After last season's dust-up between Hedi Slimane and the Times' Cathy Horyn, it's no surprise that he continued to ban her from Saint Laurent this week. And once again, she simply looked at the clothes online and wrote about them anyway, lumping her review into a larger evaluation of several major Paris collections, including Hermès and Louis Vuitton. Titled "Clothes Worthy of Their Labels," the piece insinuated that Slimane's designs did not fall under that category.
Horyn's remarks on Slimane's show, while tempered, were not complimentary. Although it's clear Slimane has been hard at work fashioning a new, modernized identity for the house, Horyn seems to think he's throwing out the baby with the bathwater:
One of the first things the new designer, Hedi Slimane, did was to remove “Yves” from the label, thereby severing a symbolic connection to the founder, and everything he stood for, like good taste and feminine power.
As for this particular collection, Horyn made a point to note that other people hadn't liked it. Almost every critic used this tactic with Saint Laurent this season, because it allowed them to knock the clothes without assigning credit (or taking blame) for negative comments. Horyn was quite measured in her approach, making some references to her colleague Eric Wilson's review from a few days prior, which had a similar tone. She writes:
Many people said the clothes looked like stuff sold at Topshop or a thrift store, while others defended Mr. Slimane’s approach and identified pieces, like a pink fur chubby, that relate back to Yves’s designs of the late ’60s and early ’70s, when he got ideas — say, for a pea coat — from the street. It’s doubtful that customers will make that connection, but such comments serve to validate what Mr. Slimane has done.
She really stuck the knife in, though, with backhanded compliments to the fashion house's reputation and Slimane's skills as an instigator.
And the controversy is good for Saint Laurent. But mainly it was clear to me how strong the name is. In terms of design, the clothes held considerably less value than a box of Saint Laurent labels. Without the label attached to them, Mr. Slimane’s grunge dresses wouldn’t attract interest — because they’re not special. But a box of labels is worth a million.
And finally, moving on:
Hermès stands in sharp contrast to the Saint Laurent show and its lazy values.
Well! At least someone was willing to express an opinion. We'll keep a close watch on Slimane's Twitter feed today.
Most Viewed Stories
‘Weed Dick’ Is the New Way for Men to Sexually Disappoint You
The Big Secret of Every Dating App: Tech Doesn’t Matter
How to Get Out of Any Party Conversation
Amber Rose, Populist Slut Hero of Our Time
Portraits of Privilege: A Teen Demands Mac ’n’ Cheese
7 Alternatives to Those Sold-Out L.L. Bean Boots
Cindy Crawford on Bagels, Instagirls, and Bringing the Supermodel Era to TV
You Think You’re Too Classy to Drink Champagne From a Bong?
Adriana Lima on Boxing, Brazilian Beauty Secrets
From Our Partners
The Evolution Of Lady Gaga In One Fabulous, Ooh-La-La GIF
5 Must-Have Products for Your Makeup Bag
'Scream Queens' Parodies Taylor Swift In New Halloween Episode
Confessions of a Coffee Non-Drinker
powered by PubExchange
The Cut’s Latest Fashion FeaturesCate Blanchett Wore a Hot-Pink Suit
Barbie, is that you?All About Chanel’s Airport-Themed Show
Paging Mr. Lagerfeld!Watch the Valentino Livestream
Enjoy!5 Things I Want to Wear From Paris: Part 3
Stripes, embroidered separates, and Céline studded boots.Cindy Crawford on Bagels, Instagirls, and Bringing the Supermodel Era to TV
And how she's helping her daughter navigate the pressures of the modeling industry.Zendaya Floated Around Paris Like a Cloud
Dreamy.See Our Exclusive Portfolio From Paris Fashion Week
Another fashion month dispatch from photographer Tomasz Lazar.Coddington, Kawakubo Star in Interview Portfolio
They were photographed for a sweeping 60-page section by Fabien Baron.American Apparel Files for Bankruptcy
Current shareholders, including Dov Charney, will no longer control the company.The Retired Modeling Agent Who Loves Empire
“I started my own agency — we represented Twiggy — but went off to be assistant to the actor Yul Brynner, who was dating my roommate at the time.”
New York women in winter's least-boring outerwear, from bright-green alpaca fur to leopard-print mohair.Céline’s Woman-Friendly Triumph
Phoebe Philo remains in touch with what women want to wear.Watch the Alexander McQueen Livestream
Enjoy!Watch the Akris Livestream
Enjoy!From Up Close, Raf Simons’s Vision for Dior Is Clear
And don't count John Galliano out at Margiela yet.5 Things I Want to Wear From Paris: Part 2
Cropped sweaters, a spangled skirt, and more.Jaden Smith and Kesha Partied This Week
Along with Cindy Crawford, Anjelica Huston, Rita Ora, and Lena Dunham.Kendall Jenner and Gigi Hadid Partied in Balmain
Plus: more highlights from Paris Fashion Week's parties, including Jared Leto.See All the Street Style From Paris Fashion Week
Featuring wooden platforms, velvet robes, and floor-length ponchos.Who Won Best-Dressed at Milan Fashion Week?
Another city, another people's choice Peacock.