119 W. 56th St., New York, NY, 10019
nr. Sixth Ave.
By CLALLL on 2/26/2008
No question about it, the best for the cost. Nicely proportioned, perfectly charred, juicy, the right bun. Only that the meat doesnot have much flavor. Resto's has better meat flavor, but costs nearly double.
By january12 on 2/27/2008
We have been to this place twice before, and really liked it. Liked it enough that we had a gift certificate given to us for our wedding. Turns out they wouldn't accept it. The woman behind the counter kept calling it a 'fake!' Quite embarrassing actually. She gave us such attitude saying it was a 'fake' and couldn't accept it. Even after we explained it was part of our wedding gift. It could have been delt with so much better, the dismissal was the worst. Now we have to go back to the person that gave us the gift, and he has to try and get his money a back. Again embarassing. Such poor customer service in dealing with this issue.
By betteroffffed on 12/6/2011
This place is a complete disgrace on every level. McDonald's quality fries, badly over-cooked sub-par burger and stylized tourist-trap attempt to be funky and original. Stand in line with all the tourists for this garbage? Never again! Give it a pass.
By centralpark on 4/11/2003
It's a great deal for a decent burger, but only for the neighborhood. There are better burgers all over town.
By hslev on 1/6/2010
The way everyone raves about this place I was expecting something special. All I got was a big disappointment. The burger isn't as good as my local coffee shop; the fries are nowhere as good as McDonald's. The setting is drab and depressing. If I were a European tourist staying at the hotel it might be a fun alternative to room service, but as a New Yorker I'll never set foot in there again.
By hungryjacq on 7/25/2003
I like burgers as much as the next person. Really. Maybe even more. Not as confident as others that these burgers are the second coming. I'm still more partial to Jackson Hole-style, too-big-to-finish-in-one-sitting burgers. These are definitely among the best for burgers you can actually pick up with your hands. Just don't be surprised...the decor belies the UWS location.
By dimensionless on 1/4/2010
I went to the Burger Joint expecting to find the "best burgers in NY", as stated by countless reviews and tourist guide books. What I was served was a ball of grocery-store-grade ground beef with a slice of tomato, lettuce and pickles, between two pieces of cheap hamburger bread. When I go for "the best burger in town", I expect to taste something beyond the regular hamburger, with unique spices, sauce and high-quality meat. I also expect good fresh bread. If I want to eat a patty of flavorless ground meat, I'll do it in my own kitchen. The setting is extremely cool, and I think is worth the detour. But do yourself a favor and skip the food. Your money will be better invested at your nearest McDonald's.
By Jveldkamp on 3/5/2011
As a semi-professional cook from Europe I think this was a enormous disappointment. I was told to go to this place to find the best hamburger in New York. I expected something with outstanding flavor. I don't get the cheap bread, bread is I think as much as important as the quality of the meat itself. I thought there would be a homemade hamburger sauce which can give a hamburger this unique unexpected touch. Cheap cheddar cheese, a slice of poor quality tomato. Overall it was really disappointing. Even the seasoning was way to poor. A bit more salt and pepper would be a huge improvement. People are flattered by the location in such a nice hotel, and therefore like this place. But the hospitality of the burger joint has nothing to do with the hospitality of the hotel itself. My hunt for the best burger isn't over yet!
By drsdakhil on 4/10/2008
The burger is flavoured and juicy but expect the the ultimate rudness from the staff, and you might face a long line to order and long wait for a table
By iloveit on 1/1/2009
it was O K but is it worth $7? I feel sad that it's hard to find cheap & good food here.