaf extract, sweet almond oil, and jojoba oil, they keep lips moisturized while adding a just-kissed hint of color. Slick it over bare lips for a more subtle look or dab it on over matte lipstick for a smooth, nonsticky sheen.

Clark's Botanicals Ultra-Rich Lip Tint, $19 at C.O. Bigelow, Anthropologie, or online.