All Reader Reviews of...
35 E. 18th St., New York, NY, 10003
By crowdancer on 10/20/2014
We found the menu inventive, uniformly delicious, and the service welcoming. The pork dish is nirvana. Our only negative was the noise level, but then, that's what people seem to want. I have gone back again...and again...and again.
By vanessa.duve on 6/25/2013
We were 5 people, all of our food was average, the portions almost invisible, one of us walked out with food poisoning....an 'the emperor has no clothes' restaurant...
Overpriced and Overrated
By foodstyle on 3/15/2013
We have eaten at this restaurant at least four times prior and last night was a huge disappointment. Beautiful space, very sceney with lots of people, but an unfriendly and disinterested waiter, along with extremely disappointing food made for a not so pleasant evening. Blah pasta, pizza, dry calamari. When did everything on this menu become so spicy? I could not even eat the roasted carrots in the carrot/avocado salad because they were so spiced with hot chiles- and not even in the description. Roasted beets? So spicy one person could only eat one bite. Sea bass stuffed with hot chiles- What???? $400 later- this is what we get. Sadly, churning out a lot of dinners over many days and years has taken a toll on this place. Never again.
By salban on 3/13/2012
The restaurant itself is beautiful with its use of natural elements, like exposed wood beams, tree branches, stones, and flowers, all against soft white walls and lit with natural lighting. The food was similarly light and ethereal. The raw diver scallops served with toasted pistachios and pickled peppers were a fun way to start the meal and were possibly the most impressive dish in that they matched an unusual pairing of flavors with great success. The kabocha squash toast was a comforting dish that paired nicely with the lighter scallops appetizer. As an entree I tried the tuna burger special and my friend had the hamburger. Both were served perfectly. I had asked for mine rare and received a burger that had been seared on the outside but was still much like tartare on the inside... perfect. Overall the meal was a very pleasant experience.
ABC Kitchen Restaurant
By jerseyboy on 3/7/2011
Unimpressed by the distinctive and classy atmosphere, because the food underwhelmed: avoid the pasta/bowties with kasha /veal meatballs....The bread was unimpressive, the calamari were dry and there was a haughty waiter taking care of our table...he was unfriendly. Overall, it is overpriced for the quality and taste...The pasta/ bowties dish was tremendously overpeppered.
By orangeblossom on 1/25/2011
Food was good, the ambiance was really good. I'll definitely go there again. My only problem was with how they were serving the white wine; white wine is supposed to be filled with least amount possible so that it stays chilled, but our server was just trying to poor the whole bottle into glasses, so that we ordered more. so sneaky
By shetoronto on 1/7/2011
When my husband said he didn't want to stay I should have listened and ran. The girls at the front desk were friendly and accomodating and sat us early. However, the servers seem to be on another planet and so it took awhile to get the food ordered. I wish it hadn't been ordered. The plate of buttnernut squash was swimming in a pool of oil. The french fries were greasy and the hamburgers were tasteless. The desserts was no better than eating a cup of lard. How unappetizing to eat off plates that looked dirty and grimy with large black streaks. The silverware was so beaten up that they looked like they had been bought at a garage sale ( I heard they were bought on Ebay---that is for sure). Looking around the room I noticed that most people had not finished their food either.I can't believe that this is a Jean-Georges restaurant! then.......
MEDIOCRE AND SALTY
By lolalex10 on 11/13/2010
I am a big fan of NY restaurants and rarely am I that disappointed. I expected the food to be much better... Extremely salty, not interesting tastes, there is an effort to create nouvelle american cuisine but ABC just does not do it. Sweets were too sweet, the special steak of the day was just bad and over-priced, the portions were too small, what makes the place is just the ambience rather than the food. It could have been much better but I was very disappointed by its quality. Sure, presentation, plates, decor, is important, but taste is more important and I have no good comments on taste. The cod we ordered was way too thin, the mushrooms under too buttery... The bread on the crab appetizer was burned, and again, the aftertaste was salt for the rest of the night.
Bring Noise Canceling Headphones
By tapwatersfine on 9/17/2010
We are big fans of the innovative culinary genius of Jean-Georges. Perry St has the best prix fixe deal in town; JoJo is always delicious; Nougatine is terrific, and for a special occasion, Jean-Georges is our favorite "big deal" restaurant. We went to ABC Kitchen right after it opened. The concept was charming; the food was uneven, and it was painfully loud. We went back last night -- same deal. It's like a Jean-Georges tribute band, with bad service (it shouldn't take 30 minutes to get a glass of wine). And it's still REALLY LOUD. Peekytoe crab toast is yummy, but it's better at Perry St. Same with the calamari -- rubbery at ABC; ethereal at Perry St. And the ABC pizza -- horrifying. I would never go back.
Love this place -- fresh all around -- Order the Sundae for dessert
By joycevdb on 8/1/2010
Absolutely loved this place. Pretty, white & chic. The food was probably the freshest tasting food I've ever had. Service: Highly attentive, friendly and knowledgeable. Concept: Sustainable food - farm fresh. The back of the menu gave credits to all the local farm providers. We started out with the Cured meats & local cheese platter (although the cheese portions were pretty petite as one reviewer did point out) they were excellent pairings of prosciutto/salami and sharp soft cheeses. Definitely try the Peeky toe crab toast if its on the menu -- it was out of this world, so fresh and light. For the entrees we had the Lobster - which was very rich, but perfectly cooked with a lemony vinaigrette, and the Black Sea Bass with chiles, and spinach, red bliss potatoes tasted so amazingly fresh as if it just swam by and we plucked it out of the ocean... For dessert he had the Blueberry Pie and I had the Sundae with Salted Caramel Ice Cream, candied peanuts, caramel popcorn, chocolate sauce and whipped cream - which was like a religious experience. We paired it all with a light and refreshing Handley Cellars Chardonnay 2007 from Alexander Valley. All in all a perfect night. We will be back.
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- Hundreds of Frozen Foods at Costco, Walmart, and Trader Joe’s Recalled Over Listeria Fears
- America Finally Realizing Subway’s Sandwiches Aren’t Very Good
- Supreme Court Won’t Stand in the Way of Seattle’s $15 Minimum Wage
- Congress Introduced a Bill to Keep Journalists From Snooping Around Big Food
- A Farming Cartoonist Was Fired for Joking About Big Agriculture