The thing about eye-shadow pencils is that all you really need is one color for a mistake-proof look. Usually creamy in texture, they glide on smooth and can easily be blended out with a fingertip or brush until there's the subtlest wash of color. A chunky, pencil-point-like tip makes for precise application near the lash line, which means drama seekers can create a smoky eye with just one tool. One swift line and these pencils are like your average eye liner, but blend out a bit more and it's suddenly become a shadow. Then layer on a more intense line by the top lash and it's a full-blown, K. Stew–approved smoky eye. Just in time for you to get glam for your family holiday party, here are seven of our favorites.
Sephora Waterproof Jumbo Liner 12HR Wear in Black ($14): This pencil glides very soft and smooth onto the lid, almost like a creamy pot of eye shadow. The color is a saturated jet black, yet unlike other pencils, this one leaves behind a subtle sheen on lids. Once it's on, there's a very short (read: few seconds long) window to smudge and blend before the color sets.
Nars Soft Touch Shadow in Aigle Noir ($24): A light tap, tap, tap with the sides of the pencil (not the tip) will leave lids with a soft wash of gold-glitter-dusted, blackish-brown shadow. It's subtle enough for day. But if you're feeling even more festive, draw on a bit more using the pencil point, especially close to the lash line, for a more intense look.
Smashbox Waterproof Shadow Liner in Lapis ($22): This deep amethyst hue is anything but costume-y. Even those who stick to a black-charcoal smoky eye will get into the party makeup spirit with this rich, subtly shimmery color. Grown-up Debbie Harry's everywhere can get onboard on this.
Stila Smudge Crayon in Smoke ($22): It's not quite gold, not quite champagne, but the color of shimmering sable. Deluxe. The pointy, self-sharpening tip makes for an easy applicator to highlight inner corners of eyes. Or drag it across the bottom lash line to add balance for a dark, smoky eye.
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Shadow Pencil in Mercury ($20): This silvery shade isn't your traditional moon-dust-like shimmer. It has a bit of chromelike depth for a more moody effect than the others.
Make Up For Ever Aqua Shadow #28E ($20): Unlike other water-resistant pencils, this one's blendable even a few minutes after application. This muted, shimmery copper shade would also be universally flattering on any skin tone.
Most Viewed Stories
The Only Woman Mike Pence Is Allowed to Eat Alone With Is His Wife
Aubrey Plaza Is Currently Serving Up the Most Terrifying Performance on TV
Political Commentator Angela Rye Has Had It With Casual Racism
I Wore Melania’s Couture Dress and It Was Terrifying
Chris Evans Has Only Nice, Beautiful Things to Say About Jenny Slate
The Makeup Police Have Come to Arrest Alicia Keys
Michelle Kwan’s Husband Filed for Divorce
Jared Kushner Is ‘Exfoliating’ His Friends
Hollywood Has Embraced Dascha Polanco. Why Hasn’t the Fashion World?
Bobbi Brown on Why She Really Left Her Brand and Resisted Making a Contour Palette, and Her Next Moves
The Cut’s Latest Beauty FeaturesSenate Votes to Allow States to Defund Abortion Providers
Vice-President Mike Pence cast the tie-breaking vote.H&M Is Launching a Slightly More Grown-up H&M
Arket will have in-store cafés.Hillary Clinton and Sex and the City Loved These Rhinestone Purses
See glittering bags from Judith Leiber’s new museum retrospective.Kim Kardashian Reveals She’s Undergoing Surgery on Her Uterus to Have a Third Child
“I want my kids to have siblings and I want to know that I did everything I could to make this happen.”Carl’s Jr. Is Trying Desperately to Escape Its Sexist Past
The company unveiled a new ad that diverges from their typical scantily-clad-woman-eating-a-burger trope, all while acknowledging it.Jared Kushner Is ‘Exfoliating’ His Friends
Like Kondo-ing, but better.HBO Picks Up Italian TV Adaptation of Elena Ferrante’s Neapolitan Novels
But who will play Lila and Lenu?Hollywood Has Embraced Dascha Polanco. Why Hasn’t the Fashion World?
Talking OITNB, the fashion world’s hypocrisies, and being a proud New Yorker.Justin Bieber Will Make Male Crop Tops Trendy Even If It Kills Him
Justin ... thank you.I Wore Melania’s Couture Dress and It Was Terrifying
It was a harrowing bellwether of a kleptocratic, oligarchic future.
Your money might be better spent elsewhere.The Exact Moment Amal Clooney Assumed Her New Form
A new woman.Tyrannosaurus rex Was the Sensitive Lover You’ve Been Looking For
Scientists say T. rex rubbed their sensitive noses together while mating.This Gender-Fluid Line From Korea Caught LVMH’s Eye
Blindness believes in designing beautiful pieces, no matter who wants to wear them.Suri Cruise Is ‘Hurt’ That Hillary Clinton Lost the Election
This will make you feel old.Adrienne Bailon on Coconut Oil, Making Lists, and Why She Wants More Women to Talk About Their Periods
“Talking about it normalizes what’s going on with us.”Sculptor Responsible for Terrible Cristiano Ronaldo Statue Defends His Work
“Not even Jesus pleased everyone.”Inside Detroit’s Rapidly Growing Art-and-Design Scene
Photographer Michel Arnaud’s new book, Detroit: The Dream Is Now, captures the revitalization taking place in of one of America’s great cities.Sheryl Sandberg Says Leaning in Hasn’t Made Women Better Off
“Overall, we are not seeing a major increase in female leadership in any industry or in any government.”25 Famous Women on Waxing and Shaving
How Rihanna, Emma Watson, Eva Longoria, and more deal with body hair.