- READER REVIEWS
All Reader Reviews of...
299 Madison Ave., 14th fl., New York, NY, 10165
at 41st St.
By Cooper11 on 1/18/2007
I was really excited about this bar--had heard great things and loved the concept. However, there was no happy hour, and the tip that was automatically added to our bill was 20%. The place was completely empty. The staff was perfectly nice, but overall I was disappointed.
Not worth the effort for overpriced bad service
By boblikestoeat on 8/18/2007
If you go for rooftop, there are very limited seats, so there is no chance you will be able to sit outside at peak hours. The inside seating/decor (also quite limited) is pretty basic for NYC, they did the minimum they could do to justify prices, which are very steep: 3 cocktails and one beer was $51 dollars - love that tax on drinks! Staff is completely disorganized - they'll be 6 hostesses swarming you when you arrive (to be sure you sit where they want you to), but good luck trying to get a drink off them. There are other rooftop/outdoor bars in the city that are much better return for your time and money. Note - photos on this website are outdated.
Nice, but very cramped, space and terrible service
By foodielover on 6/30/2008
The space is pretty, but it's way too small. On top of that, the waitresses are terrible. The bartenders are great, but the bar is so cramped that you will need to use the waitress service. The service is slow, incompetent, and snobby. Why would anyone pay so much for a drink in a place with sub-par service? Anyway, this place is past its prime.
Best rooftop bar in NYC
By mannty13 on 8/13/2008
This is the best rooftop bar in the city- great cocktails and super friendly waitstaff. The views are incredible...this is one of my favorite spots in NYC
An Oasis in Midtown
By kenny1966 on 8/13/2008
Came in recently on a tuesday after work, found the bar to be busy but well staffed with beautiful girls in black dresses with pearl necklaces. Once a table outside was availible we were moved outside. the place is very pretty with lots of flowers and very cool archetechture. its a very cozy rooftop with elegant service and no riff raff. if you are looking for a more upscale rooftop experience bookmarks is for you. its worth the prices. if you want to beat the crowds go after 8.
A great spot!
By laurene44 on 8/13/2008
This is a favorite spot for me and my girlfriends. The place is a bit crowded, yes, but the service is always fantastic and the drinks are great. The champagne infused cocktails are a must!
I proposed here!
By mritchie on 8/13/2008
I must say, this is the first review I've ever written but when I saw some of the negative responses I simply HAD to add my two cents! I moved to New York two years ago but before that, I stayed in the Library Hotel quite regularly. Now that I live in the area I still frequent the bar two or three times a month. In fact, I proposed to my wife in the greenhouse last winter! Wonderful place, wonderful people! I informed the staff of my plans and they actually bought rose petals and closed the room off without me even asking. Yes it is slightly expensive, yes it can be crowded, but sometimes that's the price you pay for being the best!
Dirty and rude
By smilelots on 11/23/2008
This is supposed to be a high-end bar, but my wine glass and my boyfriend's wine glass were both dirty! When we complained about it (we informed her of the problem and just asked for new drinks), the waitress was visibly annoyed and she gave us an attitude. Then it took her nearly 20 minutes to get us new drinks. I would never return. I understand if there is a spot on your glass, but it's the servers responsibility to rectify the mistake.
Pat , a must visit
By exFred on 4/8/2009
The people and the place were great. Try this place and the bar downstairs , 'Madison and Vine', you won't be dissappointed. Freddie
Cheesiest hotel bar in NYC
By foodielover on 6/21/2009
This place is so cheesy, and dirty. I will never go back there, especially because of the attitudes of the employees there. If you want to go to a rooftop bar, go to Barna instead!
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- Gastro Tavern
- Gay Bunker
- Half-Shell Haunt
- Home Away From Home
- Hops Haven
- Meat Market
- New Orleans Bar
- Party Train
- People’s Bar
- Shochu Joint
- Spiritual Saloon
- Uptown Hangout
- Whiskey Lounge
- Wine Bar
Best of New York: Fun & Nightlife
Picnics with a view, roller-skating nostalgia, and a party for gay headbangers.