- READER REVIEWS
All Reader Reviews of...
50 W. 17th St., New York, NY, 10011
nr. Sixth Ave.
You have got to be kidding me ...
By Nico22 on 6/17/2009
As a born and bred Chelsea Girl, I found myself here on countless nights for arbitrary reasons over the past 5 years (some of which I was not legal). On a recent Saturday night, I met a friend outside and tried to get in to meet a larger party. I was denied entrance at the door ... because I was a girl! They were apparently "packed" and they had "no room for girls". I understand this is a gay bar, but I felt the way the talked to me and handled the whole situation was very offensive.
what did they do?
By jjbartendernj on 10/11/2009
As a bartender myself, I must say something about their bartenders. I stood their watching them pouring the drinks. For instence, I saw a bartender making a Greygoose with coke. It should be 1 oz Greygoose and top with coke. However, the bartender poured 2oz + Greygoose and top with coke. Because of that, I only ordered a bottle of Corona with lime wedge for my sake. Anyway, I believe that was my last time going to Splash.
By oh.kay.50 on 3/7/2013
After our table had spent at least $80 with four people, one remaining friend and I suddenly found that the table in front of us was being taken away to clear a dance floor. I was halfway through a drink. A tall bouncer came and stood in front of me as I finished the drink, barking "one minute" at me. There was no discussion about moving to another table, there was no apology or explanation about needing to clear the tables out for the dance floor... we were suddenly and within a few minutes being treated like criminals after spending lots of money, tipping, and causing no problems. All the furniture around us was removed. I was indignant and stayed on my stool, finishing my $9 drink. The drink was suddenly ripped out of my hand. My stuff was thrown across the dance floor by a bouncer, and I was called a "bitch" by a weird guy who was a manager or something, who put his hands on my hips. I gathered up my stuff and then was picked up by a bouncer and physically removed from the bar. I suffered minor injuries on my knee and wrist was called "ugly" by the bouncer. I cannot believe this treatment--no reasonable, semi-apologietic conversation or appeal was made to ask us to switch tables. Yes, I was shoked by the poor customer service and sudden removal of the furniture around us, and therefore refused to move (really, a total of 2 minutes, we were leaving anyway) until I finished my drink. The use of physical force against me, especially in a gay bar, was totally shocking.
OLD GAY MEN & HS boys GALORE
By lover24 on 6/5/2009
What happened to this place??? I used to go there ALL the time and there were always plenty of cute young guys (in there 20s)..but now it' s filled with old sleazy looking men. WHERE ARE ALL THE CUTIES?? This place has let itself go. Also besides the really OLD men...there seems to a lot of really young (obviously younger than 21). Do they check IDs???...it's obvious that they're not selective as to who they let in. *sigh* This place is so OVER. But if you're an old searching for a nubile young thing...I guess this is the place for you.
What happened to the go-go boys they used to have?
By jjbartendernj on 10/11/2009
As soon as I walked into the club, I realized the big differences of the interior designs now than six years ago. At the same time, I also noticed the huge differences of its clientiles now than six years ago. There used to be young and handsome guys, but last night most of the guys there could be my sugar daddy. In addition, there were about 10 go-go boys last night but only one or two of them knew how to dance. Yes, I had to admit they all were eye-candies but that doesn't make them just stand on the stages to watch others dancing. I still remember six years ago, Splash had four or five go-go dancers a night they were very professional. Unfortunately, last night that bubble just bursted.
By FTC5150 on 3/26/2008
Great place to dance and hang out with friends on a drunken night. I don't make it to most of the special guest events, but my friends believe fun then super fun. The client√®le is made of beautiful young men. That being said, don't expect to make good friendly conversation with someone at the bar unless you are good-looking and a good kisser. Splash is just a fun place to unwind and have stupid fun.
By geneebivins on 8/22/2010
I'm an occasional visitor to NYC, to stay with a friend and go to the Met. We never miss a stop at Splash for a drink and sometimes go after the opera. I love the atmosphere and the boys are fun to watch, if nothing else. Methinks a few people with age issues have left reviews here; the clientele is very mixed and not at all majority "old." A great place to unwind, and definitely always on my NYC agenda!
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- Gastro Tavern
- Gay Bunker
- Half-Shell Haunt
- Home Away From Home
- Hops Haven
- Meat Market
- New Orleans Bar
- Party Train
- People’s Bar
- Shochu Joint
- Spiritual Saloon
- Uptown Hangout
- Whiskey Lounge
- Wine Bar
Best of New York: Fun & Nightlife
Picnics with a view, roller-skating nostalgia, and a party for gay headbangers.