A Ranking of Seven Hotels for Under $200 in New York -- New York Magazine

A Ranking of Seven Hotels for Under $200 a Night. In New York.

Or so close it doesn’t matter.

Add Comment

By Stephen Milioti
Published Jul 15, 2007

The Hyatt Regency in Jersey City.

(Photo: Coutesy of Hyatt Regency)

In many cities besides New York, $200 gets you a nice room at a good hotel, with shampoo, a shower cap, and maybe even an in-room coffeepot. In New York, not so much. But with some digging and some deals, it is possible to find a clean room, a soft mattress, free Internet, and fresh-baked cookies for under two Franklins. I tested seven hotels, staying on weekends and booking rooms online to take advantage of deals. Prices can vary widely (especially in the fall and spring high seasons) and often go up during the week.

1. Hyatt Regency Jersey City on the Hudson
2 Exchange Pl., Jersey City, N.J.; 201-469-1234

PRICE: $199
GREAT VIEWS

The best $200 hotel in New York is in New Jersey—a one-stop, four-minute PATH ride or short Water Taxi ride from lower Manhattan. My room has water and city views (not all do, but my ultranice front-desk agent upgraded me because there was available space). The room is 400 feet, with low-key and sophisticated touches: a granite bathroom sink; a rather masculine taupe, brown, and gray color scheme; a good-size desk for working; and very upscale bedding—plus a spectacular view of the Woolworth Building.

(Photo: Courtesy of the 414 Hotel)

2. 414 Hotel
414 W. 46th St., nr. Ninth Ave.; 212-399-0006

PRICE: $159
QUAINT AND QUIET

The Theater District's 414 Hotel is something of an anomaly. It's a quirky and inexpensive boutique hotel carved out of two historical townhouses separated by a charming, internal courtyard in the middle of the area's flashing lights, high-rises, and pricey hotels.

(Photo: Courtesy of the Comfort Inn)

3. Comfort Inn
42 W. 35th St., nr. Fifth Ave.; 212-947-0200

PRICE: $189
LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION

Thanks to its close proximity to popular sights, the Comfort Inn on 35th Street draws visitors for whom glitzy nearby surroundings trump glitzy accommodations. A short walk from Times Square, the Empire State Building, and Fifth Avenue shopping (among other attractions), the hotel is centrally located for first-time visitors.

(Photo: Courtesy of On the Ave)

4. On the Ave
2178 Broadway, at 77th St.; 212-362-1100

PRICE: $199
BIG ROOMS

It looks like W Lite, with a sparsely chic lobby and self-conscious touches like backlit black-and-white photos of New York in the elevator. The rooms have a similar aesthetic, but they’re well apportioned; mine is a good size, with a clearly delineated seating area, a wing chair, and a separate area for a desk. The bathroom, however, is tiny. The front-desk staff lacks the professionalism of bigger chains (“I’m about to go on my break, so she will gladly help you!” an attendant told me, pointing to her colleague). But at least you’re not in midtown.

(Photo: Courtesy of Affinia Hotels)

5. Eastgate Tower Hotel
222 E. 39th St., nr. Third Ave.; 212-687-8000

PRICE:$149
ADDITIONAL FACILITIES LIKE A MEETING ROOM AND FITNESS CENTER

Formerly a down-and-out Howard Johnson’s, this hotel has a cheery, contemporary lobby and freshly refurbished rooms with a happy look: curving headboards, wide-striped window treatments, and black-and-white cityscape paintings. There’s free coffee and cookies in the lobby. The drawbacks: painfully slow elevators, and the Continental-breakfast area is always packed. Here, you’re always aware of the presence of many, many other people—including large numbers of children and huge clusters of fanny-pack-wearing tourists. And you’ll hear traffic noise if you’re facing busy Eighth Avenue.

(Photo: Courtesy of Hotel 17)

6. Hotel 17
225 E. 17th St., nr. Third Ave.; 212-475-2845

PRICE: $175
GRITTY GLAMOUR

The setting for Woody Allen’s 1993 Manhattan Murder Mystery, this is one of the most love-it-or-hate-it of the bunch. The lobby is teeny, and the rooms, all decorated differently, are in a time warp. Mine has shiny prints, slight wallpaper peels, and dark wood furnishings that are very Addams Family. The bedding is reasonably clean but flimsy, with a thin comforter. There are both shared and private bathrooms, and basically no services, but given the hotel’s shockingly low $125 standard-room rate in low season, ordering in from Joe Jr.’s on Third Avenue isn’t such a hassle.

(Photo: Courtesy of Pod Hotel)

7. The Pod Hotel
230 E. 51st St., nr. Second Ave.; 212-355-0300

PRICE: $179
MOD DÉCOR

This hotel, formerly the cheap, chintzy Pickwick Arms, became the cheap, cool Pod. Rates start at $99, and just over half the rooms have private baths. The aesthetic is standard spare modern: light wood and red comforters with geometric prints. My room, measuring about twelve feet by eight feet, has a bed connected to two side tables, a tiny work desk, small closet nook, and flat-screen TV. There’s a new-paint-over-old feeling, though; the elevators are rickety, the walls are thin, and the mattresses are hard. The hallway smelled like poo for the duration of my one-night stay. For $179, the room-with-bath isn’t a great value; a shared-bath room rate for $125 or less is a decent choice.