In their attempts to divine the relationship statuses of celebrities from paparazzi photos, onlookers are scrutinizing two PDA moments this week: Arnold Schwarzenegger touching Maria Shriver's butt at their daughter's graduation, and Justin Bieber kissing Selena Gomez (and disgusting Taylor Swift) at the Billboard Music Awards, as depicted above.
After a breakup, every action is meaningful. Eye contact, Facebook "likes," dramatically timed exits — all speak volumes, but none more than physical interaction. (Well, except actual words, maybe.) Whereas the Schwarze-touch probably signals commitment, the Jelena kiss is ambiguous. To explain why, here is an illustrated guide to ten physical interactions between exes, and what each one means.
Kiss on Lips: Back Together
In private, lip-kissing could just mean no-strings-attached ex sex. In public, it usually means the couple is back together, because "publicly acknowledging that we bone" is basically the definition of a relationship.
Kiss on Cheek: Just Friends
Cheek kisses suggest intimacy, but between two people who used to swap spit, it is the equivalent of sticking out your hand for a handshake when someone is going in for a hug. That is, it's a purposeful distancing mechanism within an already-intimate realm. Exes who cheek kiss in public are close (weirdly close, I'd say, unless European) but nonetheless announcing that they are not what they once were. If they were that, the kiss would have been on the lips.
Jelena Fake-Out Kiss: It's Complicated
Taylor Swift's reaction to Jelena's kiss overshadowed how loaded the act actually was. See how Justin initially leans in for a kiss on the lips, then switches to the cheek at the last minute? This is either the ice-cold action of a man who is totally banging his ex-girlfriend, but can't decide whether he wants to acknowledge her publicly; or the heartbroken actions of a boy trying desperately to win back the affections of his first love, obeying the rules she sets even as he pines for more.
Consensual Butt Touch: Back Together
Attending their daughter Christina's Georgetown graduation, Arnold Schwarzenegger rested his hand on Maria Shriver's right butt cheek, letting it linger for several seconds while the duo walked in tandem. This level of comfortable intimacy — particularly at a family event — suggests that the fact that Arnold and Maria still haven't filed for divorce is, yes, on purpose.
Nonconsensual Butt Touch: Never Ever Getting Back Together
Not all butt touches are created equal, however. Schwarzenegger in particular is believed to sometimes touch the butts of women who have no desire to date him. That's why the butt touch itself does not indicate love; the response to and longevity of the butt touch does. For instance, if Maria had responded to Arnold's touch by whirling around and slapping Arnold, we would know that the relationship was irreparably broken.
Holding Hands: Back Together
Sexless intimacy is sometimes the most meaningful intimacy of all. Platonic adult friends simply do not hold hands in America. If a couple is holding hands, they are back together.
Shaking Hands: Never Ever Getting Back Together
Like the distancing mechanism of a kiss on the cheek, the formality of a handshake between two people who have previously been far more intimate suggests not only that the attraction is dead, but that their relationship is too chilly, even, for a hug. Exes who shake hands are never getting back together.
Caressing Hands: Totally Having Sex, Relationship Status TBD
"Hand sex," as the act of sexily caressing a partner's hands is sometimes called, only occurs in a state of extreme eros. Between exes, that means something combustible is happening. Passion is alive! If a pair of hand-caressing exes are not already boning, then they will definitely be boning soon. Are they back together, though? Their irrepressible hand-lust suggests the togetherness is still new, so it's anybody's guess. After the Jelena kiss, Justin and Selena probably caressed hands all night.
Red-Carpet Appearance: Definitely Back Together
All of the above PDA signals are, of course, imperfect relationship indicators. One signal, however, is utterly irrefutable: When a celebrity couple poses together on a red carpet, they are absolutely, completely, unquestionably back together. (Sharon and Ozzy Osbourne announcing their reunification last week, above. That chin kiss is inscrutable, but the fact that it took place during an arm-in-arm red-carpet appearance is all you need to know.) If only non-celebrities had red carpets to stroll across! Relationships would be so much easier to define.
Doing Any of the Above While Drunk: It's Complicated
The legal system holds us culpable for the crimes committed under the influence. The rules of love are more complex. A blood alcohol content of .08 percent or more results in automatic "It's Complicated" status. "Got drunk and made out in the back of a bar, then asked how his dog is doing, what does it mean?!" is actually the Oxford English Dictionary definition of "It's Complicated." Awkward morning-after text messages optional.
Most Viewed Stories
It’s Harder to Be Thin Than It Was in the ’80s
Why Do I Jerk Awake Right As I’m Falling Asleep?
From Up Close, Raf Simons’s Vision for Dior Is Clear
Michelle Obama: No Boy Is Cute Enough to Keep You From Getting an Education
A Pregnant Supermodel Explains What She Eats
The World’s Easiest Way to Highlight Your Face
Meet the Prom Queen of Instagram
Selfie Sorority Uses Media Frenzy for Good Cause
‘Truly Ugly Guy With Glasses’ Is Europe’s Most Virile Man
Stop Time-Traveling to Such Lame Eras, Losers
From Our Partners
5 Reasons Why Your Vagina Itches
Here's Everything Coming To Netflix In October
Here's What To Buy From J.Crew's HUGE 75-Percent-Off Sale!
Who What Wear
Watch how Chanel's F/W 15 Couture Collection Was Made
powered by PubExchange
The Cut’s Latest Love and War Features8 Actually Good Things That Happened This Week
Baby sea turtles wearing bathing suits and a necklace for your pizza.Selfie Sorority Uses Media Frenzy for Good Cause
Take that, sportscasters.A Comprehensive Taxonomy of Men With Long Hair
And why we like them anyway.Teens Are Dying From Train-Track Photo Shoots
The popular photo destination is actually super-dangerous.‘Truly Ugly Guy With Glasses’ Is Europe’s Most Virile Man
Ed Houben has fathered 106 children — that he knows of.The Internet of Parents Is Miserable and I Love It
Why it's so hard to look away.Did the ‘Maxipad Bandit’ Really Think He’d Escape?
Not so fast, mister.Woman Driven From Her Home by Death Threats After Starting Pro-Choice Hashtag
The hashtag drew intense scorn from anti-abortion activists.Ice-Cold Teens Don’t Hesitate to Block Their Exes
"I’m just like this is irrelevant now.”Let Sorority Girls Instagram Themselves in Peace
Come on, man.
Whether you're Lena Dunham or an emerging writer, the format has an appealing intimacy.The Bennifer Years Affected Matt Damon More Than Anyone Else
It's just really hard when your buddy breaks up with J.Lo, you know?Someone Used Gasoline to Set a Los Angeles–Area Planned Parenthood on Fire
Police believe gasoline was used as an accelerant to burn down the Thousand Oaks facility.Michelle Obama: No Boy Is Cute Enough to Keep You From Getting an Education
"Compete with the boys. Beat the boys."Stop Time-Traveling to Such Lame Eras, Losers
You have a choice, people.New ‘Yelp for People’ Will Let You Rate Everyone You Know
Kind of like Lulu, or Hot or Not, or ...Ruth Bader Ginsburg Is Glad She Was Trained in the ’60s
She's glad she was trained in the Mad Men era.Lena Dunham Apologizes for Joking About Abuse
"When I heard my own quote I was like, 'Jesus, Lena, no.'"Desperate Republicans Attack Planned Parenthood Chief’s Salary
"The disrespect, the misogyny rampant here today tells us what is really going on."Blake Lively’s Lifestyle Is No Longer for Sale
She will Goop no more.