I live in what many consider to be the capital of fake. To outsiders — and a few disgruntled insiders — Los Angeles is a company town where people reinvent themselves to suit whatever audience is present, a place where plastic surgery is a forgone conclusion, where religious affiliations and surnames are as mutable as lipstick. And no one is slapped with charges of fakery more than women who work in the business here.
As the sheer number of people with self-invented names attending the Grammys this year will attest, mutability catapults stars to success. But paradoxically, it can also be a sticking point for critics. Female pop stars, in particular, are quickly slapped with a fake label as soon as they break big. Many of the most successful women in music — Ke$ha, Katy Perry, Lady Gaga, Lana Del Rey — are highly theatrical, platinum-selling artists who are repeatedly called “fake.” And that perceived inauthenticity is endemic to how we talk about them as artists.
Most of these artists did change their names, their looks, and their sounds in pursuit of mass appeal. Katy Perry went from singing in Christian churches to spraying whipped cream out of her bra. The Katy Perry: Part of Me documentary was, in essence, a feature-length answer to charges of inauthenticity, belaboring the point that, despite early attempts to find success in a number of genres, Perry has always been herself. Stefani Germanotta, meanwhile, gave up premenstrual-angsty piano ballads and donned latex to become Lady Gaga — and was subsequently charged with faking her freakiness. When Lana Del Rey first broke big, Hipster Runoff devoted his entire blog to “The Lana Del Report,” hating on and obsessing about her “Lizzy Grant” origins and artificially plumped lips. And absolutely everyone knocked Ke$ha as a poseur until we found ourselves dancing to her hits again and again.
Reinvention has long been key to success — especially in artistic fields. So why are we hating on pop stars for adopting the very qualities that entertain us? We’ve all heard the advice to “fake it til you make it.” The pop-music industry takes that a step further: Fake it so you can make it. If your work isn’t catching on, try something new. Seen through this lens, fakery is laudable! It takes guts — and savvy — to radically change your career, your looks, your approach to life. In just about any industry, the people who don’t adapt to changing times are left behind. And those who evolve quickest, those who are first to learn new technology or hop aboard new trends, tend to be the most successful.
So-called fakeness is also the antidote to imposter syndrome: that feeling you get that you’re really not supposed to be here, that you somehow lucked your way into a job or tricked the boss into giving you that plum assignment. The best remedy is to fake it. To pretend you’re 100 percent confident in your skills and abilities, and usually you’ll rise to the occasion. (Ask almost anyone who’s “made it” if she’s ever bluffed her way through a meeting.) Most of us have never added a dollar sign to our names or purchased new boobs, but we have swallowed our insecurities in order to succeed professionally.
The most “inauthentic” female entertainers should be heralded as celebrity spokespeople in the crusade against imposter syndrome because their shape-shifting is so visible, and because they’ve accrued so much wealth and power as a result. But the fact that these women all found success after changing themselves is used as a way to discredit their work. Charges of fakeness don’t only dog up-and-coming artists; they’re a go-to insult when we want to knock a woman on top. Even Queen Bey isn’t immune: After Beyonce sang a flawless National Anthem at Obama’s second inauguration, she was accused of having lip-synched it. Then she was called hypocritical for the name of her world tour. How dare the woman who told us that girls run the world also nod to the name “Mrs. Carter”?
Meanwhile, even female artists with a more staid stage presence, like Taylor Swift — who is nominated for a slew of Grammys for the fourth time in her four-album career — aren’t safe. After years of mostly avoiding the kind of fakery charges that dogged her fellow chart-topping young women, the critics have recently gone after her personal life as the false construction. According to the tabloids, her relationships are fake, her wedding invitations are fake, even her boobs might be fake.
The problem, really, is that even starlets contain multitudes. Lana Del Rey “has many different qualities that women in our culture aren't allowed to be, all at once, so people are trying to find the inauthentic one,” Rookie founder Tavi Gevinson told music journalist Jessica Hopper last year. Society abhors a woman who can’t be categorized — especially if she is willfully defying the categories, and even more so if she’s famous. A more recent piece in The Walrus calmly explained, “When a woman embodies a persona, we see words like ‘disingenuous’ and ‘fake.’ When a man does the same, we get ‘Jack White Is the Coolest, Weirdest, Savviest Rock Star of Our Time’ — the actual subtitle of last year’s New York Times Magazine profile of Jack White by Josh Eells.”
Smart people evolve to stay relevant. And if you’re around long enough, changing often enough, people eventually accept it as a positive quality. (Madonna, anyone?) Hating on young women for daring to change is a pretty nefarious way of undermining their long-term success. I have no idea what Taylor Swift and Lana Del Rey and Katy Perry consider to be their authentic selves. And that’s exactly the point. None of us are in a position to allege what’s “fake,” especially when we’re talking about people who make their living — a very good living — entertaining us. Nicki Minaj puts it another way: “And if I'm fake, I ain't notice cause my money ain't.”
Most Viewed Stories
It’s Harder to Be Thin Than It Was in the ’80s
Why Do I Jerk Awake Right As I’m Falling Asleep?
From Up Close, Raf Simons’s Vision for Dior Is Clear
The World’s Easiest Way to Highlight Your Face
A Pregnant Supermodel Explains What She Eats
Michelle Obama: No Boy Is Cute Enough to Keep You From Getting an Education
Meet the Prom Queen of Instagram
Sleater-Kinney on Riot Grrl, Reuniting, and Portlandia
Selfie Sorority Uses Media Frenzy for Good Cause
Guess Who Renovated This Grand Upper West Side Penthouse
From Our Partners
Jennifer Garner, Before and After
Gentrification at the Goodwill: Not Even New York’s Thrift Stores Are For the Poor
5 Must-Have Products for Your Makeup Bag
Here's What To Buy From J.Crew's HUGE 75-Percent-Off Sale!
powered by PubExchange
The Cut’s Latest Love and War Features8 Actually Good Things That Happened This Week
Baby sea turtles wearing bathing suits and a necklace for your pizza.Selfie Sorority Uses Media Frenzy for Good Cause
Take that, sportscasters.A Comprehensive Taxonomy of Men With Long Hair
And why we like them anyway.Teens Are Dying From Train-Track Photo Shoots
The popular photo destination is actually super-dangerous.‘Truly Ugly Guy With Glasses’ Is Europe’s Most Virile Man
Ed Houben has fathered 106 children — that he knows of.The Internet of Parents Is Miserable and I Love It
Why it's so hard to look away.Did the ‘Maxipad Bandit’ Really Think He’d Escape?
Not so fast, mister.Woman Driven From Her Home by Death Threats After Starting Pro-Choice Hashtag
The hashtag drew intense scorn from anti-abortion activists.Ice-Cold Teens Don’t Hesitate to Block Their Exes
"I’m just like this is irrelevant now.”Let Sorority Girls Instagram Themselves in Peace
Come on, man.
Whether you're Lena Dunham or an emerging writer, the format has an appealing intimacy.The Bennifer Years Affected Matt Damon More Than Anyone Else
It's just really hard when your buddy breaks up with J.Lo, you know?Someone Used Gasoline to Set a Los Angeles–Area Planned Parenthood on Fire
Police believe gasoline was used as an accelerant to burn down the Thousand Oaks facility.Michelle Obama: No Boy Is Cute Enough to Keep You From Getting an Education
"Compete with the boys. Beat the boys."Stop Time-Traveling to Such Lame Eras, Losers
You have a choice, people.New ‘Yelp for People’ Will Let You Rate Everyone You Know
Kind of like Lulu, or Hot or Not, or ...Ruth Bader Ginsburg Is Glad She Was Trained in the ’60s
She's glad she was trained in the Mad Men era.Lena Dunham Apologizes for Joking About Abuse
"When I heard my own quote I was like, 'Jesus, Lena, no.'"Desperate Republicans Attack Planned Parenthood Chief’s Salary
"The disrespect, the misogyny rampant here today tells us what is really going on."Blake Lively’s Lifestyle Is No Longer for Sale
She will Goop no more.