All Reader Reviews of...
1167 Madison Ave., New York, NY, 10028
nr. 86th St.
Spare yourself the ignominy
By mdnewyork on 4/10/2012
I was in the restaurant in March 2012 and was astounded by how bad the service was and how short-sighted the manager on duty was. Long story short, my husband and I took several friends out for a celebratory brunch. One of the servers poured water for a guest and somehow knocked over another guests glass of sparkling wine. Her solution for remedying the situation was to offer us another glass of sparkling wine (we had purchased a bottle). The wine got all over a guests suit jacket and another guest's sweater. When I got the bill we were charged for everything. There was no adjustment for the dry cleaning, the inconvenience, the embarrassment, nothing. When I asked for the manager he bartered up to being able to take $5 off of our bill because, he told me, in his neighborhood in Queens, dry-cleaning a men's suit cost $5. Seriously.
Great food, from appetizer to dessert
By Polina11 on 4/6/2012
Amazing food and not expensive. You can feel the chef's dedication. Nice ambiamce too. We'll be back!
Nice location, all the rest .... very bad
By jmfernan on 7/16/2011
Great location on the Upper East Side. We went there after a visit to the Guggenheim. We had a table upstairs. We knew the prices were expensive but, we hoped, according to the quality of the food. We prepared if not for a great lunch at least for a nice one. Regretfully this was not the case. The service was lousy. Definitely she didnt seem to like her job. The food .... well, first of all, its a very bad thing when you ask for a couple of menu items and they are not available. After waiting a lot of time finally we were served. The food was completely uninspiring. I know very well the Italian cuisine. My grandparents were Italians and Ive been in that beautiful country numberless times. Believe me, any common trattoria on any Italian place would be ashamed of food like that. La fettina di manzo could have been any other thing. No distinctive flavor. To add insult to a painful experience they pretended to add to my bill a twenty per cent gratuity in spite I hadnt instruct them to add the gratutiy. .And to make it more annoying they calculated the percentage not over the price but over the price plus taxes. Something very important: we didnt notice anyone who could be identified as a regular customer. Now I understand why. Jose Maria
Nice Upper East Italian
By rajbhatia76 on 5/13/2011
Good Wine...excellent Mozzarella...acceptable Spaghetti...nice ambiance...We will go back
By BudSlicker on 8/15/2008
The food was authentic and good. The server was professional, everything went right. The decor was not my style, but looked suitably Italian.
By vadimr on 6/23/2007
the decor was fine but the food embarassingly bad. i had a monkfish which was literally inedible. the substitute veal was almost as bad, the pasta average at best and the dessert about the same. never again
Elegant Upper East Sider
By elennas on 2/9/2003
A warm rustic feel with upscale italian cuisine, a helpful waitstaff and a nice wine list. Recommend.
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- Ana Gasteyer Loves a Good Mint Julep
- Starbucks New ‘Secret’ Drink Is a Ghastly Purple Nightmare
- World’s Worst Customer Injures Himself and 4 Others After Accidentally Firing His Gun at a Restaurant
- A Chef Explains Why He’s Suddenly Closing His Much-Loved Brooklyn Restaurant
- More Whole Foods Products Recalled Over Food-Safety Fears