Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Best of New York Food 2004

Pie Chart

New York's best pizzas, any way you slice it.

  • Hot and Crusty: The pepperoni  pie at Nick's. (Photo credit: Carina Salvi)
  • Best Restaurant Pie


    307 Spring Street, 212-352-2269

    The pizza station is manned by a pro, and the proof is in the superb, sparingly topped Neapolitan specimens.

  • Best Bar Pie


    25 West 56th Street, 212-332-0500

    This thin-crust, wood-oven-fired ovoid beauty is slicked with a tangy quattro-formaggi mix and wild mushrooms, and rustically served on a wooden plank.

  • Best Pie In Transit


    Central Terminal Building, La Guardia Airport, 718-446-7600

    The signature prosciutto, fig, and Gorgonzola pie is the silver lining in a La Guardia layover.

  • Best Worth-the-Trip Pie

    Di Fara Pizza

    1424 Avenue J, Midwood, Brooklyn, 718-258-1367

    You could fly to Palermo in the time it takes to get here on the Q, but you wouldn’t find such an artful artichoke slice or as succulent a Sicilian.

  • Best Myth-Shattering Pie


    1814 Second Avenue, 212-987-5700; 108-26 Ascan Avenue, Forest Hills, 718-263-1126

    Heavenly mozzarella, a subtly sweet sauce, and a charred, slightly puffy, flavorful crust. Nick’s pie triumphs without the benefit of a fancy oven: no wood, no Vesuvian-lava stone, not even a single brick.

  • Best Old-School Pie


    1524 Neptune Avenue, Coney Island, Brooklyn, 718-372-8606

    The blistered crust, the sweet mozzarella ooze, the dabs of sauce all coalesce into a work of art; the occasional pizzaiolo outburst and no-frills, airline-wine-bottle selection only add to the charm.

From the 2004 Best of New York issue of New York Magazine