All Reader Reviews of...
191 Seventh Ave., New York, NY, 10011
nr. 21st St.
Maybe not during party season
By nycfellow on 12/20/2013
Entering Il Bastardo at around 7:30, I hit a wall of noise. It was holiday party season, and some such gatherings may have been present though not filling this very large space. We finally shouted loud enough for the maitre d to understand us and seat us in a distant corner. Still noisy, but possible to converse. Service was sluggish, but one makes allowances for mobbed evenings. The food and service were adequate. A baby beet salad was greens on top of part of a shaved medium-size beet. Not very beet-y, but okay. A braised lamp shank was quite good, though the seasoning seemed more salt than herbs and garlic. Orecchiette with broccoli rabe and sausage was good.
Great food, good atmosphere
By zgold55 on 5/8/2010
Fun place for dinner - doesn't really fill up until later on in the night. Waiter was friendly and helpful - overall would probably go back.
By nycdoll on 7/1/2009
Had dinner here last night. Very, very loud in the second dining room after the bar. Definitely not a good idea for talking to anyone. So no good for client dinners or catching up with family. Food was just ok. Nothing really special. Entree portions were actually small for the prices and the type of Italian restaurant this is.
Not bad for a large group
By krodster on 6/1/2009
Was just here for brunch on Sunday with approx 12 girls for the all you can drink for $15, which was totally worth it. The food wasn't exceptional, but for the price wasn't too bad. We shmoozed our waiter a little bit and definitely got a little extra out of the all you can drink, which was great. the venue isn't exactly stellar but for a large group they are quite accommodating. Considering we were such a large group the service was exceptional and timely. I would recommend it for larger gatherings when people are concerned about prices, otherwise it's nothing spectacular.
Very nice , Cool, Comfortable and great food
By dme13 on 5/26/2009
Must see and be seen yet private and great food and the white Sangria is terriffic. love the Lasangne
My favorite "Go to" place!
By GramercyGal on 1/13/2009
I adore this restaurant. This has become my "go to" restaurant this past year. it's one of those places that I feel comfortable bringing anyone to have a great meal in a beautiful place without it being pretentious. It's perfect for a date, for groups, for families, we've done birthday parties, new year's here... really spectacular. The food is consistently delicious and always exceeds my expectations. The service and staff are wonderful and helpful. The drinks are kickin' and the bar tenders are great. I've even met the owner a few times and he's delightful! I'll be going back here again and again!
By amarei on 3/31/2008
I was there on a business lunch about a month ago. The bathrooms were filthy (which meant that they where not cleaned the night before), there was construction going on so there was tarp and dust everywhere, a mouse ran across the dining area and the waiter chased it with a broom. He told us it was only a little mouse and that he took care of it. I got up and left before the food arrived.
Studiously Sleek Crowd - Hardly
By cabett on 2/1/2008
Numerous reviews stated this place was a 'hot-spot' in Chelsea. I took out of town guests here hoping to show them a good time with a 20-something crowd. Not so. The place was EMPTY and the only guests were in their 50s. I was thoroughly embarrassed to be there after informing my guests this would be a fun place for cocktails and drinks. The food was barely average and it was not worth the money.
"You screwed me, " said the waiter
By tess on 11/1/2007
Honestly, last night was one of the worst experiences I have ever had at a Manhattan restaurant, make that any restaurant, anywhere. We were subjected to the MOST obnoxious server I have ever encountered. He was angry about a table mix-up (the fault of the hostess & manager, not my friends and I), berated us repeatedly, and when he finally deigned to take our order after making us wait 30 minutes, informed the table, "You screwed me." It was outrageous, unbelievable, not to mention HOSTILE. I will never, ever set foot in this place again. If we had not been such a large party we would have left, but it would have been near-impossible finding a place on Halloween night in Chelsea. A tip: Le Zie is infinitely better, and close by...and sans rude Italian servers.
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- Scientists â€‹Pretty Sure Humans Could Eat Food Grown in Martian Soil
- Another Restaurant Bites the Dust on Clinton Street
- A Talented Pastry Chef Will Open a New Bakery in the Rockaways
- This 3-D Food Printer Actually Makes Pizza So You Don’t Have To
- Bergen Hill Relocates to Noho With a Seafood-Heavy Menu