All Reader Reviews of...
411 Park Ave. South, New York, NY, 10016
nr. 29th St.
By fionamoriarty on 8/16/2011
I recently went to Brasserie Les Halle for Brunch after Penelope on lex and 30th was overstuffed with people. The service was simply horrendous. We waited 15 minutes to get a glass of water, the server forgot to take our orders and when we finally did get our food, it was only okay. For 17 dollars brunch includes a drink which whether or not you get it, they will charge you for. Also the server never informed us that any change to a dish would result in a 2 or 4 dolalr charge. So our brunch total for two people who got no drinks and simple omelettes? 50 dollars. Bad value, worse service and my worst brunch experience in nyc yet.
By mandk on 9/25/2009
Went on a Saturday night at about 10:30 pm. Chose to sit outside for dinner b/c of the noise level inside. Waitress was in a hurry to take our order. We told her we wanted time to look at the menu and ordered pre-dinner drinks. She came back 3 times to ask if we wanted to order but never brought the drinks. When reminded, she said she forgot. So we ordered a bottle of wine to drink instead. That was brought rather quickly, and again she wanted to take our order. We just wanted to relax with a drink before dinner! But we gave her our order anyway. We never saw her after our meal arrived. Which was too bad, b/c the choucroute garnie didn't have the potatoes included, although they were listed on the menu. Also, inside diners came out and smoked right next to us on the sidewalk. Not nice.
Half off wine, and less than half the flavor.
By Hemps on 8/4/2009
Went there on Monday night for their great 50% off wine list. We had some spectacular wines that we never would've ordered( St. Estephe 04), but the food was pretty bad. Between the four of us, we had the escargot, steak frites, mussels, and rotiserie chicken frites, and all were poorly cooked. Chicken and steak were severely overdone, and the escargots lacked any measure of complexity. (even the homeless guy I gave my leftover chicken too complained about how tough it was ;) . Additionally, our waiter was slow, and they were out of some of the wines that we ordered. If it wasn't for the 50% off wine, we'd be very disappointed. Skip Les Halles, unless you're going just for drinks.
Solid Bistro Fare
By jaw1 on 12/29/2008
Went last week - attentive and knowledgable waitstaff, terrific lamb chops/frites and duck confit. Best creme brulee I've had in a while. Seating just a bit cramped but noise level not off the charts. Oh, and GREAT fries...
Great food at a decent price
By bb10065 on 10/25/2008
We had an excellent meal here. The waitstaff had great suggestions, and we tried a variety of things from the escargot to the steak frites, and loved all of it. The prices were reasonable and the atmosphere casual. We will return many times over.
Good food and a fun atmosphere
By krosenberg8 on 10/2/2008
I went to Les Halles a few years ago and was also unimpressed by the service. I went back tonight, and things had changed. My waiter was well-informed on the specials, the wine list and the menu. He didn't pressure my date or I to order alcohol to increase the check. I had the steak frites ($19.50) and escargot which were both delicious. I gave the restaurant a "7" for value because my date's scotch was $16 (Oban, a single). The restaurant had a good busy vibe but was not too loud. I will now be going back more often.
Waiters in a dreamworld of nonchalance
By superdaws on 5/29/2007
Such a shame when a restaurant serving food of good quality is let down by the carefree attitude of the waiting staff. If I hadn't been paying I would have laughed out loud at the incompetence. After being served our steaks and enquiring after the bottle of wine I had ordered in the not too distant past, I had to leave my seat to try and wake the staff out of their inaction. On eventual arrival it was offered to the diners next to us whose bottle was also MIA. No apology offered. Just a "merci beaucoup" for accepting it. Fellow diners had their barely finished starters briskly whisked away to make room for the impatient entrees. Almost as funny as 'No Reservations". Bravo !
Excellent Food, terrible service
By mmb on 4/18/2003
I have never been rushed through a meal the way I was at les Halles. The waiter hovered while we perused the menus, entrees were brought before we were finished with our appetizers and a meal with drinks, appetizers, entrees, wine and dessert was finished in just more than an hour. Not acceptable when spending $200 per couple. Complaining to the management got us nowhere...
Crowded, loud, disappointing food
By zeecee on 3/31/2003
We've given Les Halles a few chances, mostly because it looks so convincingly Parisian, has the butcher area as you enter with fresh looking meat, but the food is never up to the level of other bistros we enjoy more. The steak-frites is always somethign to judge by and if you can leave over the steak and some fries, it's not the place you want to call your own. There's a frantic quality. Tables are set too close to one another. While it has the look, it doesn't have the kitchen to match. I'm happier with steak/frites at Balthazar, Pastis or Le Jardin.
Why go to Paris?
By wudzee on 3/15/2003
Parisian spirit in ambience but not in attitude. You always know what you get - great bistro food. Steak frites, reasonably priced red wines, here's the beef. Steak tartare or hanger steak, think of Paris and you can't go wrong.
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- Scientists â€‹Pretty Sure Humans Could Eat Food Grown in Martian Soil
- Another Restaurant Bites the Dust on Clinton Street
- A Talented Pastry Chef Will Open a New Bakery in the Rockaways
- This 3-D Food Printer Actually Makes Pizza So You Don’t Have To
- Bergen Hill Relocates to Noho With a Seafood-Heavy Menu