New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Nightlife & Music > Cellar 58

PROFILE
READER REVIEWS

All Reader Reviews of...

Cellar 58

58 Second Ave., New York, NY, 10003
nr. 3rd St.
212-420-1300

Avg. Rating

"Highly Recommended"

Average Reader Rating on a Scale of 10.

100% would go back.

Write your own review

Sort reviews by:
Most Recent
Oldest
Most Positive
Most Negative
Displaying 1-10 of 11

A great experience.

By mark23 on 4/2/2012

Overall Rating: 9
Yes, I would go back!

I had passed through Cellar 58 for a couple of times but never really went in. I was walking with my girlfriend on Tuesday night and heard some nice music playing, so we decided to check it out. The experience was unbelievable. The flamenco music, a great wine list and great food made the experience very enjoyably. All the staff was knowledgeable about the wines, making great recommendations for the food we had. We had: Farro with artichoke, grape tomatoes, aged pecorin.......TO DIE FOR Pappardelle with sausage ragout............AMAZING Chocolate mousse with lingue di gatto cookie....NO WORDS, SO DELICIOUS Overall the ambience, the staff and the food/wine made a good tuesday night. I will definitely go back to try more wines.

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
8 out of 15 people found this review helpful.

Conversing and Drinking

By cclancyrobert on 11/23/2010

Overall Rating: 10
Yes, I would go back!

This is a great bar for conversation and casual drinking. The atmosphere is chill, the crowd was good looking when I came here and the service was spectacular. They make you feel special here.

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
15 out of 29 people found this review helpful.

Great After Work Spot

By arronpagee on 11/23/2010

Overall Rating: 10
Yes, I would go back!

I came here with a coworker. There were only a few people when we got here after work but it quickly turned into an intimate crowd where everyone seemed like they were friends. Maybe it was the wine but I had a great time here. Cellar 58 one of those local spots that make NYC great.

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
17 out of 31 people found this review helpful.

Good Wine Bar

By heatharnold63 on 9/9/2010

Overall Rating: 10
Yes, I would go back!

This is a great bar for conversation and casual drinking. The atmosphere is chill, the crowd was good looking when I came here and the service was spectacular. They make you feel special here.

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
14 out of 31 people found this review helpful.

Maria the Owner

By ericcatania90 on 9/9/2010

Overall Rating: 10
Yes, I would go back!

If you go to Cellar 58, make sure you talk to the owner Maria. She's a great, warm Italian mother who will take of you and your friends. I love her.. There's not a thing I wouldn't do for her, including taking time to write a review for her awesome food and even better wine. Cellar 58 Rocks!

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
25 out of 45 people found this review helpful.

Girls Night Out

By arenatrudy on 8/26/2010

Overall Rating: 10
Yes, I would go back!

I love this bar. It's great for girls night out even though you probably won't find many boys here. It's a shame. Why are all the best wine spots filled with only women? Boys - you need to stop going to those sports bars and let us women treat you with some sophisticated touches..

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
19 out of 37 people found this review helpful.

Spanish Wines

By ellasikora375 on 8/26/2010

Overall Rating: 10
Yes, I would go back!

I heard about this place from coworkers.. It was everything they said, charming, romantic, spirited, spunky, perfect for conversation. They had a dj the night I came. I highly recommend their muscles and Chilean Sea Bass.

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
23 out of 39 people found this review helpful.

Wine and Shorts

By nancyelliott39 on 8/9/2010

Overall Rating: 10
Yes, I would go back!

I went to Cellar 58 with my Zogsports teammates. I was worried about going to a wine bar in tshirts and shorts, but we sat outside and nearly closed out the place. Watch yourself here because you can easily stop by for one night and stay all night. Best place by far in the ev.

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
16 out of 32 people found this review helpful.

Women Love Wine and Cellar 58

By rudolphshirey on 8/2/2010

Overall Rating: 10
Yes, I would go back!

Why didn't someone tell me earlier that women love wine? I went to this bar with my buddy after we saw a group of 4 girls sitting outside, drinking wine on their outdoor patio. Not sure if it was the wine, neighborhood, or bar, but everyone here was friendly. I met several girls inside and walked away with a few numbers. Love this place. I now need to learn my wine etiquette. Cellar 58 Rocks

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
21 out of 39 people found this review helpful.

CELLAR 58 ....THE BEST!

By Elizabeth84 on 11/5/2009

Overall Rating: 10
Yes, I would go back!

Did you ever try Torta al Testo ? It’s a fantastic Umbrian flatbread that I ate at CELLAR 58 with prosciutto and mozzarella and pecorino cheese … TERRIFIC ! And the wine? Over 120 wines! Very nice people, excellent service and great Chef Andrea Tiberi

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
29 out of 71 people found this review helpful.