The thing about eye-shadow pencils is that all you really need is one color for a mistake-proof look. Usually creamy in texture, they glide on smooth and can easily be blended out with a fingertip or brush until there's the subtlest wash of color. A chunky, pencil-point-like tip makes for precise application near the lash line, which means drama seekers can create a smoky eye with just one tool. One swift line and these pencils are like your average eye liner, but blend out a bit more and it's suddenly become a shadow. Then layer on a more intense line by the top lash and it's a full-blown, K. Stew–approved smoky eye. Just in time for you to get glam for your family holiday party, here are seven of our favorites.
Sephora Waterproof Jumbo Liner 12HR Wear in Black ($14): This pencil glides very soft and smooth onto the lid, almost like a creamy pot of eye shadow. The color is a saturated jet black, yet unlike other pencils, this one leaves behind a subtle sheen on lids. Once it's on, there's a very short (read: few seconds long) window to smudge and blend before the color sets.
Nars Soft Touch Shadow in Aigle Noir ($24): A light tap, tap, tap with the sides of the pencil (not the tip) will leave lids with a soft wash of gold-glitter-dusted, blackish-brown shadow. It's subtle enough for day. But if you're feeling even more festive, draw on a bit more using the pencil point, especially close to the lash line, for a more intense look.
Smashbox Waterproof Shadow Liner in Lapis ($22): This deep amethyst hue is anything but costume-y. Even those who stick to a black-charcoal smoky eye will get into the party makeup spirit with this rich, subtly shimmery color. Grown-up Debbie Harry's everywhere can get onboard on this.
Stila Smudge Crayon in Smoke ($22): It's not quite gold, not quite champagne, but the color of shimmering sable. Deluxe. The pointy, self-sharpening tip makes for an easy applicator to highlight inner corners of eyes. Or drag it across the bottom lash line to add balance for a dark, smoky eye.
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Shadow Pencil in Mercury ($20): This silvery shade isn't your traditional moon-dust-like shimmer. It has a bit of chromelike depth for a more moody effect than the others.
Make Up For Ever Aqua Shadow #28E ($20): Unlike other water-resistant pencils, this one's blendable even a few minutes after application. This muted, shimmery copper shade would also be universally flattering on any skin tone.
Most Viewed Stories
The Ultimate Guide to Preparing for the Women’s March
This Conspiracy Theory Will Change How You Feel About the Bachelor Villain
Connecticut Politician Arrested for Pinching Woman’s Genitals
The Sheer Perfection of Donald Trump’s Golden Shower
15 Protest Sign Ideas for the Women’s March on Washington
Hairstylist Says She Was Asked to Do Marla Maples’s and Tiffany Trump’s Inauguration Day Hair for Free
Pakistani Pop Star Stops Concert When He Spots Sexual Harassment
The Obamas Visited Malia and Sasha’s Old Swing Set at Its New Home at a D.C. Shelter
How to Live in a 150-Square-Foot Studio
Ask a Boss: How Do I Quit the Job I’ve Had Forever?
From Our Partners
powered by PubExchange
The Cut’s Latest Beauty FeaturesRachel Comey on How She’s Mobilizing the Fashion Industry for the Women’s March
She put out a call to her fellow designers.Turmeric Might Not Have Magical Therapeutic Powers After All
A new study shines a skeptical light on turmeric.Republican Men Think Women Have It Better
A new survey found that 51 percent of Republican men think it’s a good time to be a woman in America.Obama Commutes Chelsea Manning’s Sentence
She will be out of prison on May 17.Why Some Parents Are Slaughtering Sophie the Giraffe
Cause of death: a viral article inciting mold fears.Why Not Sail to Italy With These Italian Men?
This daydream of a video comes courtesy of Caruso.Please Ignore This Enraging Person at the Women’s March
This week’s “Bermuda Square” comic strip.Activists Are Planning a Queer Dance Party Outside Mike Pence’s Home
The dance is in protest of Pence’s stance on LGBTQ issues.Louis Vuitton Held a Conversation on the Syrian Crisis
The brand has partnered with UNICEF to help the cause.You’re Not Crazy, Trump Really Is Giving You More Migraines
The election has been a headache for migraine sufferers.
After being separated from her mate for three years, Leonie the shark reproduced asexually.Hillary Clinton Supporter Ralph Lauren Will Dress Melania Trump for Inauguration
The designer will reach across the aisle — or design room.Your Guide to NYC Inauguration Weekend Protests
Not making it to D.C.? Here are some local options.See All the Best Street Style From Milan Men’s Fashion Week
Wide-leg pants, puffer coats, lots of red.Fake News, Fake Science and Why Doctors Lie About Abortion
The consequences of bad information about women’s health.Alicia Keys Really Believes That Inner Beauty Is the Best Highlighter
Her glow doesn’t come in a compact.This Conspiracy Theory Will Change How You Feel About the Bachelor Villain
Corinne is not who she seems.Ask a Boss: How Do I Quit the Job I’ve Had Forever?
With two weeks’ notice.U.S. Abortion Rate Lowest Since Roe v. Wade
A new study from the Guttmacher Institute shows a decline in abortions.Emma Watson Declares Once and for All That Belle Is a Better Disney Princess Than Cinderella
She’s only a little biased.