Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > Carmine's

All Reader Reviews of...

Carmine's

200 W. 44th St., New York, NY, 10036
nr. Broadway
212-221-3800

Avg. Rating

6
Food: 5
Service: 6
Décor: 7
"Mixed Reviews"

Average Reader Rating on a Scale of 10.

38% would go back.

Write your own review

Not real Italian

By rrh233 on 9/24/2006

  • Overall Rating: 5
  • Food: 5
  • Service: 5
  • Décor: 5
  • No, I would not go back!

This is a very americanized "italian" place. Spaghetti and Meat balls never go together in Italy... It is just unheard of. If you go there you are going for the quantity and not the actual taste of the plates. If you are looking for the average american italian place then I guess you are in luck because this is the place to be!

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
372 out of 686 people found this review helpful.

Don't waste your time

By The_G_man on 1/2/2007

  • Overall Rating: 4
  • Food: 2
  • Service: 6
  • Décor: 8
  • No, I would not go back!

If you like good italian food, don't waste your time and money here when there are many awesome places in NYC. Seriously the quality is on par with the Olive Garden. No joke. I took the time to create an account here just so I could warn people!

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
288 out of 590 people found this review helpful.

Drama in the Theater locale

By degirlz on 8/24/2007

  • Overall Rating: 5
  • Food: 6
  • Service: 4
  • Décor: 7
  • No, I would not go back!

I am a fan of their Upper West Side location, but I recently went in with a few colleagues for a business lunch. On my last visit, the main hostess was speaking to a young lady & then errupted into loud & very obscene language, following said young lady out onto the sidewalk to continue her tirade. From what I understand, she still has a job

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
261 out of 482 people found this review helpful.

Hugely overrated

By aviddiner on 8/26/2007

  • Overall Rating: 2
  • Food: 2
  • Service: 2
  • Décor: 3
  • No, I would not go back!

It came highly recommended and when we arrived, the hostess could not have been more rude. It was as if she were doing us a favor by seating us. The service was nonexistent, the food arrived luke warm and was not memorable once we had it served at the proper temperature. Go to McDonalds, at least you'll get what you're expecting!

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
200 out of 431 people found this review helpful.

Amazing! Reviewer's must be scheister's

By dangitjess on 7/22/2008

  • Overall Rating: 10
  • Food: 10
  • Service: 10
  • Décor: 10
  • Yes, I would go back!

Are these people losing it? Carmine's is so fabulous we are making another trip and have already planned to bring our 4 kids with us this time so they are able to experience everything we did there. The food portions are excessively generous. Doesn't taste like from Italy but it is great tasting regardless! American Italian yes but great beautiful salads. the place smells amazing, Beautiful bold colored foods. Great wine choices. Beautifully decorated. Our server was incredibly cordial, pleasant and KIND! They took us moments before they closed and got us everything we asked for even though they were closed. Can't wait to make the long trek to Carmine's from Florida once we arrive August 15th! Was the best rest. we experienced there. Don't miss it!

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
110 out of 211 people found this review helpful.

loved it

By bluerose on 8/7/2008

  • Overall Rating: 9
  • Food: 8
  • Service: 10
  • Décor: 10
  • Yes, I would go back!

the service there was impeccable. the waiters were quick with orders, amiable and approachable. the food was excellent, though the fish of the day was slightly oily...but it still tasted good

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
102 out of 201 people found this review helpful.

Pleasant Experience

By DanaC on 10/5/2009

  • Overall Rating: 8
  • Food: 7
  • Service: 9
  • Décor: 9
  • Yes, I would go back!

While I agree with the other reviews in that you can find more authentic (less Americanized) Italian in the city, I still thought Carmine's was a worth-while experience. Traveling to the city often for business, I look for relaxing atmospheres for my coworkers and I to meet once our day is over. Carmine's provided that. Their sommelier took time to speak with us and recommend bottles of wine from the collection. The family-style portions ended up being reasonably priced (~$40-50 for an entree with pasta added will easily feed 4 people). We arrived as shows were starting, caught the restaurant during its turnover from theatre crowd to evening crowd, and were seated immediately. It is worth noting, both when considering just dropping in without reservations as well as how quickly you have to eat and leave, that Carmine's does get very busy. As the restaurant filled up, the service became slower, but not unreasonable.

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
113 out of 216 people found this review helpful.

Crap Hole on Broadway

By MAARRS on 12/8/2012

  • Overall Rating: 1
  • Food: 1
  • Service: 1
  • Décor: 1
  • No, I would not go back!

If you can't get down to the tourist traps on the Chinatown corner known as 'Little Italy', you can always come to Carmines to eat microwaved food with a side of NYC attitude delivered to your table by Midwestern acting school rejects performing as servers. The entire place is a post-modern mindfk of walking cliches. The food is 'eye-talian', as in Olive Garden for grown-ups; the decor is Times Sq. hey-day that needs a serious dusting off, and the management thinks standing around useless in a Century 21 suit makes them a Don. You think it's worth the over-pricing for 'convenience' but forget it. They can't figure how to turn over tables for theater patrons, they ignore tables, and the staff complained TO ME that they were over booked and slammed. Kiddo, at these prices, get a shrink and work it out on your own time. EPIC FAIL. (Unless you're from Iowa, here to see Rock of Ages and plan on buying a souvenir piece of cardboard with your name written in 'chinese' - then you're in the right place)

Did you find this review helpful?
Yes No Request Removal
44 out of 85 people found this review helpful.

Add Comment

You will be prompted to sign in with your NYMag or
Facebook account.

  awful average excellent
In determining overall rating, food and service are given more weight.
Rate
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Food
Service
Décor
Would you go back?

Some Hints:

  • The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
  • If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
  • Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
  • Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
CloseUpdating your review
By
| Not you?
Advertising
Advertising
Advertising
Advertising