Like a weather pattern in reverse, the “year of the woman” trope has moved west from Washington, D.C. — where it is periodically used to describe female victories in the House and Senate — to Hollywood. Never mind that Bridesmaids came out in 2011, The New York Times Magazine says that 2012, with Katniss, Bella, Catwoman, Hush Puppy, and Anna Karenina, was the year of the woman. Excuse me, the year of “Hollywood heroine worship.” But not because the movies with interesting female leads will win fancy awards, break box-office records, or were directed by women. They won't and they weren't. Acknowledging all that, critic A.O. Scott concludes that it’s not so much the year of the woman as it is the year of woman as news. He’s talking about all those “controversial” Atlantic, Time, and Newsweek covers, but really, he’s talking about Lena Dunham. (Aren’t we always?) And he doesn't make it sound like anything worth celebrating.
The problem is not that [woman-centric] issues are not important but rather that they are presented with a sensationalism that tends to undermine their ongoing and complicated significance. The behavior of a woman who appears on the public stage can be counted on to provoke a contentious referendum on the state of women in general. Is this good for women? Is she doing it wrong?
[The] reception of “Girls,” even more than the show itself — which is, to keep things in perspective, a clever half-hour sitcom about a bunch of recent college graduates — is an interesting sign of our confused times. Dunham was mocked for her body, sneered at for her supposed nepotism, scolded for her inadequate commitment to diversity and lectured about the inappropriate things her alter ego, Hannah Horvath, does in bed. That much of the criticism came from Dunham’s peers is both evidence of a robust feminist discourse in the cultural blogosphere and a legacy of the under- and misrepresentation [of women in film and television]. Dunham was not quite allowed just to explore her own ideas and experiences. She was expected to get it right, to represent, to set an example and blaze a path.
The important difference between Girls and all the movies featured in the Times' pretty women of Hollywood slideshow is that Girls, unlike, say, Anna Karenina, is about women and made by women. I don't love the fact that Dunham's work became something onto which every female critic could project her feelings about her unwritten novel/lost youth/class anxiety/eating disorder/whatever. But the "disproportionate" response to Girls — like the so-called controversy surrounding Atlantic articles about women — has less to do with some nefarious and exploitative sensationalizing of them and more to do with how starved we are for them. Every writer like Dunham, or the Atlantic's Kate Bolick and Anne-Marie Slaughter, who tells a story successfully (if someone has written a critique of their articles that engages with the content of the articles, not their headlines or the facts of their existence, please direct me to it), shows studio executives and magazine editors that topics confined to women's magazines and rom-coms, like women writers, can be smart, funny and interesting and are therefore good for business. Criticism and engagement with women's work can get ugly, especially on the crowded, loud, and anonymous Internet. But I'll take it over simple "heroine worship" any day.
Most Viewed Stories
Rob Kardashian and Blac Chyna Reportedly Broke Up
It’s Finally Possible to Understand What Happened to Amanda Knox
The Very Uncomfortable Experience of Rewatching Election in 2016
Outrageous Party Photos From Andy Warhol’s Factory Days
Chelsea Clinton Says She Didn’t Initially Know Her Mom Had Pneumonia Because She Was Trying to Power Through It
22 Intimate Lost Photos of Marilyn Monroe
Ask a Boss: My Co-worker Wants Everyone to Call Her Boyfriend Her ‘Master’!
Ask Polly: Should I Try to Help My Alcoholic Friend?
YogaToes Cured My Lifelong Fear of Bunions
This Lipstick Was Designed by a Woman Who Can See 100 Million Colors
From Our Partners
The Zoe Report
powered by PubExchange
The Cut’s Latest Love and War FeaturesThe Novelist Disguised As a Housewife
Shirley Jackson wrote 17 books while raising four children — and she couldn't have had a successful career without them.Ava DuVernay on Hollywood Racism, Modern-Day Slavery, and Why She’s Still an Optimist
The director, whose new documentary The 13th chronicles America’s history of racial subjugation, talks to Rebecca Traister about Bill Clinton, Newt Gingrich, and the modern criminal-justice system.What No One Tells Couples Trying to Conceive
It helps to be rich.The Hidden Black Women Who Helped Win the Space Race
A segregated unit of mathematicians born of desperation during World War II became the secret to NASA’s success.Slut-Shaming Squids Are Everywhere
The “Bermuda Square” comic strip is back.Santigold’s New Video Is the Result of a Spontaneous Run-in With Kara Walker
The collaboration that dreams are made of.Emma Stone and Andrew Garfield Spotted Together Again, Love Might Be Real
They could be back together ahh!Teen, Forced to Go on Vacation With Her Family, Calls 911
The logical decision.Report: Hearst Fired Seventeen EIC Michelle Tan During Her Maternity Leave
Tan had been at the magazine for about two years.Good Morning America Host Amy Robach Apologizes for Saying ‘Colored People’ on Air
She quickly apologized.
That’s one way to do it.Don’t Mess This Up, Mischa Barton
Marissa Cooper is poised for a comeback ... maybe.California Votes to Remove Time Limit on Prosecuting Rape Cases
In light of the Bill Cosby case.Beyoncé’s Behind-the-Scenes Lemonade Photos Belong in a Museum
She had the "Boycott Beyoncé" sign already in formation on set.The Rise of the Male Celebrity Full-Frontal
An ex-publicist explains.Gabby Douglas Will Be a Miss America Judge
The gold-medal gymnast will help choose the 2017 pageant winner.Camille Becerra’s Photo Diary of Rockaway Beach
An ideal trip to add and cross off your summer bucket list.Sorry Nerds, Ian McKellen Won’t Officiate Your Expensive Lord of the Rings–Themed Wedding
Not even for $1.5 million.Miles Teller Is Still Upset About Being Called a Dick
He wants to set the record straight.Why Parents Shouldn’t Talk About Weight With Their Teens
New guidelines seek to banish weight talk.