- READER REVIEWS
All Reader Reviews of...
94 Prince St., New York, NY, 10012
at Mercer St.
Fan of Fanelli's
By gelf on 9/4/2010
Fanelli's was our home-away-from-home for 15 years. Spent many weekends, major holidays & the evening of 9/11 there not only the great food, but the great company & service. They were like family and have mastered the art of maintaining the integrity of old New York. xo
By donaldwaits on 8/14/2009
I was a patron of this bar for 30 years, seldom missing a day or night. As a would-be painter, the place was a living room for all of the artists in the area. Great bartenders, great food, beautiful wait staff, it had everything. I say had because if was forced out of N.Y. in 1994 by the rents and the smoking police. But even today, I can send friends from New Orleans to the place and they are treated with superb service and a good time. Long live Fanelli.
By donaldwaits on 7/11/2009
Fanelli Cafe was my living room for 30 years until the smoking ban took place. My memories are so wonderful and positive about the place that I cry just thinking about ihem. The many terrific friends I met on a daily basis kept me happy and content for three decades. The wait staff (we called them waitresses in those days) were always beautiful and friendly. Larry Trapp was the king of bartenders. I moved to New Orleans in 1994 and send all of my friends to the Fanelli Cafe when they visit New York. (By the way, the name is NOT "Fanelli's"!)
Fell in love at Fanelli's
By slowpokemary on 11/12/2008
First went there 24 years ago, with my then-boyfriend. Friends who lived the neighborhood said the food was good. It was more than good! It was fabulous. Shepherd's pie and pasta primavera, a bottle of wine and great conversation with people sitting nearby. For about $20. We fell in love on that trip to NYC and partially credit a wonderful evening at Fanelli's. Now husband of 23 years and I took our kids there 18 years later - they loved it, too. We met a great character there this time who was drunk as a skunk and told us the whole history of the bar. I pointed out to my family later that the "drunk" was wearing $400 loafers and Brooke's Brothers casual! You never know who you'll meet there.
Best bar in New York
By gburts on 4/23/2008
First visitied NY in Dec 2004 and popped in here for some soup on a cold christmas afternoon after buying an ipod next door. It was the best soup i ever tasted. Was in NY again last week and simply had to call in to see if they could satisfy my hunger for a second time. Did they What? I had the best burger i've ever taseted. Melt in the mouth it was. I cannot wait to go back again. Good looking staff to boot. They should put this bar on a plane and fly it back to Ireland. As Arnie once said "I'll be back"
Maryland Crabcake Sandwich
By JonesF1 on 1/29/2008
Stumbled upon this place during a hard days shopping. The service was great despite how busy it was and the Maryland crabcake sandwich was to die for. Can't wait to go back.
By Francisxmc on 12/23/2008
Why isn't the fact that Fanelli's is the third oldest drinking establishment in New York City along with a rich history not mentioned. Their history is posted in the Prince Street window and handouts are in a box inside the front door. In addition, they have a collection of their 19th century saloon licenses on the back room restaurant wall.
Great Hunger Buster in Middle of Christmas Tour
By swynne on 12/31/2003
Just to sit down and grab a burger was great. Service was quick and responsive. Would definitely hit it again.
Open Early, Open Late
By roastbeef on 1/31/2003
OK, so my fondest memories of Fanelli's have taken place before 11 in the morning, but they do make the best bloody mary going. They start with Absolut Citron, and make each one individually. Toss back two of these devils and the night before feels like it's still going strong. I think it's best to just pop in for a coupla pops, chat with the bartender, crusty regular or Sasha, the owner, and head on to the next place.
Arrogant Bar tender
By AnthonyJordan54 on 3/12/2013
Today we stopped by to have a couple of beers and a plate of French fries. French fries were average and then we got the bill. Being from Southern Africa we are not used to the custom and on a $26 bill we left $3. The Bar tender threw it back at me and told me 15-20% tip. On asking what she'd prefer she told me she'd done her job and it was now time to do mine. Gobsmacked and probably stupidly i handed her $5. I have many friends coming over to holiday and i will be sure to tell them not to bother stopping by. Lady in my custom, arrogance like yours should have left you with no tip at all!
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- Gastro Tavern
- Gay Bunker
- Half-Shell Haunt
- Home Away From Home
- Hops Haven
- Meat Market
- New Orleans Bar
- Party Train
- People’s Bar
- Shochu Joint
- Spiritual Saloon
- Uptown Hangout
- Whiskey Lounge
- Wine Bar
Best of New York: Fun & Nightlife
Picnics with a view, roller-skating nostalgia, and a party for gay headbangers.